AN INTRODUCTION TO
JUDAISM
NICHOLAS DE LANGE
University of Cambridge
PUBLISHED BY CAMBRIDGE UNIVERSITY PRESS (VIRTUAL PUBLISHING)
FOR AND ON BEHALF OF THE PRESS SYNDICATE OF THE UNIVERSITY OF
CAMBRIDGE
The Pitt Building, Trumpington Street, Cambridge CB2 IRP
40 West 20th Street, New York, NY 10011-4211, USA
477 Williamstown Road, Port Melbourne, VIC 3207, Australia
http://www.cambridge.org
© Nicholas de Lange 2000
This edition © Nicholas de Lange 2002
First published in printed format 2000
A catalogue record for the original printed book is available
from the British Library and from the Library of Congress
Original ISBN 0 521 46073 5 hardback
Original ISBN 0 521 46624 5 paperback
ISBN 0 511 00931 3 virtual (netLibrary Edition)
Contents
List of tables page x
List of illustrations xi
Preface xii
Chronology xiv
Map of the Jewish world in 1930 xvi
Map of the Jewish world in the 1990s xix
1 The Jews in the world 1
Who are the Jews? 1
Facts and figures 4
Natives or immigrants? 6
The Jews throughout the world 11
North America 11
Israel 15
Former Soviet Bloc countries 19
The European Union 21
Latin America 24
2 The Jewish people and its past 26
The Jewish nation 26
Enemies of the nation 33
Universalism 34
Assimilation 38
Individualism 40
Dispersion 41
Fragmentation 43
Genocide 43
3 Jewish books 45
The Bible 46
The prayer book 54
vii
The Talmud 56
The Shulhan Arukh 59
The Zohar 62
The Guide of the Perplexed 63
4 The Jewish religion 66
Traditional Judaism 66
The modernist reform 72
Radical alternatives 79
5 The family 84
The family as a unit 84
The Jewish home: space 89
The Jewish home: time 94
Rites of passage 107
6 The community 119
The Jewish community and how it works 119
The synagogue 125
The worship of the synagogue 127
Religious services 132
The cycle of the year 141
Moments of life 147
Other communal institutions 150
7 God and the Jewish people 155
The Jews and God 155
Sources of Jewish theology 160
The Bible 161
Midrash and Haggadah 164
The philosophers 166
Mystical approaches 169
The liturgy as a source of theology 172
God in the twentieth century 175
Hermann Cohen and his legacy 175
American Jewish theology 179
God and the Shoah 182
New issues 185
8 Objectives 187
Holiness 187
Obedience 190
viii Contents
Righteousness 194
Faith 196
Fear 197
Love 198
Bringing the Messiah 201
Repairing the world 206
Making peace 208
After life 209
9 Judaism and the future 213
External pressures 214
Demographic trends 215
Political aspects 217
Social aspects 219
Religious pluralism 220
Theological developments 223
Glossary 226
Further reading 238
Index 245
Preface
This book is intended for students of religion and others who seek an
introduction to Judaism. It is, as its title says, an introduction, and
nothing more. Some suggestions for further reading are given at the end.
I hope I have covered the main points, without becoming too embroiled
in details. I make no apology, however, for including a certain number
of quotations, from the prayer book and other sources, because Judaism
is a text-based religion, and to describe beliefs or rituals without giving
texts would be to offer a very faint glimpse.
The focus throughout is on contemporary Judaism. Insofar as I delve
into history, I do so through the eyes of the present. There are many
books which tell the story of the Jewish people, but what matters for this
introduction is the way that the past is perceived today and the ways that
it affects contemporary Judaism.
Judaism today is very fragmented, as I have tried to explain in the
book, and I have been careful to try to do justice to the different strands,
roughly in proportion to their numerical importance. If I have been less
than fair to secular Judaism that is because it does not yet seem to be as
articulate about itself as the other trends.
The main centres of Judaism today are in the United States and
Israel, and I have tried to reflect that importance in the book. However,
I have also referred to Judaism in Europe, not only before the Second
World War but today as well. Although the heyday of European Judaism
lies in the past, it cannot be written off.
I have designed the book so that the chapters can be read in any order,
and have deliberately included some repetition and cross-reference to
that end. However, I believe there is a certain logic in the order in which
the subject is presented, and recommend readers to follow the good
advice to ‘begin at the beginning’.
I acknowledge that my attempts to avoid sexist language may seem
half-hearted. I have aimed at a compromise between accuracy and
xii
elegance, and I know I have not always succeeded. It is hard to avoid
sexism completely when writing about Judaism, because it pervades the
sources. I do hope, though, that when I refer to God as ‘he’ I do not give
the impression that he has a sex or gender, and I sincerely hope I do not
use the word ‘Jew’ to mean ‘male Jew’.
Since this is an introduction, I have allowed myself to use a simplified
system of transliteration of Hebrew, which aims to give an approximation
of the pronunciation, rather than to permit words to be retranscribed
directly into the Hebrew alphabet. There are pitfalls: in
particular, the letter h is used for two Hebrew letters, one of which is a
harder sound than English h. Those readers who know some Hebrew
should have no difficulty in identifying the transliterated words, but for
added clarity I have inserted a more exact transcription of each word in
the Glossary.
I have incurred many debts while writing this book. I must thank the
Weizmann Institute, Rehovot, for offering me shelter while I was
researching the Israeli aspects, and the Oxford Centre for Hebrew and
Jewish Studies, Yarnton, for similar hospitality during the writing. I
derived terrestrial and intellectual nourishment from friends in both
places. I am grateful to my students in Cambridge and during a brief
stay at the Free University of Berlin for letting me test out my ideas on
them, and for trusting me with some of their own. Several friends have
offered advice and suggestions, for which I am duly grateful. Finally, my
warm thanks to my mother and to my children for not letting me stray
too far from reality, and for putting me right on lots of details.
Chronology
c. 1225 BCE Suggested date for Exodus of Israelites from Egypt
c. 1000 BCE Kingdom of David and Solomon
c. 950 BCE First Temple
722 BCE Sargon of Assyria conquers kingdom of Israel
586 BCE First Temple destroyed by Babylonians.
Babylonian exile. Beginning of eastern Diaspora
c. 520 BCE Second Temple
333–323 BCE Conquests of Alexander the Great
167 BCE Revolt of the Maccabees (Hasmoneans) against
Seleucid rule
164 BCE Hasmoneans capture Jerusalem. Hasmonean
dynasty
40–4 BCE Herod the Great king of Judaea
66–74 CE Great revolt; sack of Jerusalem by Romans (70 CE)
77–8 Flavius Josephus, Jewish War
115–17 Diaspora revolt
132–5 Bar Kokhba revolt
c. 220 Mishnah compiled
313 Emperor Constantine establishes tolerance of
Christianity: beginning of Christian dominance
c. 415 Jerusalem Talmud compiled
589 Beginning of the Geonic period; Babylonian
Talmud compiled
eighth century Rise of Karaism
1040–1105 Rashi
1096 Crusaders massacre Jews in Rhineland
1138–1204 Maimonides
c. 1275 Zohar compiled
1488 First printed Hebrew Bible
1492 Unbaptised Jews expelled from Spain
xiv
1534–72 Isaac Luria
1567 Shulhan Arukh published
1626–76 Shabbetai Tsvi
1654 Jews arrive in New Amsterdam
1698–1760 Baal Shem Tov, founder of Hasidism
1720–97 Elijah of Vilna (the ‘Vilna Gaon’)
1729–86 Moses Mendelssohn
1730 First public synagogue in New York
1791 Russian Pale of Settlement, Jews of France
emancipated
1817 First Reformed congregation in Hamburg
1873 Union of American Hebrew Congregations
from 1881 Pogroms in Russia; rise of antisemitism; migrations
1882–1903 First aliyah (Zionist immigration to Israel)
1885 Codification of Reform Judaism (Pittsburgh
Platform)
1886 Jewish Theological Seminary of America
1894–9 ‘Dreyfus Affair’ in France
1897 First Zionist Congress; founding of the Bund
(Jewish Workers’ Union)
1917 Emancipation in Russia following the Revolution;
Balfour Declaration
1920–48 Palestine under British Mandate
1925 Founding of Hebrew University of Jerusalem
1933–45 Nazi persecution; the Holocaust
1934 Birobidzhan proclaimed ‘Jewish Autonomous
Oblast’
1936 World Jewish Congress
1948 State of Israel founded
1967 Six Day War
1973 Yom Kippur War
CHAPTER ONE
The Jews in the world
WHO ARE THE JEWS?
The Jews are a scattered people. They live in many different countries,
and with one exception they are a numerically insignificant minority in
all of them. They belong to many different ethnic and linguistic groupings,
and many different cultural backgrounds. Even within a single
country these differences divide the Jewish communities from one
another. So what is it that binds them all together, and allows us to speak
in general terms about ‘the Jews’?
One superficially attractive but actually misleading answer is that they
are united by a common religion. There is a Jewish religion, and for very
many Jews it is the focus of their lives and a strong cement binding them
to other Jews. But it would be unrealistic to maintain that it is the Jewish
religion that unites the Jewish people. In fact the Jewish religion divides
the Jewish people today, perhaps almost as much as it divides Jews from
non-Jews. And even the most pious Jews would probably admit that it is
not their religion that defines them as Jews. They practise the Jewish
religion because they are Jews, not the other way around.
What is it then that makes a Jew a Jew? In today’s world, although
there are many ‘Jews by choice’, the overwhelming majority of Jews are
born into Jewish families. Most Jews would answer the question ‘why are
you a Jew?’ by saying ‘because I was born a Jew’.
This basic fact has important implications. It is sometimes said that
‘Judaism is not a proselytising religion’, meaning that Jews do not
actively seek to make converts to Judaism. Yet this formulation is fundamentally
misleading. Religious Jews are generally proud of their religion,
they are happy to explain it to non-Jews, they welcome and are even
flattered by the interest of outsiders. But since in their minds the religion
is somehow secondary to Jewish identity, it is not conversion to
Judaism that is the issue. In the relatively rare cases where a non-Jew does
1
opt to become a Jew, this is probably seen more in terms of joining a
people than subscribing to a faith. Indeed, as we shall see, even within
the Jewish religion belief itself occupies a somewhat secondary role.
Secondly, since the Jew’s sense of being a Jew springs primarily from
birth rather than from personal commitment, links to other Jews tend
also to be based on birth at least as much as on other factors. In other
words, the family tends to play a large part in the consciousness of Jews,
and the sense of family is very broad, encompassing the most distant
cousins.
This feeling also leads Jews to have a very intimate connection with
the past of the Jewish people. This connection is reinforced by established
religious maxims: all Jews should consider themselves as if they
personally were led out of Egyptian slavery by Moses, stood before God
at Mount Sinai and received the gift of the Torah. But it is a general,
spontaneous feeling nonetheless, by no means limited to religious Jews,
but shared by many who reject religious belief.
Nahum Goldmann, one of the outstanding Jewish leaders of the
twentieth century in the political rather than the religious sphere, wrote
these words in his memoirs about the Jew of the Lithuanian shtetl into
which he was born:
Not only did he live on an intimate family footing with his fellow Jews, who were
much more to him than members of the same race or religion; he experienced
a heartfelt closeness to the past of his people and to his God. When, as a child,
he learned about Moses, he saw him not as a mythical figure but as an important
though perhaps somewhat distant uncle. When, as a student at the rabbinical
academy, the yeshiva, he analysed Rabbi Akiba or Rabbi Judah, he was not
an antiquarian studying history so much as a man engaged in a living discussion
with an older, wiser relative.1
The whole Jewish past, not the past of a single family or a local Jewish
community, is in a sense part and parcel of the inner experience and
identity of every single Jew. And since Jews everywhere share this sense
of their history, they are all somehow part of the same huge, scattered
family.
Note that the expression ‘Jewish race’, which is still occasionally
encountered, is no longer appropriate. It came into use in a period when
the definition of ‘race’ was much looser than it is today, and when one
could speak, for instance, of the ‘English race’. Antisemitism, a
European political movement that gained many adherents from the
2 The Jews in the world
11 Nahum Goldmann, Memories (London, 1970), p. 6.
early 1880s on, attempted to isolate the Jews from the rest of society by
pretending that they were somehow genetically different from other
people. In some European countries, traumatised by recent dramatic
political and economic upheavals, the antisemites really did succeed in
driving a wedge between friends, neighbours, business associates.
(English-speaking countries have been largely immune to their efforts.)
But this view of Jewish identity was never realistic. There are no racial
characteristics that are shared by Jews and that distinguish them from
non-Jews, and a moment’s reflection will show that it would be extraordinary
if there were, because the boundaries of Jewish identity have
never been watertight. Throughout the recorded history of Europe individuals
have joined or left the Jewish communities, and sometimes whole
populations have changed their allegiance. Christianity at its inception
spread among Jews, and all the churches have devoted strenuous efforts
at different times to converting Jews, sometimes by force. In 1215 the
Fourth Lateran Council, wishing to segregate Jews from Christians,
ruled that they must wear special badges sewn to their clothing to distinguish
them: apparently 800 years ago it was considered that Jews and
Christians did not differ outwardly, and when the Nazi Germans in their
race laws of 1935 revived the Jewish badge they were implicitly
reaffirming the same belief, despite their strident racial mouthings. The
Nazi laws define a Jew as someone with at least one Jewish grandparent,
and this turned out to be a very unrealistic and haphazard definition in
a Germany where Jews and Christians had been intermarrying for generations.
Jewish law has its own definition of Jewish identity: one becomes a Jew
either by birth or by choice. In the former case the traditional law defines
the child of two Jewish parents or of a Jewish mother alone as a Jew, but
today the most liberal movements in Judaism consider the child of a
non-Jewish mother to be Jewish if the father is a Jew and the child has
been raised as a Jew. A non-Jew can become Jewish by applying to a
court (nowadays usually consisting of three rabbis, although traditionally
it was not necessary for any of the three to be rabbis), by studying,
and by undergoing the rituals of immersion in water and (in the case of
males only) circumcision. Some add that there must be a period of time
spent within a Jewish family or community, and a commitment to continue
to observe the commandments; but there is a contrary view, based
on ancient rabbinic opinion, that only minimal study is necessary if the
commitment is strong, because the process of learning will be more
effective if it is pursued within the community after acceptance.
Who are the Jews? 3
FACTS AND FIGURES
There are some thirteen million Jews in the world today, according to
the most reliable estimates.2 The Jewish people thus ranks among the
smaller scattered peoples, and Judaism has far fewer adherents than any
of the other main world religions.
Naturally it is impossible to obtain accurate statistics about the
numbers of Jews, because of the lack of agreement over how to define
a Jew. As has already been mentioned, definitions range from the very
strict and narrow definition of the traditional law, the so called ‘halakhic
definition’, to various much broader and vaguer definitions. Some
published statistics are based on people’s own definitions of themselves,
others are based on synagogue membership, and some are based on
pure speculation.
Many countries, including some of those with the largest Jewish populations
(notably the USA), do not keep official figures about the number
of Jews in the population. In the statistics from Israel, where ‘Jewish’ is
an officially recognised ‘nationality’, the figures are based on the halakhic
definition but are augmented by the non-Jewish members of ‘Jewish’
families, who sometimes outnumber the Jewish members.
Consequently all these statistics must be treated with reserve.3 Certain
broad facts, however, are indisputable. First, although Jews are scattered
among a very large number of countries, the vast majority are concentrated
in very few countries. Of the thirteen million Jews in the world
5.69 million (43.6%) are believed to live in the United States and 4.55
million (34.8%) in Israel. No other country approaches anywhere near
these figures: the next in rank is France with about half a million Jews.
Again, certain regions of the world are far more strongly represented
on a map of Jewish populations than others. Outside Israel, most Jews
live in North or South America, Europe, South Africa or Australia. In
the rest of Africa and Asia Jews are few and far between, and even within
individual countries the Jewish population tends to be concentrated in
specific regions or cities.
Another way of looking at the figures is in terms of the ratio of Jews
to the total population. Here, on a national basis, Israel is totally exceptional,
with Jews constituting just over 80% of the population, whereas
elsewhere only three countries (USA, Canada, and, among the smallest
communities, Gibraltar) count more than ten Jews per thousand of the
4 The Jews in the world
12 American Jewish Year Book 1997, p. 517. All the statistics given here are taken from that publication.
13 See ibid., pp. 515ff.
Facts and figures 5
Table 1.1. Countries with the largest Jewish populations, 1995a
Jewish % of population % of world
Rank Country population of country Jewish population
1 United States 5,690,000 22.14 43.6
2 Israel 4,549,500 80.97 34.8
3 France 4,525,000 20.90 24.0
4 Canada 4,362,000 21.22 22.8
5 Russia 4,360,000 20.25 22.8
6 United Kingdom 4,292,000 20.50 22.2
7 Argentina 4,206,000 20.59 21.6
8 Ukraine 4,180,000 20.35 21.4
9 Brazil 4,100,000 20.06 20.8
10 South Africa 4,295,000 20.22 20.7
11 Australia 4,292,000 20.50 20.7
Notes:
a Source: American Jewish Year Book 1997, p. 543.
population, and elsewhere the Jewish presence is numerically
insignificant.
The Jewish population is predominantly urban. This is in line with a
general trend in the world, but Jews are more liable to live in towns, and
particularly large conurbations, than the general population and, with
the exception of a few countries where deliberate efforts have been made
to settle them on the land, they rarely live in villages or isolated settlements.
This is not a new phenomenon, although before the Nazi genocide
it was common to see Jews living in villages or on rural estates and
even farming the land in eastern Europe. Today the overwhelming
majority of Jews live in large urban areas, and indeed more than half of
world Jewry lives in ten large metropolitan areas in the United States,
Israel and France.
Well over half the Jews in the world live in English-speaking countries,
and while it would be an exaggeration to say that all Jews speak or understand
English it is probably true that English is the most important
means of communication among Jews, and the largest number of books
and periodicals aimed at a Jewish readership are in English. Hebrew is
also an important language for Jews, both because it is the main official
language of Israel and because it is used either exclusively or side by side
with the local vernacular as a liturgical language in synagogues around
the world. As the language of the ancient scriptures, Hebrew is uniquely
associated with the Jews: although non-Jews sometimes study it, they
have only rarely used it as a medium of self-expression or communication.
Russian is also spoken or understood by a large minority of Jews.
In the past many Jews have spoken other languages, such as Arabic,
Spanish, German, Yiddish and French, and all these languages are still
spoken by some Jews today. Going back further in history an important
place was once held by Aramaic (a Semitic language closely related to
Hebrew) and Greek, but both these languages have very few Jewish
speakers today; in fact Aramaic is almost extinct as a spoken language,
although it still plays a part in Jewish worship and study.
NATIVES OR IMMIGRANTS ?
Paradoxically, although Jews justifiably consider themselves as one of the
oldest of peoples, a majority of Jews today would see themselves as newcomers
in the places where they live. Relatively few Jews live where their
grandparents or their great-grandparents were born. The story of the
Jewish people over the past century or more has been a story of dramatic
upheavals and displacements, and the map of the Jewish world has been
subject to constant and kaleidoscopic change.4
If we look back to the beginning of the nineteenth century we detect
a pattern of settlement that in its main outlines had not changed for cen-
6 The Jews in the world
14 See Nicholas de Lange, Atlas of the Jewish World (New York/Oxford, 1984).
Table 1.2. Metropolitan areas with the largest Jewish populations, 1995a
Rank Metropolitan area Jewish population
1 New York 1,917,000
2 Tel Aviv 1,878,000
3 Los Angeles 1,585,000
4 Jerusalem 1,470,000
5 Haifa 1,432,000
6 Miami 1,382,000
7 Philadelphia 1,314,000
8 Paris 1,310,000
9 Chicago 1,261,000
10 Boston 1,228,000
Note:
a Source: American Jewish Year Book 1997, p. 544.
turies. Most Jews lived either in the Christian countries of Europe or in
the Muslim lands centred on the Ottoman Empire and stretching from
Morocco in the west to Iran and Bukhara in the east. The Jews constituted
a prominent presence in the towns of North Africa, but already an
unprecedentedly dense concentration was building up on the territory
of what had been (until the recent partitions) Poland. The Jews of North
Africa and the Middle East mainly spoke Arabic or a distinctive form of
Spanish, whereas in central and eastern Europe the majority spoke a
form of German peculiar to the Jews and known locally as Yiddish
(meaning ‘Jewish’). Outside this main area of Jewish settlement there
were some small and fairly isolated outposts, either old ones, such as
those in India and China, or new ones, in the Dutch colonies, in the
United States and in Canada. Some Christian lands were deliberately
closed to Jewish settlement by the policy of their rulers: the most extensive
of these were Spain and Portugal and their considerable overseas
colonies, and the Russian Empire outside the frontiers of the former
Polish kingdom. Russia kept its Jews penned inside those old frontiers, in
what came to be known as the Pale of Settlement, which was to have an
enormous impact on Jewish history and culture.
Within the Pale of Settlement the Jewish population grew in the
course of the nineteenth century by leaps and bounds. In 1800 there
were little more than a million Jews in the territories of what had been
Poland, of whom three quarters lived under Russian rule; already Jews
outnumbered Christians in some places. By 1880 Europe contained
some seven million Jews, accounting for about 90% of the Jews in the
whole world, and most of them lived in the eastern half of the continent,
with about four million in the Pale of Settlement. Warsaw alone
counted more Jews than the whole of Britain or France. And although
there was a constant emigration westward into central and western
Europe, and on to North America and other parts of the New World,
the population of the Pale continued to grow dramatically. In the early
1880s, when to economic hardship was added anti-Jewish violence, the
trickle of emigration became a flood. Between 1881 and 1914 (when the
outbreak of war made travel difficult) some 2.75 million Jews left eastern
Europe, more than a third of all the Jews in the region and more than a
quarter of all the Jews in the world. Eighty-five percent of them settled
in the United States, where they constituted one of the largest immigrant
groups. Population movement on this scale was virtually unprecedented
in Jewish history, and its consequences were enormous.
These eastern European Jews had a very strong and cohesive culture,
Natives or immigrants? 7
the main elements of which originated in the Middle Ages in the
Rhineland, from where the Jews known as Ashkenazim began to migrate
eastwards from the thirteenth century. Being strictly separated from the
Christian population they maintained their own language (Yiddish) and
their own distinctive culture over the centuries, and when in modern
times they began to migrate westwards again they took their language
and culture with them. Although Yiddish is now a dwindling language
in terms of numbers of speakers, it can still be heard in many parts of
the world, particularly among the older generation, as can the distinctive
Ashkenazi pronunciation of Hebrew in the synagogue, although it
is rarer than it used to be.
When the Ashkenazim arrived in the cities of western Europe they
encountered Sephardim, Jews whose families came from Spain and
Portugal. So different were the religious customs and culture of the two
groups that they tended to form separate communities, with their own
synagogues, and intermarriage between the two was often frowned on.
Today the two types of synagogue still exist, but there is generally a more
open and friendly relationship. The term ‘Sephardi’ is properly reserved
for Jews of Iberian origin, but in Israel it is applied (rather disdainfully)
by Ashkenazim to any non-Ashkenazi Jews. Like the Ashkenazim,
Sephardim too migrated in considerable numbers from the Ottoman
Empire and Morocco at the end of the last and the beginning of the
present century, many of them settling in Spanish-speaking countries of
the New World.
In the present century the immigration just described continued, but
othermovementswere added. For example therewas massive emigration
from Germany, Austria and Czechoslovakia during the period of Nazi
ascendancy in the 1930s, and after the SecondWorldWarmany of the few
survivors of the Nazi genocide decided to leave Europe. During the 1950s,
as Arab nationalism swept through North Africa, there was an exodus of
Jews from the region, and whenever the authorities permitted it Jews also
left theCommunist countries of central and easternEurope. After the collapse
of Communism this trend became even more pronounced.
Meanwhile, for various political reasons, the countries of the Middle East,
with the exception of Israel, became almost emptied of Jews, and even in
India, where there was no specific political cause, a similar phenomenon
was observed. The result of all this movement was to reduce drastically
or even obliterate the oldest Jewishcommunities in theworld, and to swell
the newer ones. Recently some of the new communities, such as those in
southern Africa, have experienced an exodus too.
8 The Jews in the world
To take a few examples to illustrate all this movement, between 1930
and 1990 the Jewish population of Canada, Mexico and Sweden
doubled, that of Australia and Brazil trebled, while in other countries
such as Chile, Uruguay and Venezuela the Jews went from a barely
significant to a much more noticeable presence. On the other hand,
during the same period important European communities such as
Austria, the Baltic republics, Bulgaria, Byelorussia (Belarus),
Czechoslovakia, Greece, the Netherlands, Poland and Ukraine were
reduced to a miserable shadow of their former selves, and the ancient
Jewries of Aden, Afghanistan, Algeria, Egypt, India, Iraq, Libya,
Morocco, Syria, Tunisia and Yemen virtually disappeared.
The main countries of immigration, notably the United States and
Israel, have welcomed large numbers of Jewish immigrants from many
different countries. This inflow has had a marked effect on the character
of the Jewish communities within the various countries. In many,
Jewish communal and cultural life has been enormously strengthened.
However, massive immigration can alter the character of the community,
as happened for instance in London with the huge wave of immigration
from Russia between 1881 and the early years of the present
century, in France with the North African Jews who arrived in the 1950s,
or with the Russian Jews who came to Germany in the 1990s.
Israel has absorbed huge numbers of Jewish immigrants since its
inauguration in 1948 as a state guaranteeing a refuge to all Jews, against
a background of continuing economic and political difficulties.
(However, large numbers have emigrated from Israel at the same time,
to the great benefit of Hebrew teaching in other countries.) Great efforts
have been devoted to teaching the newcomers the Hebrew language and
helping them and their children to assimilate to the prevailing culture.
At the same time, there is a strong tendency for Jews to maintain and
express their distinctive identity, derived from their ethnic background
or the country from which they came. It is not so much a melting pot as
a fruit salad, particularly so far as the first generation of immigrants is
concerned, since their children tend to adapt to a more homogeneous
Israeli culture during their period of compulsory military service.
Israel holds a unique place in the affections of Jews around the world,
whether or not they consider it to be the holy land or the Jewish homeland
in a political sense. Israel itself views itself as different in kind from
the rest of the Jewish world, which is called in Hebrew galut or golah,
‘exile’. (In other languages Jews speak of ‘Diaspora’, from an old Greek
term meaning ‘dispersion’, ‘dissemination’.) To go to live in Israel is
Natives or immigrants? 9
termed in Hebrew aliyah, ‘ascent’, a term formerly reserved for journeying
to the holy city of Jerusalem. Conversely, to emigrate from Israel is
termed yeridah, ‘descent’, and is viewed negatively. Emissaries are sent
out from Israel to the communities of the Diaspora to inculcate a knowledge
and love of Israel and to encourage aliyah.
Although Jews tend to feel a strong bond with all other Jews around
the world, they are likely to be unaware of the international organisations
that bring together, represent, and to some extent protect and
sustain Jews in the different countries. There is a multiplicity of such
organisations, of which only a few can be mentioned here.
Six Jewish organisations have consultative status with the Economic
and Social Council of the United Nations. TheWorld Jewish Congress,
founded by Nahum Goldmann, whose name has already been mentioned,
first convened in Geneva in 1936. It is a voluntary association
of Jewish bodies, communities and organisations from around the
world, whose aim is ‘to assure the survival, and to foster the unity of the
Jewish people’. The International Council of Jewish Women, whose
name speaks for itself, was founded in 1912. The International Council
on Jewish Social and Welfare Services, the Coordinating Board of
Jewish Organisations and the Consultative Council of Jewish
Organisations are umbrella bodies representing different national and
international agencies. Finally, Agudas Israel World Organisations,
founded in 1912, is a traditional Orthodox body having as its aim ‘the
solution – in the spirit of the Torah – of problems which periodically
confront the Jewish people in Eretz Yisroel [the Land of Israel] and the
Diaspora’.
Of the other international organisations the most powerful is the
World Zionist Organisation, set up by the First Zionist Congress in 1897.
The moving spirit in the events leading up to the establishment of the
State of Israel in 1948, it continues to work for the strengthening of
Israel, encouraging aliyah, and promoting a distinctive (not necessarily
religious) Jewish culture. The World Union for Progressive Judaism
fosters the growth of Reform and Liberal Judaism, while the much more
recent World Council of Synagogues does the same for Conservative
Judaism, and the World Sephardi Federation deals with the religious,
cultural and social welfare of Sephardi congregations. The Maccabi
World Union is an amateur sporting association. There are many more
specialised associations, as well as organisations serving particular
groups of countries, such as the European Union or the British
Commonwealth. These multifarious organisations reflect the many and
10 The Jews in the world
varied currents within World Jewry, as well as the high value traditionally
placed upon communal service.
THE JEWS THROUGHOUT THE WORLD
North America
It is convenient to group the United States and Canada together, despite
their different histories and disparate size. Their six million Jews represent
the powerhouse and centre of gravity of the whole Jewish world
(with Israel providing something of a counterweight). They wield an
influence out of proportion to their numbers, both within the Jewish
world and beyond. Numerically not much more than 2% of the population,
the Jews are self-conscious and self-confident, have well-endowed
and well-organised institutions, and contain among their number some
influential individuals. They thus have a disproportionate impact politically,
religiously, culturally, and in terms of welfare aid and social issues
both on their own countries and on the wider Jewish world.
The experience of Jewish immigrants in the United States, often
arriving from countries of very limited opportunity for Jews if not outright
discrimination against them, has not set them apart greatly from
other immigrants, and has presented them with enormous opportunities
for self-fulfilment and advancement, even if, inevitably, they have had to
face serious hardships and challenges. Like other immigrant groups, the
Jews have had to adapt to very new circumstances and to the demands
of a cultural and social ‘melting pot’, which yet offers very distinct possibilities
and even pressures to maintain their own distinctive identity
and way of life. Jewish responses to these conflicting pressures have
ranged very widely, from total assimilation and abandonment of Jewish
identity at one extreme, passing through various modes of religious and
social accommodation, to the maintenance of a very traditional and separate
existence at the other.
Unlike the European countries from which most Jews came, the
United States accorded religious and other freedoms to its citizens from
its inception. The constitution of 1787 explicitly forbade religious tests
for public office (although some states retained them until much later),
and the Bill of Rights of 1791 guaranteed total freedom of religion. The
numbers of Jews affected by this momentous change were very small at
first, but they rose very quickly in the course of the nineteenth century,
from a few thousand to more than a quarter of a million by 1880. The
12 The Jews in the world
Table 1.3. American states with the largest Jewish populations, 1995a
Rank State Jewish population %of total population
1 New York 1,652,000 9.1
2 California 1,921,000 2.9
3 Florida 1,644,000 4.5
4 New Jersey 1,435,000 5.5
5 Pennsylvania 1,325,000 2.7
6 Massachusetts 1,268,000 4.4
7 Illinois 1,268,000 2.3
8 Maryland 1,212,000 4.2
Note:
a Source: American Jewish Year Book
period of really momentous immigration began after that date, with the
outbreak of pogroms in Russia, and by 1900 the Jewish population had
already quadrupled to one million; by 1910 it was estimated at over two
million, by 1914 at over three million, and in the middle of the 1920s at
four million. Whereas the pre-1880 immigrants came mainly from
central Europe, the newcomers originated predominantly in eastern
Europe, and were mostly very poor. Despite low wages, frequent unemployment
and disease they gradually improved their position by hard
work and self-help, and they were probably the most dramatically successful
of all the immigrant groups of the period.
Today immigration continues on a relatively small scale, mainly from
the former Soviet Union and Israel, helping to compensate for the very
low birthrate of the native Jewish population. Nearly half the Jews in the
US live in the north-east (as compared to less than one fifth of the
general population)
The American Jewish community is served by a large variety of
organisations with very different aims. One of the most venerable is the
American Jewish Committee, set up in 1906, at a time of growing antisemitism,
by members of the Jewish elite, whose concern was spiritual
and cultural as well as social and political. In its distinguished history of
involvement in campaigns against discrimination and prejudice it has
frequently met with opposition from other groups, particularly those of
a socialist or Zionist complexion, such as the American Jewish Congress,
a politically vocal and partisan organisation with a decidedly Zionist
orientation. At the head of the many Zionist organisations is the Zionist
Organization of America (founded 1897) and the women’s organisation,
12 The Jews in the world
Table 1.3. American states with the largest Jewish populations, 1995a
Rank State Jewish population %of total population
1 New York 1,652,000 9.1
2 California 1,921,000 2.9
3 Florida 1,644,000 4.5
4 New Jersey 1,435,000 5.5
5 Pennsylvania 1,325,000 2.7
6 Massachusetts 1,268,000 4.4
7 Illinois 1,268,000 2.3
8 Maryland 1,212,000 4.2
Note:
a Source: American Jewish Year Book 1997.
Hadassa (founded 1912). The B’nai B’rith, which began life in 1843 as a
fraternal order of Masonic type, is now a broadly based organisation,
particularly devoted to youth work, student counselling and combating
antisemitism. The United Jewish Appeal (founded 1939) channels funds
raised in a massive annual campaign into a wide range of deserving
causes. Its foremost beneficiary is Israel, which has received enormous
funds destined particularly for the absorption of immigrants, but help is
given to humanitarian projects in many countries. Two other important
organisations which continue the American Jewish tradition of rendering
practical assistance to the less fortunate are the Hebrew Immigrant
Aid Society (HIAS, founded 1880) and the American Jewish Joint
Distribution Committee (JDC, founded 1914). HIAS is a worldwide
migration agency, which does invaluable practical work in the resettlement
and rehabilitation of refugees, while the JDC works to relieve
hardship overseas, in Israel, North Africa, eastern Europe and elsewhere.
While both these organisations concentrate their efforts on Jews
they also help needy non-Jews.
American Judaism is as dynamic, as varied and as unique as American
Jewry. Its variety reflects the different waves of immigration and their
experiences of adapting themselves to a free and open society. The few
congregations of the Colonial period were Sephardi; then the ‘German’
immigrations of the nineteenth century brought Ashkenazi religious
leaders from central Europe, schooled in the dominant forms of Jewish
modernism (whether Orthodox or Reform). By 1880 there were over 200
congregations, and all but a handful were Reform. The huge immigration
from Russia brought Jews who, even if they were avowed secularists,
were accustomed to the old-style religion of the ghetto. Three
hundred new congregations had been founded by 1890, and they were
traditionalist in flavour. As the newcomers established themselves and
adopted an American way of life they developed their own style of
Orthodoxy, and meanwhile immigrants from the old Ottoman lands
brought a style of Sephardi religiosity far removed from that of the
established American Sephardi synagogues, so they too established congregations
of their own. Later refugees from Nazi Europe included
adherents of the more evolved forms of European Liberalism, as well as
communities of Hasidim with a highly developed folk tradition strongly
resistant to new external influences. The most recent waves of immigration,
from Israel and the former Soviet Union, stem from highly assimilated
societies in which religion has ceased to be a living force for most
Jews.
The Jews throughout the world 13
The differences between these various strands of Jewish religion will
be discussed in a later chapter. For the present it is important to note that
religious pluralism is a real feature of the Jewish community in America,
just as it is in the population as a whole. A survey of denominational preferences
in 1990 showed that very similar numbers of Jews were attracted
to Reform and Conservative Judaism (39% and 40%) respectively, while
6% expressed a preference for Orthodoxy. If those who are not
members of a synagogue are omitted, the figures are respectively 35%,
51% and 10%.5 These three movements have their own separate congregational
associations, rabbinical assemblies and rabbinic seminaries. A
later offshoot is Reconstructionism, which has its own institutions, and
in recent years there has been a proliferation of less formal, ‘alternative’
Jewish religious groups.
Canada’s political history is very different from that of the United
States, and Canadian Jews are more likely than those in the US to
think of themselves as Jews first and foremost. Anti-Zionism, which has
been quite strong at various times in the US, is all but unknown in
Canada.
The Jews of Canada were granted full citizen rights in 1832 (well
ahead of parallel developments in Britain), but their numbers at first
were relatively small. As in the US, it was immigration from Russia after
1880 that laid the real foundations of the large present-day community.6
Between 1881 and 1921 the Jewish population rose from 2,400 to over
126,000 (out of a total population of nearly nine million). Most of the
immigrants settled in Montreal and Toronto, where they tended to concentrate
in dense voluntary ghettos, but many travelled across the plains
to the growing towns of the west.Winnipeg soon established itself as the
third largest community, with 14,5000 Jews by 1921. Some agricultural
settlements were also established in Manitoba, Saskatchewan and
Alberta. Recent uncertainty about the future of Quebec has led to a
noticeable movement of English-speaking Jews from Montreal to
Ontario and as far away as Vancouver. A survey in 1991 showed that 21%
of the Jews in Montreal were Sephardi, and 70% of these gave French
as their mother tongue.
Canadian Judaism conforms more closely to the British than to the
American model, in that the large majority of synagogues are Orthodox
and only a small minority are Conservative or Reform. The synagogal
14 The Jews in the world
5 B. Lazerwitz et al., ‘A Study of Jewish Denominational Preferences: Summary Findings’, in
American Jewish Year Book 1997.
16 See Gerald Tulchinsky, Taking Root. The Origins of the Canadian Jewish Community (Toronto, 1992).
associations and rabbinic bodies follow the American pattern, and tend
to be associated with their American counterparts.
Like Britain, and unlike the USA, there is a single representative body,
the Canadian Jewish Congress (founded 1919), which concerns itself
with the welfare of the community and provides a unified voice for
Canadian Jewry. A distinctive feature of Canadian Jewry is the strong
emphasis on Jewish education. All communities of any size have at least
one Jewish day school, and these schools are very successful in attracting
pupils.
Israel
Israel is unique in the Jewish world, not only because the large majority
of its population is Jewish, but because it defines itself as a ‘Jewish State’.
This concept is novel and to a large extent experimental. The
Declaration of the State (1948) begins by stressing the place that the land
of Israel (Eretz Israel) has always occupied in the hearts and minds of
the Jewish people:
Eretz Israel was the birthplace of the Jewish people. Here their spiritual, religious
and political identity was shaped. Here they first attained to statehood,
created cultural values of national and universal significance and gave the world
the eternal Book of Books.
After being exiled from their land, the people kept faith with it throughout their
dispersion and never ceased to pray and hope for their return to it and for the
restoration in it of their political freedom.
The Declaration concludes:
We appeal to the Jewish people throughout the Diaspora to rally round the Jews
of Eretz Israel in the tasks of immigration and upbuilding and to stand by them
in the great struggle for the realisation of the age-old dream – the redemption
of Israel.7
In keeping with this grandiose vision, the Law of Return (1950)
begins: ‘Every Jew shall have the right to come to this country as an oleh
[immigrant].’
Thus, although Israel is a secular state with no established religion, Judaism has
a central and strong place within it, and the Jewish majority have certain rights
and privileges which are not shared by others.
The Jews throughout the world 15
17 For the text of the Declaration, the Law of Return and other key documents see Philip S.
Alexander, ed., Textual Sources for the Study of Judaism (Manchester, 1984), pp. 164ff. These texts can
also, at the time of writing, be found on the internet at http://www.israel.org/gov/laws.
The question of freedom of religion in Israel is a complex one, and
this is an area in which there are many tensions. In principle Jews are
free from any external constraint, and can practise their religion in
whatever way they see fit, indeed this is proclaimed as one of the advantages
of living in Israel over life in the Diaspora. In reality it has to be
said that many Jews, and particularly immigrants from western countries,
where non-Orthodox (Conservative, Reform and Liberal) forms of
Judaism predominate numerically, feel frustration at being deprived of
certain basic religious freedoms, hampered in the free exercise of their
religion, and denied access to the official structure of religious life in the
religious councils. This is due to the privileged position accorded to
Orthodoxy in Israel for political reasons. In the 1996 elections the three
religious political parties increased their representation from sixteen to
twenty-three seats, and controlled four ministries, including the Ministry
of the Interior. The religious parties at once presented a number of
demands, insisting on implementation of Orthodox law in such areas as
public observance of the Sabbath and forbidden foods, conversion to
Judaism (which as we have seen has a bearing on civil rights), homosexuality,
public decency and even archaeology. At the same time, the strong
place accorded to religion in general in Israeli public life weighs very
heavily upon those citizens who are not religious at all: for example,
there is no civil marriage or burial. Constant public controversy focuses
on all these issues.
Israel must be considered a country of Jewish immigration, in that the
overwhelming majority of Jews are from families that have immigrated
in the present century, even though, as we have already seen, Israel has
also experienced, and continues to experience, considerable Jewish emigration.
The original Jewish inhabitants before the first Zionist aliyah in
the 1880s were mainly pious Jews who lived in the holy cities of
Jerusalem, Hebron, Tiberias and Safed, keeping the flickering flame of
Judaism alive through the dark centuries of Muslim and Crusading
Christian rule. They are known as the ‘Old Yishuv [settlement]’, to distinguish
them from the ‘New Yishuv’ that followed. Their numbers were
very small. Zionist immigration, before and after the Balfour
Declaration of 1917 and the granting of the British Mandate by the
League of Nations in 1922, completely changed the nature of the Jewish
presence in the Land of Israel. The first census held in British Palestine,
in 1922, recorded 84,000 Jews, 11% of the total population, whereas in
1995 there were 4,549,500, forming 81% of the total. As with other countries
of immigration, successive waves have come from different coun-
16 The Jews in the world
tries. In the early part of this century the immigrants were mainly ideologically
committed Zionists from Russia who came ‘to build the country
and to be built by it’. They instituted the distinctive form of co-operative
agricultural settlements known as kibbutzim. Later they were joined
by Jews from Poland, Germany and other central European countries,
whose culture was rather different. The declaration of the state in 1948
was followed by the arrival of Holocaust survivors from displaced person
(DP) camps in Europe and later, in the 1950s, by massive immigration
from Arab lands. More recently there has been an airlift of Ethiopian
‘Falashas’, and a vast influx of Jews from the countries of the former
Soviet Union. Naturally all this immigration has given rise to massive
social problems, but what is particularly interesting for the observer is the
way that in the midst of a ‘melting pot’ groups successfully strive to
retain something of the flavour of the places from which they came,
including distinctive religious traditions.
All recognised religious institutions in Israel fall under the authority
of the Ministry for Religious Affairs. The Jewish religious establishment
consists of chief rabbis, state rabbis, religious councils and rabbinic
courts. Under a system inherited from the British and ultimately
from the Ottomans, there are two chief rabbis, one Ashkenazi and one
Sephardi. The main cities also have a dual chief rabbinate. The election
of the chief rabbis has caused repeated problems, and the dual
chief rabbinate has led to serious and sometimes apparently absurd
conflicts. The district rabbis and other local rabbis with official positions
are appointed, with the approval of the chief rabbinate, by local
religious councils, which also pay their stipends. The religious councils,
another heritage from the period of the British Mandate, are
effectively part of the structure of local government. They are
appointed jointly by the Ministry of Religious Affairs, the local authority
and the local rabbinate, and are totally under the influence of the
National Religious Party. Each rabbinic court (Bet Din) consists of three
judges (dayyanim) who are appointed formally by the president of the
state with the approval of both chief rabbis. The positions are well
paid and highly sought after. The Supreme Bet Din is headed by the
two national chief rabbis.
The chief rabbis, the dayyanim and other officially appointed rabbis
are state functionaries, and their authority derives from the state rather
than from the consent of the Jewish community or their personal powers
of spiritual leadership. A few chief rabbis have commanded widespread
respect, but they constitute the exception. By contrast other holders of
The Jews throughout the world 17
religious appointments have earned public ridicule and have contributed
to the very obvious alienation of many young Israelis from religion. In
contrast to most diaspora communities, the image of the rabbinate in
Israel tends to be a negative one, particularly among secular Jews. This
is not merely a matter of anticlerical prejudice. The state rabbis rarely
involve themselves in pastoral care or religious instruction, as their diaspora
counterparts do, and so are not treated with the respect and
affection accorded to some religious figures who are outside the state
system. The authority of the chief rabbis is not recognised by the more
extreme Orthodox groups or by the non-Orthodox movements.
The Reform and Conservative congregations are not recognised by
the Ministry for Religious Affairs and are not entitled to government
funds. The growth of non-Orthodox Judaism has been met by fierce
opposition from the Orthodox establishment, and at one point it was
seriously suggested that Reform and Conservative Judaism should
accept the status of non-Jewish religions, so as to qualify for state aid on
the same basis as Christianity and Islam. The growth of both movements
was slow at first, but they are now well established and increasingly
vocal, mainly thanks to immigration from the United States.
At the other extreme, various very traditional groupings have also
remained outside the state system. The Jews of the Old Yishuv, both
Sephardi and Ashkenazi, mostly held aloof from Zionism, and opposed
the creation of the Jewish state. Their ranks were swollen after the
Second World War by obsessively traditionalist immigrants from
Hungary. They live in voluntary segregation in their own close-knit
communities, mainly concentrated in the Mea Shearim quarter of
Jerusalem. There they maintain the lifestyle of the old ghetto, with their
own schools and yeshivot (Talmudic colleges). Their numbers are small,
and they would remain a quaint curiosity were it not for a streak of religious
zealotry which has often led to clashes with the secular powers.
Ambulances answering emergency calls on the Sabbath have been
pelted with stones, buses have been attacked by rioters complaining of
obscene advertisements, and there have been violent demonstrations
against sporting, social and cultural centres open to both sexes. Some of
these outbreaks are spontaneous, but often they are organised by the
Eda Haredit, an umbrella organisation of all the traditionalist groups,
and they tend to exacerbate the delicate co-existence between the
officially sanctioned religious authorities and the secular organisms of
the state.
18 The Jews in the world
Former Soviet Bloc countries
Eastern Europe was, as we have already seen, an area of dense Jewish
population before the First World War. It was also one of the most active
theatres of that war, in which European Jews suffered heavy damage
both as combatants and as civilian victims. The end of the war brought
a new beginning to the Jews of this troubled region. In Russia the
Revolution of February 1917 brought citizen rights to the Jews at last,
and the removal of the many disabilities from which they had suffered
under the autocratic monarchy. In the other countries of central and
eastern Europe the postwar peace treaties incorporated specific guarantees
of the Jews’ rights as a minority. The hope of progress was shortlived,
however, as the triumph of Bolshevism in Russia and later of
German state antisemitism made their condition much worse than it
had been before the war. While the Jews of the Soviet Union had some
hope of being spared the extermination policies of the Germans, they
suffered terrible privations during and after the Second World War,
while in the territories annexed or occupied by the Germans the Jews
were butchered with a brutality that still has the power to shock and
haunt us today. The imposition of Communist regimes in most of those
countries after the war condemned the survivors to further suffering,
both material and spiritual, and hardly anything now survives to remind
us of the teeming Jewish life and the glorious cultural achievements of
the region.
The sudden and unexpected collapse of the Communist regimes in
eastern Europe put an end to a system which, while it had been felt as
repressive by many Jews, and particularly by their religious leadership,
had also generally respected their ethnic integrity and protected them
from the worst effects of popular antisemitism. The restoration of
freedom of speech made life easier for Jews in some ways, but also gave
greater freedom to the Jews’ enemies. Emigration, which had proceeded
by fits and starts in response to volatile political opportunities, now
became a spate. According to the 1979 Soviet census, based on a national
definition of Jewish identity and on respondents’ own replies to enumerators’
questions, there were 1.81 million Jews in the Soviet Union, of
whom 700,000 were in the Russian Federation and 634,000 in Ukraine.
In 1995 according to the most reliable estimates there were only 360,000
Jews in Russia and 180,000 in Ukraine.
We have already seen the enormous growth of the Jewish population
The Jews throughout the world 19
in the Pale of Settlement in the course of the nineteenth and early twentieth
centuries. Their inferior status, poverty and overcrowding in the
Pale and a lack of opportunities for self-improvement created a feeling
of frustration and despair. In the period of reaction following the assassination
of Emperor Alexander II in 1881 the government adopted an
openly anti-Jewish policy, and there were savage pogroms that drove
many Jews to emigrate or to embrace revolutionary movements. The
Revolution of February 1917 was welcomed with enthusiasm. The provisional
government abolished all legal restrictions on Jews, and Zionist,
socialist and religious parties attracted a mass following. The triumph of
Bolshevism led, however, to the abolition of existing autonomous Jewish
institutions, and Jewish religion, in common with all religions, came
under attack. The Jews were treated as a nation, and when internal passports
were introduced in 1933 children of Jewish parents were classified
as being of Jewish nationality. Unlike other nations, however, the Jews
have no territory of their own in Russia, apart from Birobidzhan, an
‘Autonomous JewishOblast’ established in the far east in the 1920s,which
even at its height in the middle of the 1930s never achieved more than
23% Jews in its population. This is not the place to document the hardships
suffered by Jews as individuals and as a group under successive
Soviet governments, but what it is relevant to underline here is the virtually
total disappearance of religious and educational resources before the
introduction of new freedoms.With the abolition of the old restrictions,
and the facilitation of relations with organisations abroad, there has been
a striking revival in Jewish religious and cultural life in these countries.
New synagogues have been created, including some non-Orthodox ones,
and many educational initiatives have been implemented.
The formerly Communist countries of Europe which were within the
Soviet ambit have experienced a similar resurgence of Jewish life.
In no other country was the murderous effect of the Nazi German
genocide felt in a more dramatic form than in Poland, both because of
the numbers involved and because the killing machine, intended to rid
the whole world of Jews, was cynically centred by the Germans in this
country, where they calculated there was less likely to be humanitarian
protest or resistance than in Germany. Before the Second World War
there were more than three million Jews in Poland, nearly 10% of the
population, and in some places they formed a majority. At the liberation
barely 50,000 remained, and several hundred of these were subsequently
killed by their Christian neighbours. Emigration and assimilation
have since reduced the number of Jews to a few thousand.
20 The Jews in the world
About half of Hungary’s 450,000 Jews survived the war, and particularly
in the capital, Budapest, where the Germans did not have time to
implement their policy of deportation and extermination. Even under
the Communist regime, and despite the departure of many young Jews
when the borders were briefly opened in 1956, Hungary maintained an
active Jewish life, with many functioning synagogues and a rabbinic
seminary in Budapest that served not only Hungary but all the Soviet
Bloc. Exceptionally in a Europe where most religious Jews are nominally
Orthodox, in Hungary a form of Conservative Judaism, termed
‘Neolog’, is dominant. Today there are about 54,000 Jews in Hungary,
who constitute a little over half of 1% of the population of the country,
a little more than in Britain.
In Romania the losses of Jews in the war were less heavy than in most
other countries, leaving aside the territories (such as Bessarabia, the
Bukovina and Transylvania) that were added after the First World War.
In these latter regions the deportations were catastrophic, but in old
Romania, despite some terrible pogroms, the Jews survived more or less
intact, and some religious and communal life continued even under the
repressive Communist regime. The current Jewish population is around
14,000.
Czechoslovakia before the Second World War was home to some
360,000 Jewish inhabitants. Today there are about 2,200 in the Czech
Republic and 3,700 in Slovakia, who constitute an insignificant proportion
of the total population. The same is true of the 3,200 Jews of
Bulgaria, where most of the Jews survived the war, but emigrated soon
afterwards.
The European Union
Soon after the French Revolution, the French National Assembly began
to discuss the issue of emancipating the Jews from the medieval segregation
and subjection under which they lived. Resistance to emancipation
was strong, and a vote at the end of 1789 was lost by a narrow
margin. But the passion for freedom was too strong for the question to
be shrugged off, and a decree of enfranchisement was eventually passed
on 27 September 1791,8 inaugurating a new era in the history of the Jews.
The policy of segregating the Jews from the Christians, shutting them
away in ghettos behind high walls and gates that were locked at night,
The Jews throughout the world 21
18 This decree applied to Ashkenazim. The Sephardim of the south-west had demanded separate
treatment, and were granted equality of citizen rights in a decree of 28 January 1790.
forbidding them to meet or marry Christians or to have any authority or
power over them had been evolved gradually in the Christian states over
centuries: some of the rules can be traced back to the earliest Christian
rulers in the fourth century. The legislation was accompanied by what
we would now call a public relations campaign aimed at persuading
ordinary Christians that the Jews were not merely inferior by nature to
Christians, but also subhuman, demonic, wicked beings, whose aim was
to subvert society. As the position of the Jews in society was gradually
made more and more degraded at the behest of the Church, leaders of
Christian opinion tried to persuade the public that this was imposed by
God as a punishment. Some Christian states took such drastic steps as
baptising all the Jews by force (first decreed in Spain in 613) or expelling
them en masse (as happened in England in 1290). At the time of the
French Revolution Judaism was still outlawed in Spain, in consequence
of an edict imposing baptism on all those who refused to leave the
country on the completion of the Christian Reconquest in 1492, an
event which has left a permanent scar on the collective Jewish psyche.
Popular superstition had its roots in Christian teaching: a ‘cloven hoof
tax’ was levied in some French market towns on cattle and Jews, on
account of the old Christian claim that Jews were the children of the
devil. But popular antagonism was boosted by economic causes for
which the policy of exclusion from society was ultimately responsible.
Although in some respects the Christian policy towards the Jews can be
compared to the white South African racial policy of apartheid, in other
respects it was much more severe, and its legacy can still be felt today,
despite a change of attitude by some Christian churches, and, more
importantly, their loss of political power.
Generally speaking, the European states that emerged in the course
of the nineteenth century, even if they formally recognised the Christian
churches and accorded them some residual powers, tried to tame them
and bring them under the control of the state for the benefit of all citizens.
Religious minorities, the Jews included, tended to be treated in a
similar way. The rights of citizens as citizens were protected, and given
priority over the powers of the religious authorities. Thus in France
Napoleon I extended to the Jews a model of state regulation devised for
the Protestant minority. Under this system, which still exists, local consistories
send representatives to a central consistory which, among other
functions, maintains the chief rabbinate and the rabbinical seminary.
In France the reforms begun under the Revolution and consolidated
under the Empire were perpetuated under the restored Bourbon mon-
22 The Jews in the world
archy. Carried to neighbouring countries by Napoleon’s armies, they
were temporarily reversed in some, but after stormy ups and downs by
the end of the nineteenth century the Jewish minorities had been
granted equal civil rights in most of the present member states of the
European Union.
The process of emancipation, which was not initiated by the Jews but
by political reformers as part of a large-scale package of changes, necessitated
an uneasy adjustment on the part of the Jews themselves, which
will be explored further in the next chapter. Briefly, if emancipation
brought immeasurable advantages for Jews as individuals, it brought a
severe challenge to the rights and powers of the Jewish communities
(kehillot), which had previously enjoyed internal autonomy, and to the
rabbis, who found their powers curtailed as they were subordinated to
the state. Many of the uncertainties and conflicts still felt today in
Europe can be traced back to those momentous changes, which brought
the Jews out of their long Middle Ages and into the modern world.
A special word needs to be said here about Great Britain, which has
a rather distinctive history in terms of Jewish emancipation, as in so
many other respects.
The established position of the Church of England placed citizens
belonging to other Christian denominations, as well as Jews, under a
range of disabilities, including not only a bar on assuming civic office
but even on taking a university degree. In practice the most common disabilities
were gradually removed in the course of the nineteenth century,
although the Jews had to struggle for longer than the Catholics and
Protestant dissenters for equal rights.
Britain also differs from the other EU states in being the only one with
a significant Jewish population to have been spared the trauma of the
Nazi and Fascist racial legislation and deportations. (A few Jews were,
however, deported from the Channel Islands, which were occupied by
the Germans.) In all the other countries which had Jewish communities
of any size, the Jews were segregated from their neighbours, deprived of
their citizen rights, and eventually sent off to the German slave labour
and extermination camps. Many managed to escape before the borders
were closed, and some survived in hiding or in the camps, but the overall
effect of the Nazi war on the Jews was to devastate Jewish life in these
countries. After the end of the war the few who survived or returned,
often broken in body and spirit, and having lost their families, their
homes and their belongings, had to confront the neighbours who had
failed to support them in their hour of need, and who too often had
The Jews throughout the world 23
betrayed them for material advantage, from fear, or from religious
motives. Astonishingly, some semblance of organised Jewish life was
gradually pieced together, with help from agencies such as the JDC. The
current strength of Jewish life in some countries owes much to postwar
immigration. The Jewish community in France has benefited greatly
from an influx of Jews from newly independent Algeria, Tunisia and
Morocco, as well as from Egypt; Germany has received many Jews from
the former Soviet Union; and smaller numbers have arrived in Britain,
Italy, Belgium and Holland from former colonies, in Sweden from
Poland, in Spain from Morocco and South America, and throughout the
region from Israel.
The Jewish religion underwent a veritable reformation in the EU
countries in the course of the nineteenth century, a process that went
hand-in-hand with political emancipation and the reintegration of the
Jews into society. The dominant form of Judaism today throughout the
Union is modern Orthodoxy, which is constantly challenged by simultaneous
pressure from more radical reforming movements and from traditional
types of Judaism introduced by immigrants.
Latin America
During the centuries of Spanish and Portuguese rule Judaism was
officially banned in the South American colonies, and for much of the
time even Christian descendants of Jews were persecuted. Only the territories
that came under English, Dutch or French rule allowed the open
practice of Judaism, and some Sephardim today can trace their origins
to these colonies. With independence from Spain and Portugal the
Inquisition was abolished in the Latin colonies and freedom of religion
was gradually introduced, although Roman Catholicism has maintained
its dominance. The Jews were not specifically emancipated, but rather
benefited from legislation framed with Protestant minorities in mind.
Large-scale Jewish immigration began in the 1880s. From 1880 to 1914
130,000 Jews arrived in the region, most of whom settled in Argentina.
About 20% were Sephardim from North Africa, the Balkans and the
Ottoman Empire; the rest were Ashkenazim from eastern and central
Europe. Although most settled in the larger towns, there was a concerted
attempt to settle some in agricultural colonies set up by the Jewish
Colonization Association. Immigration continued at a rate of some
10,000 a year until 1940, when it was severely restricted, and since the
war there has been much less immigration and substantial emigration,
24 The Jews in the world
either from one country to another within the region or to the USA and
Israel. There are now reckoned to be some 380,000 Jews in Latin
America as a whole, the largest concentrations being in Argentina
(206,000), Brazil (100,000) and Mexico (40,000).
The different groups of Jewish immigrants have developed their own
institutions. The religious associations, centred on synagogues, still
reflect differences not only between Ashkenazim and Sephardim, but
also between Spanish- and Arabic-speaking Sephardim or between
Yiddish- and German-speaking Ashkenazim, or even bringing together
settlers from one particular region or town of Europe and the Middle
East. Beginning in the 1950s the American Conservative Movement has
established synagogues in several countries, and there has also been
some growth in American Reform Judaism.
This, then, in broad outline, is the shape of the Jewish world today. Of
the countries not mentioned, only South Africa and Australia have
significant Jewish populations (over 90,000 in each case). Elsewhere the
communities are very small, though some are quite lively. The world
Jewish population has not recovered from the catastrophe of the Nazi
genocide, and it seems to be declining, mainly because of demographic
factors, coupled with a strongly felt consensus opposed to making up the
losses through campaigning for new adherents. 1997.
x
CHAPTER TWO
The Jewish people and its past
THE JEWISH NATION
What binds the Jews together is not a creed but a history: a strong sense
of a common origin, a shared past and a shared destiny. Even if
Ashkenazim acknowledge a history set in Poland and Germany while
Sephardim together look to a past set in Spain and Portugal,
Ashkenazim and Sephardim look beyond to a more ancient shared experience
that makes them both part of a single people. Scattered though
this people is across the continents of the world, there is still a strong
feeling of unity, which has been strengthened by the ‘ingathering of
exiles’ in the State of Israel.
A comparison between Judaism and Christianity on this point highlights
the difference. Christianity is a faith, and the story of Christianity
is the story of that faith spreading from modest beginnings in the Middle
East through the efforts of missionaries to illumine the hearts of many
different peoples around the world, and all the Christian believers in the
different countries together constitute the great faith community that is
the Christian Church. The Jews are a people, and their story tells how,
from equally modest beginnings in the Middle East, the people grew,
mainly through natural increase, and became spread throughout the
world by voluntary or imposed migration. Whether this dispersion is a
good or bad thing is a matter of debate, but there is a strong belief that
at the end of history the scattered people will be reunited on the soil of
their ancestral land, the Land of Israel.
A key moment in the history of the Jewish people is the Roman conquest
of the holy city of Jerusalem in the year 70 CE. The Temple was
burned to the ground, and tens of thousands of Jews were killed or sold
into slavery. The Land of Israel became the Roman province of Judaea,
losing the last vestiges of its political autonomy. For Zionists, this was the
beginning of centuries of exile that only ended in 1948 with the declar-
26
ation of the State of Israel.1 For traditional and Orthodox Jews it was a
sign of divine displeasure at the sins of the people, and the following
statement was added to the synagogue liturgy at a point where the
solemn sacrifices ordained in the Torah are mentioned:
But because of our sins we have been exiled from our land and been removed
far away from our country, and are unable to perform our duties in your chosen
house, that great and holy House which bore your name, because of the hand
that was stretched forth against your sanctuary.2
Terrible though the hurban (destruction) was, it is not correct to see it
as the beginning of the Diaspora. That can be traced back at least as far
as the first hurban in 586 BCE, when the Temple was destroyed by the
Babylonians and many captives were led off to Babylon. Although
seventy years later the temple was rebuilt under Persian rule, the later
books of the Bible are deeply marked by the experience of exile, and
there is no doubt that the memory of the earlier hurban shaped (and continues
to shape) responses to the second hurban. In fact, in the aftermath
of the Roman destruction it was probably assumed that there would be
a return and rebuilding after a generation or two, just as had happened
the first time.
The concept of the nation that prevailed around the time of the
destruction of the Temple was rooted in the holy scriptures. Judaism was
already a text-based religion, and the caste of the scribes was entrusted
with the copying, studying and teaching of the old writings. In addition
to the books that make up the Bible of the Jews today, there were various
‘external books’, and all of them share more or less the same conception
of the Jews as a nation chosen by God and set apart from other nations
to be his special people.
Because you loved Abraham, you took him aside secretly one night and showed
him everything to the end of time, you made an everlasting pact with him and
promised you would never abandon his children. You gave him Isaac, and you
gave Isaac Jacob and Esau. You made Jacob your heir, but you hated Esau; so
Jacob became a great people. You led them out of Egypt and took them to
Mount Sinai. You split the sky and shook the earth, you made the world stand
still and the depths shudder, you threw the universe into a whirl, and your glory
The Jewish nation 27
11 ‘Nearly two thousand years have elapsed since, in an evil hour, after an heroic struggle, the glory
of our Temple vanished in fire and our kings and chieftains changed their crowns and diadems
for the chains of exile.’ Manifesto of Bilu, a Zionist pioneering movement, 1882. See P. R.
Mendes-Flohr and J. Reinharz, The Jew in the Modern World (New York/Oxford, 1980), p. 421.
12 The opening words of this prayer in Hebrew are mipnei hataeinu, and this phrase has become a
catch-phrase of Holocaust theology, with the idea that the Holocaust, like the destruction of the
Temple, was a punishment for the people’s sin.
passed through the four gates of fire, earthquake, storm and ice to give the
Torah to Jacob and teachings to the children of Israel.3
Whereas the contemporary Jewish historian Josephus interpreted
God’s promise to Abraham that he would be the ancestor of a great
nation who would subdue their enemies as referring to the remote past,
and the entry of the Israelite tribes into the land of Canaan,4 other
readers of the scriptures became convinced that the promises referred
to a future time. To Abraham’s daughter-in-law God had said:
Two nations (goyim) are in your womb
and two peoples (leumim) will divide from your belly;
One people shall be stronger than the other,
and the older shall be the servant of the younger. (Genesis 25:23)
Who were these two nations? The older one was Esau, the supposed
ancestor of the Romans, and the other one was Jacob, the ancestor of
the Jews. The meaning of the prophecy was that in some future time the
Jews would rule over the Romans, just as the Romans had ruled over the
Greeks.5
And to Jacob God said:
I am El Shaddai:
Be fruitful and multiply.
A nation and an assembly of nations shall come from you
and kings shall issue from your loins.
The land I have given to Abraham and Isaac I give to you
And to your descendants after you I give this land. (Genesis 35:11–12)
Biblical texts like this one are still influential today, particularly when
they are made familiar by the daily, weekly or annual rituals. The annual
festivals of Pesah (Passover), Shavuot (Pentecost) and Sukkot
(Tabernacles) all focus attention on events connected with the Exodus
from Egypt, when a ‘mixed multitude’ was moulded into a people, given
a code of law, and eventually acquired its own land. The Passover ritual
recites the biblical verse that encapsulates the rapid growth of the people
from tiny beginnings: ‘My father was an Aramean nomad: when he went
down to Egypt and settled there for a while he was few in number, but
28 The Jewish people and its past
13 Apocalypse of Ezra (also known as 2 Esdras or 4 Ezra) 3:14–19, translated by Nicholas de Lange
in Apocrypha: Jewish Literature of the Hellenistic Age (New York, 1978), p. 135. This work, preserved in
some Christian Bibles, disappeared from Jewish tradition, but gives an authentic glimpse of
Jewish attitudes in the aftermath of the destruction of the Temple.
14 E.g. Josephus, Jewish Antiquities 1.235.
15 See the texts cited in N. R. M. de Lange, ‘Jewish Attitudes to the Roman Empire’, in Imperialism
in the Ancient World, ed. P. D. A. Garnsey and C. R. Whittaker (Cambridge, 1978), pp. 255–81, esp.
pp. 269–71.
there he became a great nation, mighty and numerous’ (Deuteronomy
26:5). Similar references to the biblical idea of the nation as interpreted
by the rabbis can be found scattered throughout the prayer books of the
synagogue.
The concept of the nation described in these prayers was of great use
during the long years of subjection to the power of the Roman Empire
and its Christian and Muslim successors. It shaped the way that Jews
thought of themselves as both a political and a religious entity. They
were a single people, set apart from other nations by their special relationship
with God. And one day their God would rescue them from subjection
to the other nations, and give them real control of their own
destiny again. Even in times of persecution Jews could be buoyed up by
this confidence. It is astonishing how very few Jews, during fifteen centuries
of Christian rule during which every possible kind of inducement
or pressure was tried to make them convert to the ruling faith, abandoned
the Jewish people.
The Jewish communities during this period of ostensible powerlessness
were successful self-governing entities within a wider state, governed
by their own officials according to the Jews’ own laws. The Roman
Empire, down to the early fifth century, recognised the Patriarch of the
Jews as a state functionary; one observer described him as ‘hardly
different from a ruler of the nation’. The Greek word laos (people) was
used as a title of the local community as well as the people as a whole.6
The medieval community was inherently similar, with the rabbis administering
the Jewish law and settling disputes and lay leaders dealing with
finance and internal politics, and occasionally representing the community
in dealings with the higher authorities. And provided the peace was
kept and taxes were paid, the rulers of the state were content to allow
this system to continue.
Curiously, it was precisely when this pressure was removed because
the Church had lost most of its political power that Jews began to defect
in large numbers, and even embraced Christianity. A new definition of
the nation was gaining currency, that made the old concept seem obsolete
and repressive. The new-style nation was identified with the state,
and all citizens were members. It was an attractive doctrine, but some
Jews drew a different conclusion from the premisses: if the Greeks could
break away from the Ottoman Empire and have their own state, if
subject peoples like the Hungarians or the Czechs could struggle for
The Jewish nation 29
16 Examples in Margaret H.Williams, The Jews among the Greeks and Romans (London, 1998), pp. 30–1.
their national liberation, the Jews too could square the circle by declaring
themselves a nation in the modern sense, and fighting, by force if
need be, for their own state. This outlook was strongest in eastern
Europe, where civic disabilities continued for longest to weigh on the
Jews and where they were surrounded by peoples engaged in a struggle
for self-determination. Some of the leaders of the movement, such as
the rabbis Zvi Hirsch Kalischer (1795–1874) and Judah Alkalai
(1798–1878) and even a socialist like Moses Hess (1812–75) (dubbed by
Marx ‘the Communist rabbi’), were also influenced by the ancient
prophecies of the ingathering of the dispersed at the end of days.
However, the religious hope for messianic redemption and the return to
the land of Israel was gradually replaced by a secular vision of political
self-emancipation. Zionism has often been described as a form of ‘secularised
Messianism’, and there is some truth in this formula.
In nineteenth-century eastern Europe various groups sprang up
devoted to the promotion of national resettlement of the Jews in their
ancestral homeland, and the cultivation of the Hebrew language. These
groups were loosely joined together in the Hovevei Zion (Lovers of Zion)
movement, originally an outgrowth of the Hebrew Enlightenment
(Haskalah), which gained in strength through the political unrest caused
by the rise of antisemitism in Russia and outbreaks of violence against
Jews (the so-called pogroms). It was one of the leaders of this movement,
Nathan Birnbaum (1864–1937), who first coined the term ‘Zionism’.7
Leon (or Yehudah Leib) Pinsker (1821–91) gave a great boost to the
nationalist movement with his pamphlet Autoemanzipation (‘Self-emancipation’,
1882), written under the impact of the first pogroms. Pinsker
argued that antisemitism would not be eliminated by progress in society
at large towards greater liberalism. The emancipation of the Jews,
granted as a boon by others, did not lead to real equality. The Jews, as a
nation without a territory of their own, would always remain an oddity,
neither fully independent nor fully integrated. After the publication of
his pamphlet Pinsker was invited to join the Hovevei Zion and to lead the
movement, and he accepted, although he did not share their view that
Palestine was the only possible place where their vision could be realised.
A leading figure of the Hovevei Zion who made a lasting contribution
to the Jewish national movement through his writings was Ahad Ha-am
30 The Jewish people and its past
17 Birnbaum, a founder of the first nationalist Jewish students’ movement, Kadimah, and the first
German-language Jewish nationalist journal, Selbstemanzipation (Self-emancipation), eventually
turned against political Zionism and became the first secretary-general of the ultra-Orthodox,
anti-Zionist movement Agudas Yisroel.
(‘One of the People’, pen-name of Asher Ginsberg, 1858–1927). He is
remembered as an advocate of ‘cultural’ Zionism: critical of attempts to
revive a Jewish nation without first reviving its culture, he was insistent
on the need for an ethical content in such a revival (including sensitivity
to the existence of a large Arab presence in Palestine). Ahad Ha-am saw
Zion not as superseding the Diaspora but as enriching it culturally and
ethically. While rejecting traditional Jewish religion as archaic, he built
on its historical and moral heritage.
The Austrian journalist Theodor Herzl (1860–1904) has come to be
seen with good reason as the father of political Zionism, the movement
about which Ahad Ha-am expressed such acute criticisms. If Pinsker
was motivated by the shock of the first pogroms, in Herzl’s case it was
the conviction of the French soldier Captain Alfred Dreyfus on a false
charge of treason in 1895 that suddenly made him question the whole
process of emancipation. He at once set about writing the short text that
was to become the foundation document of political Zionism, Der
Judenstaat, known in English as The Jewish State.8 Herzl summarised the
main ideas of the book in the London Jewish Chronicle. He wrote:
We are one people – One People.We have honestly striven everywhere to merge
ourselves in the social life of surrounding communities, and to preserve the faith
of our fathers. It has not been permitted to us . . . We are one people – our
enemies have made us one in our despite, as repeatedly happens in history.
Distress binds us together, and thus united, we suddenly discover our strength.
Yes, we are strong enough to form a state, and a model state.9
In an age of nationalism, Herzl argued, the problem of Jewish identity
and the related problem of antisemitism demanded a radical political
solution: ‘Let the sovereignty be granted us over a portion of the
globe large enough to satisfy the rightful requirements of a nation; the
rest we shall manage for ourselves.’10 Herzl worked out his plan in considerable
detail, and presented it as a document for discussion and
implementation. Among the Hovevei Zion in Russia, who were already
well prepared for such a project, it met with an enthusiastic response, but
the response in the west was more guarded. Nevertheless, Herzl felt
sufficiently encouraged to convene an international congress to promote
his plan. The First Zionist Congress met at Basle in Switzerland in
The Jewish nation 31
18 As Steven Beller points out in his book Herzl (London, 1991), p. 35n., ‘the proper translation
should be The Jews’ State, or, perhaps better, The State of the Jews.’
19 From The Jewish Chronicle, 17 January 1896. See Mendes-Flohr and Reinharz, The Jew in the Modern
World, p. 423.
10 Theodor Herzl, The Jewish State, tr. Sylvie d’Avigdor (London 1896), 4th edn, London, 1946,
p. 28.
August 1897. The Congress adopted the Basle programme, committed
to the establishment of a national homeland for the Jews in Palestine,
recognised by international law. The Congress also set up the World
Zionist Organisation, with Herzl as its president. Herzl devoted the
remainder of his short life to building the WZO into an effective institution,
and promoting his vision by every means possible. Herzl’s efforts,
although they did not meet with great success in his lifetime, contributed
immensely to the Zionist movement, led by eastern European Jews,
which eventually established the State of Israel in 1948.
It is easy now to forget that only a minority even of Jews who favoured
a national solution to the ‘Jewish problem’ at the end of the nineteenth
century looked to Palestine, the ancestral Land of Israel, as the location
for a Jewish homeland. Pinsker was not alone in keeping an open mind
on this subject. Herzl himself in Der Judenstaat wondered whether
Palestine or Argentina should be chosen for the state. The Zionist movement
was torn apart by debate over the possibility of establishing a
homeland in Uganda.
The commonest form of Jewish nationalism in eastern Europe was a
cultural nationalism based on the Yiddish language and rooted in the
countries, particularly the Pale of Settlement, where most Jews lived.
The majority of Jews looked to socialism, with its universal vision of
human solidarity, to solve the problem of antisemitism, but even socialist
Jews tended to look for some sort of national status. Since there were
so many nationalities in Russia, surely the national identity of the Jews
could be officially recognised. In 1897 the Bund (Algemeyner Arbeter Bund
in Polyn un Rusland/General Jewish Workers’ Union in Poland and
Russia) was founded. The Bund sought full civil rights for the Jews in
Russia coupled with recognition of their ‘national-cultural autonomy’,
similar to other national groups. At first the question of securing
national rights for the Jews was hotly debated, but eventually it was
agreed as an aim. At the same time the Bund was resolutely opposed to
the out-and-out nationalism of the Zionists. The Fourth Party
Convention, in May 1901, declared that ‘Zionist propaganda inflames
nationalist feelings and hinders the development of class consciousness
among the Jewish proletariat’.11 Despite the hostility of the Zionists and
of both Jewish and non-Jewish socialists, the Bund attracted a large following,
and continued to be active politically in Poland down to the Nazi
occupation.
32 The Jewish people and its past
11 Mendes-Flohr and Reinharz, The Jew in the Modern World, p. 341.
The historian Simon Dubnow (1860–1941) was a proponent of
‘autonomism’, calling for Jewish communal autonomy and minority
rights to be recognised not only within a multinational Russian state but
throughout the world. This he felt, was the defining characteristic of
Jewish life among the nations down the ages, from the time of the
Talmudic rabbis in Roman Palestine and Babylonia through the Jewries
of medieval Europe to the Councils which had governed the Jewish
communities of Poland and Lithuania in the sixteenth and seventeenth
centuries. As a convinced secularist he looked to the synagogues of
Germany to convert themselves into secular national organisations, and
hoped that a similar type of structure would emerge in America, to
which large numbers of European Jews were emigrating. Dubnow came
to an original conception of Jewish national identity: the Jews, in
uniquely maintaining a sense of nationhood while emancipating themselves
from attachment to land or territory, represent the highest form of
nation ever to have evolved.
Dubnow was murdered by Nazis in Riga in 1941, and his writings are
little read now, but his ideas have been remarkably influential, mainly
indirectly through his direct influence on the Bundists and the so-called
Yiddishists, both of whom gave a high priority to preserving the national
and cultural integrity of the Jewish minority. This aim was written into
the peace treaties following the First World War, and in a more muted
way has formed the basis of the American Jewish compromise with the
‘melting pot’ idea. Dubnow’s vision of a semi-autonomous community
was not a viable proposition, but American Jews mostly accept it as axiomatic
that it is possible to be a hundred percent American and a
hundred percent Jewish. This idea was advanced by leading figures such
as Louis Brandeis (1856–1941) and Horace Kallen (1882–1974), the theorist
of cultural pluralism. Mordecai Kaplan (1881–1983) also made a
significant contribution, with his definition of Judaism as not a religion
but a civilisation. These three men were all Zionists (Brandeis was the
leader of American Zionism in his day), but they were also all actively
concerned for the maintenance of a distinctive Jewish identity within the
American ‘melting pot’.
ENEMIES OF THE NATION
The idea of the nation, which is such a strong cement binding Jews
together and giving them a common sense of purpose and destiny, has
many enemies, both within and without. These enemies are of different
Enemies of the nation 33
kinds: some aim to destroy the Jewish people itself, while others aim to
replace the idea of the nation by some alternative vision.
Universalism
In the second of these categories the most powerful enemy of the nation
is the concept of universalism. This is the outlook that values the human
race as a whole above any single one of its components, including the
Jewish people. Jewish universalism is no less deeply rooted than nationalism
in the sacred literature of the Jews. The fact that the Bible begins
with the creation of the world and humanity instead of the beginnings
of the people can be used as an illustration of the centrality of universalism
in Judaism. An old rabbinic teaching says: ‘The fact that [in the
Bible] one man was created [rather than separate founders of each
nation] teaches us that none of us can say to another: My father was
greater than your father.’12 The Bible is full of reminders to the Jews that
their God is the God of all the nations. ‘You Israelites, are you not just
like the Ethiopians to me, says the Lord? Just as I brought Israel out of
Egypt, did I not bring the Philistines out of Caphtor and the Arameans
out of Kir?’ (Amos 9:7). The biblical book that expresses this universal
vision most powerfully is Isaiah. There is only one God for all humankind,
and even if they do not recognise him now they will at a future
time:
I am the Lord, there is no other;
there is no god besides me.
I will strengthen you, although you have not known me,
so that men from the rising and the setting sun
may know that there is none but me. (45:6)
The nations shall march towards your [ Jerusalem’s] light
and their kings to your sunrise (60:3)
The same idea is expressed in the prayers. In the Ashkenazi liturgy the
strongly ‘nationalist’ Aleynu prayer, which ends every service, is immediately
followed and, so to speak, neutralised, by a more universal vision.
The first prayer says:
It is our duty to praise the Lord of all things, to magnify the Author of creation,
who has not made us like the nations of the lands, nor placed us like the families
of the world, who has not made their portion like theirs nor our destiny like
that of their multitude . . .
34 The Jewish people and its past
12 Mishnah, Sanhedrin 4:5.
And the second:
Therefore we hope in you, Lord our God, that we may soon behold your glorious
might, when you remove paganism from the earth and idolatry is uprooted,
when the world is set to rights under the kingdom of Shaddai and all mankind
call on your name, and all the wicked of the earth are turned towards you. All
the inhabitants of the world shall realise and know that it is to you that every
knee must bend and every tongue swear loyalty . . .
In this vision, God is the Lord of all humankind, even if his rule
cannot be said to be established until all people acknowledge him as
God. This is a rather different idea from the one found in many sources,
that the universal God chose the Jews to be his special people, and gave
them the commands contained in the Torah, but that he gave the non-
Jews a simplified law code with only seven laws in it. A gentile who obeys
all of these ‘laws of the sons of Noah’ is as ‘good’ as a Jew who obeys all
613 commands of the Torah.13
The eighteenth-century Enlightenment led to deep embarrassment
or impatience with Jewish particularism, and at that time the universalistic
side of Judaism was seen as a useful counterbalance to it. For the
German philosopher Moses Mendelssohn, for example, Judaism has
always consisted of three elements, namely general truths, historical
truths and commandments. The second and third categories belong to
the Jews as a nation, but the general truths are not revealed by God to
the Jews alone, but to all rational beings. ‘Their effect is as universal as
the salutary influence of the sun.’14
Mendelssohn and other Enlightenment thinkers insisted that Judaism
does not teach that only Jews can be saved. A later German philosopher,
Hermann Cohen (1842–1918), quoted with approval Maimonides’ statement
that the righteous from among the nations have a share in the
Coming Age. Cohen agreed with Mendelssohn in seeing no contradiction
between Judaism and the universal religion of reason. He believed
that humanity, in the modern era of the nation-state, was being drawn
ever closer together and developing towards overcoming national
differences, and he identified this universal vision with that of the biblical
prophets. He did not define the Jews as a ‘nation’ (a term he reserved
for the citizens of a nation-state) but a ‘nationality’, a purely ethnic
group held together by its religion. The Jews had long ago abandoned
Enemies of the nation 35
13 See the rabbinic passages collected in A Rabbinic Anthology, ed. C. G. Montefiore and H. Loewe,
reprinted with a Prolegomenon by Raphael Loewe (New York, 1974), pp. 556–65.
14 See the extract from Mendelssohn’s Jerusalem (1783) in Mendes-Flohr and Reinharz, The Jew in
the Modern World, p. 87.
their statehood, thus pointing towards the supra-national future of
mankind. As a Jew, Cohen felt at home in the culture of modern
Germany, which he felt to be close to the outlook of the prophets.
We may compare the statement of the so-called ‘Protest Rabbis’
who united in 1897 to oppose the holding of the first Zionist congress
on German soil, at Munich, forcing it to be held in Switzerland
instead:
We comprise a separate community solely in respect of religion.With regard to
nationality, we feel totally at one with our fellow Germans, and therefore we
strive towards the realisation of the spiritual and moral goals of our dear fatherland
with an enthusiasm equalling theirs . . .
Eighteen hundred years ago history made its decision regarding Jewish nationhood
through the dissolution of the Jewish state and the destruction of the
Temple.15
In other words, although the universal vision of the prophets is perfectly
compatible with the idea of the national destiny of the Jews (as it
was for the prophets themselves), once this national destiny came to be
identified in the modern period as a political one, culminating later in
the creation of a specifically Jewish nation-state, some universalists came
to see the two as standing in opposition to each other. This attitude is
often associated with Liberal Judaism, although it is not confined to it.
The ‘Protest Rabbis’ included both Liberal and Orthodox rabbis. The
father of German Orthodoxy, Samson Raphael Hirsch (1808–88), was
opposed to expressions of Jewish nationalism, and declared that ‘the
more the Jew is a Jew, the more universalist will his views and aspirations
be . . . the more joyfully will he seize every opportunity to give proof of
his mission as a Jew, the task of his Judaism, on new and untrodden
ground, the more joyfully will he devote himself to all true progress in
civilisation and culture.’16
Meanwhile in America the Reform rabbis assembled at Pittsburgh in
1885 issued a declaration along similar lines, firmly rejecting the claims
of nationalism:
We recognise in the modern era of universal culture of heart and intellect the
approach of the realization of Israel’s great Messianic hope for the establishment
of the kingdom of truth, justice and peace among all men. We consider
ourselves no longer a nation but a religious community, and therefore expect
neither a return to Palestine, nor a sacrificial worship under the administration
36 The Jewish people and its past
15 See Mendes-Flohr and Reinharz, The Jew in the Modern World, p. 427–8.
16 Judaism Eternal: Selected Essays from the Writings of Rabbi S. R. Hirsch, ed. and tr. I. Grunfeld (London,
1956), vol. 2, p. 236; see Mendes-Flohr and Reinharz, The Jew in the Modern World, p. 180.
of the sons of Aaron, nor the restoration of any of the laws concerning the
Jewish state.17
This is an implicit rejection of Zionism, as well as a rebuttal of any
imputation of dual loyalties. Both Reform and Orthodox Judaism were
associated for a long time with anti-Zionism, which was very widespread
among middle-class Jews in the West. Since the Holocaust this is no
longer the case: declared anti-Zionism is relatively rare, and limited to
marginal extreme groups – religious traditionalists on the one hand, who
judge it to be a secular usurpation of the divine prerogative, and socialist
universalists who object to its particularism.
Universalist opposition to Jewish nationalism took a different form at
the same period among Jewish socialists. In its most extreme form, it
asserted such a strong faith in the brotherhood of all people that Rosa
Luxemburg (1871–1919), for example, could write to a friend: ‘I have no
separate corner in my heart for the ghetto: I feel at home in the entire
world wherever there are clouds and birds and human tears.’18 Others
found it harder to abandon the idea of the nation entirely. Especially in
Russia, where anti-Jewish sentiment was strong even among socialists,
and where additionally the ignorance of Russian among the Jewish proletariat
constituted an obstacle to the dissemination of socialism, many
Jewish socialists felt that it was essential to combine the maintenance of
the idea of Jewish nationality with the pursuit of socialist goals. This
apparent paradox was viewed with disfavour by leading socialists. The
Bundist compromise between Zionism and socialist universalism was
opposed and ridiculed by Lenin, who stated that ‘Whoever, directly or
indirectly, presents the slogan of a Jewish “national culture” is (whatever
his good intentions may be) an enemy of the proletariat, a supporter of
the old and of the caste among the Jews, an accomplice of the rabbis and
the bourgeoisie.’19 Stalin, too, attacked the Bundists’ demands for
national autonomy, the protection of the Yiddish language and the
Jewish Sabbath, and claimed that the Jews could not be a nation since
they lacked a territory of their own and were not united economically.20
During the great purges he strove to eradicate every trace of a distinctive
Jewish identity, including Yiddish schools, publishing houses and
Enemies of the nation 37
17 Full text in Michael A. Meyer, Response to Modernity: A History of the Reform Movement in Judaism (New
York, 1988), p. 388; Mendes-Flohr and Reinharz, The Jew in the Modern World, pp. 371–2.
18 See Mendes-Flohr and Reinharz, The Jew in the Modern World, p. 225.
19 V. I. Lenin, Critical Remarks on the Jewish Question, 1913, quoted in Mendes-Flohr and Reinharz,
The Jew in the Modern World, pp. 344–5.
20 Joseph Stalin, Marxism and the National Question, quoted in Mendes-Flohr and Reinharz, The Jew
in the Modern World, pp. 346–8.
theatres. Even the memory of this cultural catastrophe has not prevented
some socialists of Jewish origin from perpetuating the assault on
Jewish particularism; although this attitude has some Jewish roots, it
cannot seriously be claimed as an expression of Jewish universalism,
which always maintained some sense of the distinctive existence of the
Jewish people.
Assimilation
The attitude just described exemplifies one of the most powerful forces
threatening the Jewish nation: assimilation.
The political emancipation of the Jews, as we have seen, was allied to
their integration within European society. As a small minority, they could
be absorbed and eventually disappear. Clearly this process represents a
danger not only to the idea of a Jewish nation but to the very existence
of the Jews as a separate entity. It quickly became a nightmare that continues
to haunt the Jewish leadership, both political and religious, today.
A good deal of the support enjoyed by Zionism in western Jewish communities
can be safely described to a feeling that it represents a bulwark
against assimilation, which is often identified with intermarriage, perceived
as the first step towards the extinction of the Jewish people.
Although the changing conditions of the modern world have
intensified the question of assimilation, however, the question itself is an
old one. The purpose of a good number of the commands in the Torah
is thought to be to separate and distance the Israelites from the culture
of the other nations among whom they lived. From the revolt of the
Maccabees on there is a polemic against Hellenising, or adopting Greek
customs (for example by neglecting the dietary laws, abandoning
circumcision, and adopting elements of idolatrous worship). So powerful
was the memory of this conflict that the term ‘Hellenising’ is still
sometimes used as a synonym for assimilation.21
Those Jews who welcomed the political emancipation while resisting
the threat of annihilation through assimilation were forced to redefine
Jewish identity, and in Western Europe the preferred model was that of
the religious minority. ‘We admit of no difference but that of worshipping
the Supreme Being’: this was the reply of the assembly of Jewish notables
convened by Napoleon in 1806 to the question how Jews are
required by their law to behave towards Frenchmen who are not their
38 The Jewish people and its past
21 See further Yaacov Shavit, Athens in Jerusalem. Classical Antiquity and Hellenism in the Making of the
Modern Secular Jew, tr. C. Naor and N. Werner (London and Portland, Oregon, 1997).
co-religionists.22 And indeed, the provisions instituted by Napoleon to
regulate the status of the Jews were similar to those regulating the
Protestant minority. As a religious minority, the Jews lost any political
rights or privileges they might have enjoyed, and received in exchange
freedom to practise their religion on the same basis as other citizens. In
some countries, such as France, religion was totally severed from the
state, and the rights and obligations of Jews became identical to those of
all other citizens. When, in March 1994, an election day fell on a Jewish
festival, some Jews demanded special arrangements to enable observant
Jews to vote, but the state refused to make an exception. The question of
excusing Jewish students from attending state schools on the Sabbath is
still an issue in France. In other countries, such as Britain, special rights
were eventually accorded to the Jews to enable them to participate in the
civic and political life of the country. For example, Jews (like other
minorities) are exempted from having to take unacceptable oaths or
from swearing on a Christian Bible.
The conflict between the concept of the Jewish nation and that of the
religious minority came to a head during the early days of Zionism,
which in Britain was largely a popular movement sustained by the recent
immigrants from Russia, while the more ‘anglicised’ establishment
rejected any hint of dual national loyalties. The two principal institutions
representing the latter group, the Board of Deputies and the
Anglo-Jewish Association, formed a common front, and on 24 May 1917
The Times newspaper published a joint letter from the presidents of the
two bodies containing the following statement, which expresses very
clearly this anti-national position:
Emancipated Jews in this country regard themselves primarily as a religious
community, and they have always based their claims to political equality with
their fellow-citizens of other creeds on this assumption and on its corollary –
that they have no separate national aspirations in a political sense. They hold
Judaism to be a religious system, with which their political status has no
concern, and they maintain that, as citizens of the countries in which they live,
they are fully and sincerely identified with the national spirit and interests of
those countries. 23
Some six months later the British Government issued the Balfour
Declaration, expressing support for the Zionist aim of establishing a
Enemies of the nation 39
22 For the complete reply see Mendes-Flohr and Reinharz, The Jew in the Modern World, pp. 116–21.
23 Letter to The Times from the presidents of the Board of Deputies and the Anglo-Jewish
Association, 24 May 1917. Text in Mendes-Flohr and Reinharz, The Jew in the Modern World,
p. 456.
national home for the Jewish people in Palestine, ‘it being clearly understood
that nothing shall be done which may prejudice the rights and
political status enjoyed by Jews in any other country’.24 The Balfour
Declaration recognises the very deep divisions that existed at the time
between Zionists and anti-nationalist Jews in Britain and elsewhere.
Although with the passing of time and the achievement of the Zionists’
aims anti-Zionism as such has become muted in the Jewish establishment
in the West, there is still a strong resistance to representing the Jews
as a nation in any way that implies that they are not loyal citizens of the
countries where they live.
Individualism
At the opposite end of the spectrum, an entirely different counterbalance
to the strong emphasis on the nation in classical Judaism is found
in the appeal to the individual. The idea of the nation requires that the
needs of the individual should be subordinated to those of society as a
whole. A striking example of this tension is found in the period of political
emancipation. It is embodied at its clearest in the celebrated words
of Count Stanislas de Clermont-Tonnerre, a revolutionary and supporter
of Jewish emancipation, to the French National Assembly during
the debate on the eligibility of the Jews for citizenship of France on 23
December 1789: ‘As a nation, the Jews should be denied everything; as
individuals, they should be granted everything.’25 In other words, the
benefits of emancipation were only available to Jews as individuals, on
condition they abandoned their claims for special treatment as a nation.
Very many Jews over the following two centuries have succumbed to this
temptation, despite the strenuous efforts of the rabbis and lay leaders of
the community to retain their allegiance.
This extreme example highlights the conflict between nation and
individual in its most acute form, but there is always a certain tension
between the individual’s sense of his or her own needs and the state’s
requirement of obedience. Plato attempted to harmonise the two by
arguing the true freedom for the individual can only be found within the
framework of the wise laws of the state, and his philosophy has exerted
a strong influence on Judaism. Biblical law was seen by many to be a
harsh burden imposed on the people of Israel (one ancient commentator
goes so far as to speak of God picking up Mount Sinai, which sym-
40 The Jewish people and its past
24 Full text ibid., p. 458. 25 Ibid., pp. 103–5.
bolises the divine legislation, and trapping the people underneath it), but
a clever preacher explained that the text had been misread: the Torah
does not say that the word of God was engraved (harut) on the tablets of
stone, but that freedom (herut) was on the tablets of stone (Exodus 32:16).
Obedience to the law is real freedom: the law of God, as interpreted by
rabbinic tradition, is not constraint but freedom, whereas what most
people take for freedom is actually a kind of slavery.26
This view has certainly been very strong in rabbinic Judaism, but it
had to face a keen challenge in the Middle Ages from the movement
called Karaism, which spread from Iraq throughout the Middle East
and eventually became strong in eastern Europe. The Karaites rejected
rabbinic tradition and urged a return to the direct reading of the Bible
(whence their name, which is derived from the verb kara, ‘read’, and
related to Hebrew mikra, ‘scripture’), and they attached importance to
communal consensus, but they also insisted on the judgment of the individual.
Another outlet for individualism is found in personal devotion, which
is attested in the Bible, particularly in the Book of Psalms, and throughout
the history of Judaism. It is particularly prominent in the mystical
tradition, in kabbalism and Hasidism.
Dispersion
A different kind of threat is posed to the nation by physical dispersion,
which has been a notable characteristic of the Jewish people for most of
its history. Being concentrated in a particular place might seem to be
necessary for the formation and preservation of a national identity,
although a moment’s reflection will yield several examples of nations
that are widely dispersed. In the case of the Jews wandering and dispersal
has come to seem almost an integral part of the people’s experience,
and it certainly bulks large in the way the Jewish people thinks of itself.
How can a nation survive such dispersion?
Close study of the rabbinic literature reveals two different attitudes to
dispersion, and there are traces of a dialectic between them. On the one
hand, ‘the dispersion of the ungodly is a benefit to them and a benefit
to the world, but the dispersion of the righteous is a misfortune to them
and a misfortune to the world’.27 On the other hand:
Enemies of the nation 41
26 Mishnah, Avot 6:2. See C. G. Montefiore and H. Loewe, A Rabbinic Anthology (reprint New York,
1974), p. 128. More generally on the subject of individualism see Louis Jacobs, Religion and the
Individual. A Jewish Perspective (Cambridge, 1992). 27 Mishnah, Sanhedrin 8:6.
Rabbi Eleazar said: God scattered Israel among the nations for the sole purpose
that they should gain many proselytes. Rabbi Hoshaya said: God did Israel a
favour in scattering them among the nations.28
The root meaning of ‘diaspora’ is to scatter seed (the English word
‘spore’ comes from the same root), so it can be understood in a positive
sense: just as a farmer scatters seed to bring in a richer harvest, so God
scattered the people so as to win proselytes. This attitude is meant to
counter the view that dispersion means exile and punishment, which has
been more prevalent, both in the Bible and in subsequent Jewish tradition.
Another motive for the praise of dispersion in the rabbinic literature
is the harshness of Roman rule. ‘God knew that Israel would be unable
to bear the cruelty of Edom [Rome], and so he exiled them to Babylon.’
In Babylon there is peace and prosperity, and the Jews are able to devote
themselves to the study of Torah. Furthermore, dispersion makes it less
likely that the people will be destroyed by persecution: if they disappear
in one place they will survive in another.29
A positive evaluation of diaspora existence can be found throughout
the ages, though it tends to be silenced by the far more numerous texts
that protest against exile and look forward in hope and prayer to the end
of the dispersion. The anti-Zionism of Liberal and Orthodox Judaism
has become more muted since the creation of the State of Israel, but the
theologian Ignaz Maybaum, who was a strong supporter of the idea of
a sacred Jewish mission to be a ‘light to the nations’, declared in a sermon
delivered in 1956:
The Zionist dogma of the end of the Diaspora has been thrown onto the dustheap
of history. The State of Israel is not the successor of the Diaspora, but it
is part and parcel of it. As a people of the Diaspora we can only exist as a
priestly nation, not as a political nation. The state of Israel is a dearly loved but
very vulnerable part of the Diaspora.30
In modern times the positive attitude to the Diaspora is associated
particularly with Simon Dubnow, who refused to see the Diaspora in a
negative light, but chose to interpret it instead as a natural and organic
development in Jewish history. Even when they ruled the Land of Israel,
42 The Jewish people and its past
28 Babylonian Talmud, Pesahim 87b.
29 See the texts cited in de Lange, ‘Jewish Attitudes to the Roman Empire’, pp. 276–81.
30 Ignaz Maybaum, The Faith of the Jewish Diaspora (London, 1962), p. 181; cf. his The Jewish Mission
(London, [1949]), p. 74. See also Nicholas de Lange, ‘Ignaz Maybaum and his Attitude to
Zionism’, in Tradition, Transition and Transmission, Jubilee Volume in Honor of Dr I. O. Lehmann, ed.
Brian D. Fox (Cincinnati, 1983), pp. 93–107.
he observed, the Jews chose to establish other centres, in Babylonia and
Egypt and eventually throughout the Greek world. They led the other
nations of the world in moving away from land and state towards a
supra-territorial existence in multiethnic communities.
Fragmentation
Fragmentation is a danger which is related to dispersion, but is different
from it. The unity of the Jewish people is something of a myth. Many
different elements go to make up the people.We have seen that Sephardi
and Ashkenazi synagogues exist side by side in some towns, because the
two communities do not feel that they have enough in common to
worship together, even though they would readily agree that they serve
the same God and are divided by no points of belief. But this is only the
tip of the iceberg. There are many different groups of Jews, defined by
ethnic or geographic origin, by religious denomination or simply by
social class. Even in the State of Israel, where enormous resources and
efforts have been devoted to forging a unified and homogeneous society,
the differences are all too visible. In some ways fragmentation is one of
the most acute dangers threatening the nation, particularly in the light
of the continuing debate about the definition of Jewish identity. Already
there have been painful disagreements about the Jewish status of such
groups as the Samaritans, the Karaites and the Ethiopian Jews, but the
large questions which remain to be faced in the future concern the disagreements
between the Reform and the Orthodox rabbinates about the
criteria for Jewish identity (particularly for proselytes and for those with
only one Jewish parent), and the mismatch in Israel between the
definitions of Jewish identity adopted by the state and the Orthodox rabbinate.
Genocide
One menace remains to be mentioned, and it is the most alarming of all
at the present juncture in history: elimination by force, or genocide. A
century ago it would have been hard to imagine that violence on such a
scale would be tolerated by the civilised world. Theodor Herzl, who was
so alert to the dangers of antisemitism that he devoted his life to the campaign
for a Jewish homeland, could not conceive that a really large-scale
antisemitic attack on the Jews was still possible. Even today it hardly
seems credible that a nation, supposedly among the most civilised in
Enemies of the nation 43
Europe, fell prey to such appalling collective madness. Yet the possibility
of genocide has always been present in the Jewish mind. It is mentioned
in the Bible, in the beginning of the book of Exodus and again
in the book of Esther, and it is found in the rabbinic literature and in the
liturgy, most prominently in the Passover Haggadah. Yet always it is tempered
by the belief that God intervenes to protect and save his people.
It is certainly possible to argue that this happened in the Nazi Holocaust,
that though six million were killed twice as many were saved; but that is
not an argument that is usually advanced, and the universal attitude to
the Holocaust is that it was an actual destruction, not a threat of destruction
that was averted. This attitude has very important consequences for
Jewish theology, which we shall look at in a future chapter. For the
moment we should note that European antisemitism, the Russian
pogroms and the Nazi policy of genocide have actually had the effect of
greatly strengthening attachment to the Jewish nation, as an ideal and as
a reality. Anti-Zionism has been virtually eliminated, and on the personal
level totally assimilated Jews have been brought to a realisation of
their Jewish identity: the realisation which dawned on Herzl in 1885 still
operates a century and more later.31
44 The Jewish people and its past
31 ‘I am a Jew who was born and raised in a Catholic country; I never had a religious upbringing;
my Jewish identity is largely the result of persecution,’ writes the Italian historian Carlo
Ginzburg in Occhiacci di Legno (Rome, 1998).
CHAPTER THREE
Jewish books
Jewish culture is profoundly textual. Literacy has always been highly
valued, and the written word enjoys a status that is all the stronger for
want of a strong continuous tradition of musical or visual art. The book
has been accorded a status little short of magical. At the heart of Jewish
worship is the display, reading and exposition of a written text, the
Torah. Public education has been accorded a high priority in Jewish
society down the ages, and the possession of books has been a feature of
Jewish homes even when it was rare in the surrounding culture.
Scholarship has been valued as a profession, and those who earn their
livelihood by other means have made time in their lives to pursue it,
often to a high standard. The scholars have been the custodians and
transmitters of Jewish culture throughout the centuries, and they are the
true heroes of Jewish history.
Most of what has been said may seem unremarkable in a society
shaped by Christianity, which has adopted or imitated the Jewish respect
for sacred texts; and indeed it could be argued that all the world’s religions
possess sacred scriptures of their own that stand at the core of religious
belief and practice. But in Jewish life the place of the book is
exceptionally elevated. Jews have tended to show an extraordinary
respect for books, and there is no hint of the chaining, censorship or even
burning of books as practised in the past by other religions. Respect for
the book as an object is enjoined in the codes of Jewish practice, and this
applies not only to sacred texts but to books of all kinds, which must not
be used for inappropriate purposes, or defaced, or even left lying open
or fallen on the ground. When a religious book is no longer fit for use it
is not thrown out but given burial with due honours in the cemetery. A
great rabbi of the fifteenth century banned from attending his lectures
a student who had refused to lend another student a book. With the
invention of printing Jewish books were among the first books to be
printed in large numbers, and in many places Hebrew presses were the
45
first printing presses to be set up. Even today, when the publishing and
reading of books is widespread, Jews are prominent among writers, publishers
and readers.
In the specific context of Jewish religion, arguments that in other
circles might hinge on an appeal to common sense or rational proof are
liable to resort to written authority. This tendency can be discerned
everywhere, from old texts like the Talmud to current debates on
medical ethics or politics. It is therefore necessary to open our study of
Jewish religion with an examination of the main written sources and an
assessment of their relative authority.
A Jewish home contains books. It is a commandment to study Torah
‘when you sit at home and when you walk abroad’ (Deuteronomy 6:7).
‘The Jewish book is the great instrument which helps to shape our life
according to this commandment. The Jewish book belongs to the Jewish
home. Without it the Jewish people cannot continue to exist.’1
What are the books we would expect to find in a Jewish home? Two
books hold pride of place, and are likely to be found in any Jewish home:
the Bible and the prayer book. Larger private libraries might well
contain the foundation work of rabbinic Judaism, the Talmud, some
manuals of halakhah (Jewish practice), particularly the Shulhan Arukh, and
perhaps (although it is less popular nowadays than in the past) that masterwork
of Jewish mysticism, the Zohar. Apart from these fundamental
books, and commentaries on them, we may find works of philosophy or
theology, such as Maimonides’ Guide of the Perplexed or modern books on
similar subjects. This chapter will be devoted to an account of each of
these types of work in order.
THE BIBLE
Pride of place belongs to the sacred scriptures, the oldest and most
highly esteemed of all Jewish books and in a sense the foundation document
upon which the whole of Judaism is built and to which it constantly
refers.
The term ‘Bible’ is borrowed from Christian usage, and the Jewish
Bible contains substantially the same texts as the Christian ‘Old
Testament’, although they are arranged differently. The existence of this
common ground between Jews and Christians has in the past facilitated
controversy and disputation, and today happily provides food for
46 Jewish books
11 Ignaz Maybaum, The Jewish Home (London, [1945]), p. 148.
friendly dialogue and shared study. In few other areas is the mutual
influence of these two religions more evident. Jews tend to refer to the
Bible in Hebrew, the original language, whereas the Christian biblical
tradition has been dominated by the Greek and Latin translations. But
the Christian Reformation espoused a return to the original text preserved
only by the Jews, and in the King James Bible the ‘Old Testament’
section was translated from the Hebrew, incorporating insights derived
from the Jewish tradition of interpretation. Jews, for their part, commonly
use Hebrew texts edited and printed by Christians, and have
adopted the Christian chapter divisions, while English-speaking Jews
have been comfortable reading the King James Version, recognising that
it is a faithful and accurate rendering of the original.
The Hebrew text used by Jews, as indeed by Christian scholars, is the
so-called Masoretic Text, which was given its present form by Aaron Ben
Asher in Israel in the tenth century. He was the last of a series of textual
scholars or Masoretes whose work extended over several centuries. The
Masoretic text of the Bible consists of a traditional consonantal text,
equipped with vowel signs to assist reading, and other signs that aid liturgical
cantillation and phrasing, together with an apparatus containing
textual variants, conjectural emendations, and notes on the way certain
letters are to be written and on the number of letters, words and verses
in each section. Most readers pay only scant attention to these last features,
but they respect Masoretic advice about certain preferred variants
(termed qeri) which are used in reading aloud even if a different form
(called ketiv), sanctified by tradition, is written in the text.
While a fair amount of information about the activity of the
Masoretes is available to scholarship through the study of medieval
manuscripts, until recent times the previous history of the Bible text
mainly had to be studied by means of comparing the Hebrew with the
translations that were made in earlier ages. However, the recovery of
older Hebrew manuscripts from the Cairo Genizah and the Judaean
Desert has made it possible to trace this prehistory in greater detail.
While the ancillary signs are the work of the Masoretes, it is now clear
that consonantal text they adopted goes right back to the time of the
Second Temple, even if we can also see that other forms of the text
existed side by side with it.
Originally the sacred books were written on parchment scrolls, and
this ancient form of book is still retained for the copies of the Torah used
in the synagogue. The scroll of Esther read at Purim, as well as mezuzot
and tefillin, are also handwritten on parchment. In time, however, for
The Bible 47
other purposes the scroll gave way to the codex, and the manuscript
codex was eventually replaced by the printed book. The Hebrew Bible
was first printed in its entirety at Soncino, near Mantua in northern
Italy, in 1488, and other editions soon followed. In 1516/17 the ‘Rabbinic
Bible’, that is a Hebrew Bible accompanied by an Aramaic translation
(Targum) and rabbinic commentaries, was printed in Venice by a
Christian printer, Daniel Bomberg. The Bible has been printed in
Hebrew many times since, by Jews and Christians, in various editions.
However, there is hardly any variation in the text contained in the
different editions, because they are all based ultimately on the Masoretic
Text. It is also possible to obtain a printed facsimile of the text as it is
written in a scroll, without punctuation or vowel points but with ornaments
on many of the letters; this is known as a Tikkun Sofrim, and is
useful for scribes and for practising the reading in the synagogue. The
Bible has been translated into virtually every language under the sun,
mainly by Christians but also by Jews. English translations are available,
some equipped with commentaries. Particularly popular editions are the
Torah edited by the British Chief Rabbi J. H. Hertz in the 1920s and
1930s (the original edition had a very fine and catholic commentary); the
American translation published by the Jewish Publication Society and
drawing on traditional and critical scholarship; and the ‘ArtScroll’
edition, with facing Hebrew and English text.2
The Christian term ‘Bible’ has been adopted into English-speaking
Jewish usage. In earlier Hebrew sources we find such designations as ‘the
books’ or ‘sacred books’, reminding us that the Bible is not a single work
but a library composed of many individual volumes. We also find the
expression ‘reading’ (miqra), a term that points to public reading. The
title that figures on modern editions is Tanakh, an acronym made up of
the initial letters of the three sections, Torah, Neviim and Ketuvim. This
abbreviation has been in use since the Middle Ages.
The three sections in question were compiled at successive stages. The
oldest section, Torah (‘guidance’ or ‘instruction’), is also the one that is
considered most sacred and authoritative. According to an old tradition
it was written by Moses, and this tradition is widely maintained today
among traditionalist Jews, although it is not supported by critical scholarship.
The Torah consists of five books, and for this reason the Hebrew
48 Jewish books
12 Pentateuch and Haftorahs. Hebrew Text, English Translation and Commentary, ed. J. H. Hertz (5 vols.,
Oxford/London, 1929–36; 1 vol. London, 1938; 2nd edn, 1 vol., London, 1978); The Holy
Scriptures: the New JPS Translation (Philadelphia, 1985); Tanach: the Torah, Prophets,Writings (ArtScroll
series), ed. Nosson Scherman (Brooklyn, 1996).
term humash (derived from the word for ‘five’) is used for a book containing
it. The Torah tells the early history of the people of Israel, from the
beginning of time to the death of Moses, and it also contains a large
body of laws and regulations that are the ultimate source of much of the
religious practice of Jews to this day. The whole Torah is read in synagogues
in the course of a year.
The second section, Neviim (‘prophets’), contains eight books, two of
which are divided into two parts each, while another consists of twelve
short works. These eight books tell the story of the people from the entry
into the Land of Canaan under Joshua to the Babylonian exile, and
contain the teachings of individual prophets. The authority of the
prophets is secondary to that of the Torah. Only short selections are
read out in synagogues, chosen to accompany the readings from the
Torah in synagogues.
The Ketuvim (‘scriptures’) constitute a miscellaneous compilation of
historical, poetic and other works. The largest component is the Book of
Psalms (Tehillim), itself divided into five books on the model of the Torah.
These poems are used in private and public devotion. The five scrolls
(Song of Songs, Ruth, Lamentations, Kohelet [Ecclesiastes] and Esther)
are read publicly on specific annual occasions, and the Book of Job, a
profound meditation on the problem of suffering, is also read among
Sephardim. The other books in this section are generally less studied and
carry less authority than the rest of the scriptures.
The authority of these various books, the most ancient works to have
come down to us in the Jewish tradition, is enormous. However, the
different books enjoy different kinds and levels of authority, and different
sectors of Jewry have different understandings of the claims the books
exert on Jews today. At the heart of the matter is a theological question:
whether the books are believed to emanate directly, so to speak, from the
‘mouth of God’. These are complicated questions, to which we shall
return in later chapters. For the present we should take note of the
strongest claim, shared to a greater or lesser extent by more or less the
whole of the Jewish tradition down to the beginning of the nineteenth
century and by all traditionalist and Orthodox authorities today, that the
five books of the Torah at least are a direct revelation from God given
to Moses and the people of Israel at Mount Sinai. This tenet has been
challenged in the past two centuries from a number of angles, historical,
philosophical and theological, but despite all the challenges the authority
of the Torah has remained very strong, and is invoked even by Jews
who reject any supernatural belief. In the modern period the appeal to the prophets has also become stronger, particularly among Reform and
socialist Jews, who admire the loud and confident cry for justice and
compassion for the less privileged members of society.
The reading of the biblical books is inseparable from their interpretation,
and the Jewish tradition of interpretation is embodied in a large
mass of writings going back to antiquity. Leaving aside various works
written by Jews in Greek and other languages and only preserved in the
Christian Church, which enable us to reconstruct many otherwise lost
interpretations, we have a vast literature, mainly written down in
Hebrew or Aramaic, of which the earliest layers are found within the
biblical books themselves, as later books rewrite or expound material
from earlier books. The Masoretic notes also embody a large amount of
interpretation, and much more interpretation can be found in the pages
of the Talmud, to which we shall return below. However, the main classical
rabbinic sources for the interpretation of the biblical books are
found in the bodies of writings known as Targum, Midrash and
Commentary (perush), each of which comprises an enormous mass of
written materials. Selections from these three categories of writing
accompany the Hebrew text in the Rabbinic Bible, which is the foundation
of serious biblical study among Jews, and in the annotated texts that
are used by congregants in synagogues for following the public reading.
Targum (‘translation’) is the name given to various translations of biblical
books into Aramaic, which was in ancient times the spoken language
of a vast area including the major Jewish centres of Babylonia and
the Land of Israel. Their origin is thought to be in synagogal practice,
when a vernacular translation was given in conjunction with the Hebrew
reading to help the public understand the Hebrew words. Some of the
Targums adhere very closely to the actual words of the Hebrew and to
what might be called their plain meaning, while others import a greater
or lesser amount of explanatory material and even mini-sermons, but all
of them represent an interpretation of what the Hebrew text means.
The best-known Targum is the one attributed to Onkelos (a shadowy
figure of whom nothing is known beyond his name, and indeed even that
is in doubt). Onkelos became the favourite Targum of the Torah for
eastern (Babylonian) Jews, while Jews in the west (Israel and associated
areas) used a variety of different translations.
Midrash (‘investigation’) is the name given collectively to a mass of
works compiled mainly in Israel between the third and eleventh centuries,
preserving excerpts from sermons and lectures and other comments
on the words of scripture. In the sixteenth century the so-called Midrash
Rabbah was published, presenting midrashic compilations on each of
the five books of the Torah and the five scrolls from the Ketuvim, and
these ten books have acquired a kind of canonical status. However, there
are many more midrashic texts surviving in whole or in part, and scholars
have hardly begun to grapple with the complexities presented by this
literature, which is one of the richest departments of the rabbinic tradition.
While the midrashic interpretations do not have explicit religious
authority, they are read with interest and cited with affection, and they
have exerted a strong influence on biblical commentary and preaching.
Biblical commentary in Hebrew arose in the course of the tenth
and eleventh centuries, replacing and at first building on the midrashic
The Bible 53
tradition and no doubt echoing trends in contemporary Arabic study of
the Qur’an and Greek study of the classics. The work of the Masoretes
fed an interest in the ‘plain’ meaning of scripture as opposed to the
flights of fancy that are characteristic of Midrash. Of the commentators
whose writings are still widely known and used the earliest is Rashi
(1040–1105), who lived and wrote in Troyes in Champagne, a region with
little previous history of Jewish scholarship. Rashi’s work is characterised
by brevity and clarity, and he avoids being drawn into technical
arguments. His commentary is thus remarkably accessible to anyone
who can read Hebrew (although he often explains difficult words in
French), and it is often the first port of call for serious Jewish readers in
search of guidance on the meaning of a biblical obscurity. It is printed
alongside the biblical text in rabbinic bibles and drawn on freely in annotated
editions, side by side with the commentaries of Abraham Ibn Ezra
(1089–1164) and David Kimhi (c. 1160–1235), who represent the Spanish
tradition characterised by an interest in the study of grammar and a
rationalist philosophical orientation. Many other commentaries survive
from the Middle Ages.
A new era in Jewish Bible commentary was inaugurated by Moses
Mendelssohn, the towering figure of the German Jewish Enlightenment
movement of the eighteenth century. Mendelssohn published in the
1780s his own translation of the Torah into German, accompanied by a
commentary in Hebrew (known as the Bi’ur) composed by a group of
scholars under his direction, and combining traditional comments with
the ideas of the Enlightenment. Subsequent Hebrew commentaries
have tended to follow in Mendelssohn’s footsteps in combining traditional
and modern insights. Meanwhile, with the rise of secular education
since the Enlightenment fewer Jews are at home in Hebrew, and so
editions of the Torah and other parts of the Bible used in the synagogue
are generally accompanied by notes drawing on older and more recent
commentaries.
THE PRAYER BOOK
After the Bible the best-known Jewish book is the prayer book. The
Hebrew prayers were first codified in the ninth century, but considerable
variation between different rites continued, and today with the burgeoning
of different religious tendencies and synagogal organisations the
diversity of prayer books has become even more marked. Recent prayer
books of the Liberal wing of Judaism tend to incorporate not only
54 Jewish books
English translations (first introduced in the late eighteenth century) but
also additional English materials of a meditative, instructional or
explanatory character.
Whereas the earliest manuscript prayer books tended to encompass
prayers for every occasion, nowadays a clear distinction is drawn
between the Siddur, which contains daily and Sabbath prayers, and the
Mahzor, containing festival prayers, often with separate volumes for the
various festivals. Prayer books are provided in synagogues, but are also
commonly found in Jewish homes. Most homes also possess the prayer
book for the home celebration of Passover, named the Haggadah.
The origins of Jewish liturgy are obscure in the extreme. The earliest
influential codifications, both combining Siddur and Mahzor, are the
Seder Rav Amram, compiled in Babylonia in the ninth century, and the
Mahzor Vitry, made in northern France in the eleventh. Many other documentary
sources survive from this period, testifying to the diversity of
local rites. Over a certain space of time, the Babylonian rite gradually
replaced the Palestinian and other rites virtually everywhere (just as the
Babylonian Talmud replaced the Palestinian Talmud). The Land of
Israel resumed a central role again, however, in the sixteenth century,
with the kabbalistic school of Isaac Luria in Safed. Luria’s distinctive
prayer book, the Minhag Ari, was widely diffused, and became particularly
popular among the Hasidim. Although the introduction of printing
led to the diappearance of many individual rites, there is still great
diversity in prayer books, which has increased to some extent in the past
century. In Britain an important milestone in the standardisation of
worship was the publication in 1890 of the Authorised Daily Prayer Book of
the United Hebrew Congregations of the British Empire, commonly known as
‘Singer’s Prayer Book’ after its editor, Simeon Singer. Singer’s Prayer
Book has been issued in a succession of revised editions, and is still very
widely used in British Orthodox synagogues and is found in many
homes.3 The prayer books for the festivals in several matching volumes,
popularly known as the ‘Routledge Mahzor’, are also very popular.
Some Orthodox Jews, however, prefer to use other editions brought in
from abroad, particularly from Israel and the United States. The
American ‘ArtScroll’ editions are becoming increasingly popular; they
adopt a more traditional approach to the service, and are equipped
with helpful notes and explanations. Meanwhile the Sephardi, Reform
and Liberal congregations have issued their own prayer books, as have
The prayer book 55
13 The latest edition was published by Cambridge University Press in 1990.
the Conservative, Reform and Reconstructionist movements in
America.
The prayer books have to be considered as a main source of religious
ideas, which by dint of repetition are ingrained in the minds of worshippers.
In the absence of definitive creeds or catechetical education, they
constitute the only induction many Jews ever receive in the theological
beliefs of their faith. However, this is a largely unconscious process, and
prayer books are not usually referred to or cited to settle disputes about
matters of doctrine.
THE TALMUD
The foundation text of rabbinic Judaism is the Talmud, by which is normally
meant the Babylonian Talmud (named from its place of compilation)
or Talmud Bavli. There is also a Jerusalem Talmud (Talmud
Yerushalmi), which was at one time dominant in the Byzantine Empire,
but for historical reasons it was eclipsed by its eastern rival, although
there has been a revival of interest in it in modern Israel.
The Talmud is a huge work, which occupies many volumes.
Consequently it is not found in many Jewish homes. Moreover, it is
written in a mixture of Hebrew and Aramaic, in a distinctive and
difficult style, and even people who have learned to read biblical
Hebrew fluently are unable to read it without extensive further training.
It is therefore the domain of rabbis and scholars, and is not really
accessible to the wider Jewish public. Nevertheless its authority in traditional
rabbinic Judaism is enormous, even outstripping that of the Bible
in some respects. This authority has not gone unchallenged. In the
Middle Ages the Karaite movement denied the authority of the
Talmud, and in the early nineteenth century the reformer Abraham
Geiger declared that it was an ‘ungainly colossus’ that must be toppled.
Study of the Talmud does, however, figure on the syllabuses of contemporary
Reform rabbinical colleges, even if the laws and regulations
which make up a large part of its subject matter, and have a great
influence on Orthodox practice, are not considered binding in Reform
Judaism.
The Talmud consists of two intertwined text: the Mishnah, a relatively
short work composed in Hebrew in Israel in the early phase of rabbinic
Judaism (the period of the teachers known as Tannaim), and the
Gemara, a much longer work, mainly in Aramaic, presenting the discussions
of the later rabbis or Amoraim. Some tractates of the Mishnah,
56 Jewish books
however, have no Gemara. Both the Mishnah and the Talmud as a
whole are sometimes referred to as codes of law, but this designation is
doubly misleading, since there is a great deal of material in both which
is of a non-legal nature, and since unlike a lawcode they frequently
report inconsistent or contradictory rulings side by side without deciding
between them. In fact the Gemara consists largely of detailed and
strenuously argued disagreements on the meaning and validity of both
Mishnaic and biblical laws, in which as much attention is paid to the
arguments that are eventually overruled as to those that carry the day.
For this reason the close study of the Gemara has been regarded as an
excellent mental training. Many commentaries have been written on the
Talmud in whole or part, of which the most famous is that of Rashi.
Three of Rashi’s grandsons were among the Tosafists, ‘supplementers’
of Rashi’s work who lived in France and Germany in the twelfth and
thirteenth centuries. Their scholia, the Tosafot, are generally printed
alongside Rashi’s commentary.
Current editions of the Talmud are based on the text published by the
Romm publishing house in Vilna in 1880–6, which in turn was based on
the first printed edition, printed by Daniel Bomberg in Venice in 1520–3.
In these editions the text is accompanied by Rashi’s commentary and by
the Tosafot. An English translation of the whole Talmud was published
by the Soncino publishing house in London in thirty-five volumes in
1935–52 (reprinted in eighteen volumes in 1961), and a bilingual edition
with helpful notes is being produced under the direction of the Israeli
rabbi Adin Steinsaltz (New York 1989– ). An excellent English translation
of the Mishnah was made by the Anglican scholar Herbert Danby
and published in Oxford in 1933.
The tractates of the Talmud
FIRS T ORDER: Zeraim (‘Seeds’)
Berakhot (‘Benedictions’)
Peah (‘Gleanings’)
Demai (‘Produce Not Certainly Tithed’)
Kilaim (‘Mixtures’)
Sheviit (‘The Seventh Year’)
Terumot (‘Heave Offerings’)
Maaserot (‘Tithes’)
Maaser Sheni (‘Second Tithe’)
Hallah (‘Dough Offering’)
The Talmud 57
Orlah (‘Fruit of Young Trees’)
Bikkurim (‘Firstfruits’)
SECOND ORDER: Moed (‘Set Feasts’)
Shabbat (‘Sabbath’)
Erubin (‘Fusion of Sabbath Limits’)
Pesahim (‘Passover’)
Shekalim (‘Shekel Dues’)
Yoma (‘Day of Atonement’)
Sukkah (‘Tabernacles’)
Tom Tov or Betsah (‘Festival Days’)
Rosh ha-Shanah (‘New Year’)
Taanit (‘Fast Days’)
Megillah (‘Scroll of Esther’)
Moed Katan (‘Intermediate Days’)
Hagigah (‘Festal Offering’)
THIRD ORDER: Nashim (‘Women’)
Yevamot (‘Sisters-in-law’)
Ketubot (‘Marriage Deeds’)
Nedarim (‘Vows’)
Nazir (‘Nazirite Vow’)
Sotah (‘Suspected Adulteress’)
Gittin (‘Bills of Divorce’)
Kiddushin (‘Betrothal’)
FOURTH ORDER: Nezikin (‘Damages’)
Bava Kamma (‘The First Gate’)
Bava Metzia (‘The Middle Gate’)
Bava Betra (‘The Last Gate’)
Sanhedrin (‘Lawcourts’)
Makkot (‘Lashes’)
Shevuot (‘Oaths’)
Eduyot (‘Testimonies’)
Avodah Zarah (‘Idolatry’)
Avot (‘Sayings of the Fathers’)
Horayot (‘Instructions’)
FIFTH ORDER: Kodashim (‘Holy Things’)
Zevahim (‘Animal Offerings’)
58 Jewish books
Menahot (‘Meal Offerings’)
Hullin (‘Animals Killed for Food’)
Bekhorot (‘Firstlings’)
Arakhin (‘Vows for Valuation’)
Temurah (‘Substituted Offering’)
Keritot (‘Extirpation’)
Meilah (‘Sacrilege’)
Tamid (‘Daily Whole-offering’)
Middot (‘Dimensions’)
Kinnim (‘Bird Offerings’)
SIXTH ORDER: Tohorot (‘Purities’)
Kelim (‘Vessels’)
Oholot (‘Tents’)
Negaim (‘Leprosy-signs’)
Parah (‘The Red Heifer’)
Tohorot (‘Purities’)
Mikvaot (‘Ritual Baths’)
Niddah (‘Menstrual Impurity’)
Makhshirin (‘Rendering Susceptible [to ritual impurity]’)
Tevul Yom (‘He who has Bathed during the Day’)
Yadaim (‘Hands’)
Uktsin (‘Stalks’)
THE SHULHAN ARUKH
Although the Torah and the Talmud are major sources of halakhah (Jewish
practice), their prescriptions cannot be applied today without recourse to
the enormous subsequent tradition that has refined them and adjusted
them to changing conditions and perceptions. Much of this tradition is
embodied in a succession of codes produced throughout the course of the
Middle Ages, and in collections of responsa–authoritative rabbinic replies
to questions, usually of a practical nature. The codes facilitated access to
the Talmudic sources and resolved contradictions and uncertainties,
while the responsa, in applying the old laws to actual situations in everchanging
circumstances, constantly renewed and extended them.
Observant Jews today seeking the answer to a halakhic question are
likely to refer to the Shulhan Arukh (‘Spread Table’), the latest and most
widely accepted of the authoritative codes of halakhah, or to one of the
various abridgments of it that have been made for popular use.
The Shulhan Arukh, first published in 1565, was compiled by Joseph
Caro (1488–1575), an exile from Spain who settled in Safed, now in
northern Israel. It is a digest of Caro’s larger work, the Beit Yosef (‘House
of Joseph’), which in turn was based on an earlier compilation, the
Arbaah Turim (‘Four Rows’) of Jacob ben Asher (c. 1270–1340). The
Shulhan Arukh was compiled with the needs of Caro’s fellow Sephardim
in mind, but an Ashkenazi contemporary, Moses Isserles (c. 1525–72) of
Cracow, appended his Mappah (‘Tablecloth’), providing Ashkenazi rules
and customs where these differed. The title Shulhan Arukh is nowadays
applied to the composite work, which has been deemed acceptable to
both main branches of Jewry.
Following the pattern introduced by Jacob ben Asher, Caro divides the
laws under four headings. The first section, Orah Hayyim (‘Path of Life’),
deals with the ritual obligations of daily life, including worhsip and
prayer and the observance of Sabbath and holy days. Yoreh Deah
(‘Teacher of Knowledge’), the second section, contains ritual and
dietary regulations. Even ha-Ezer (‘Stone of Help’) concerns itself with
rules of personal status, marriage and divorce. Finally, Hoshen Mishpat
(‘Breastplate of Judgment’) covers civil law.
Although it is now more than four hundred years old, and in the intervening
period many changes have taken place in Jewish life and many
developments have been introduced in halakhah, the Shulhan Arukh has
never been superseded as a basic reference work. Specialised halakhic
scholars need to refer of course to the wider halakhic literature, which
can fill a whole library, and includes both later treatises and responsa and
earlier writings, including Maimonides’ great code of Jewish law, the
Mishneh Torah. There are also innumerable commentaries on the Shulhan
Arukh itself, beginning almost as soon as it was published. A whole school
of commentators existed in Vilna in the seventeenth century, and the
commentary by the famous rabbi of Vilna, Elijah ben Solomon, known
as the Vilna Gaon (1720–97), relating the laws to their source in the
Talmud, helped to spread the influence of the work still further. Indeed,
although he was a notorious opponent of the young Hasidic movement,
it was probably under the Gaon’s influence that the founder of the
Habad branch of Hasidism, Shneur Zalman of Lyady (1745–1813), compiled
his own reworking of the Shulhan Arukh, thus ensuring that his followers
would be brought under the discipline of the great halakhic code
and respect its authority.
The Shulhan Arukh is still viewed with affection and respect by
Orthodox Jewish laymen. It is available in abridged and translated form,
The Shulhan Arukh 61
and new commentaries continue to be written. The most important and
influential of the modern commentaries, both on the first section, the
Orah Hayyim, are the Mishnah Berurah of Israel Meir Ha-Kohen, known
as the Hafets Hayyim (1838–1933), and the Hazon Ish of Abraham Isaiah
Karelitz (1878–1953), who is universally referred to by the title of his
enormously popular book. Each of these authors was among the great
leaders of traditional Judaism in his own day, and both alike succeeded,
by focusing on the exhortation to moral and spiritual perfection, in
breathing life into the dry bones of the halakhah, and making the code
into a guide to religious living instead of merely a list of dos and don’ts.4
THE ZOHAR
Kabbalah is the name given to the main mystical tradition in Judaism,
and even though relatively few Jews today would probably describe
themselves as kabbalists the classical text of kabbalah, the Zohar
(‘Radiance’) still enjoys a following, seven centuries after its appearance
in late thirteenth-century Spain. Written in an artificial Aramaic, the
book has the form of a commentary on the Torah, outwardly resembling
the Midrash and purporting to go back to the time of the Tannaim. The
work is a vehicle for the theosophical ideas of the kabbalah, centring on
the doctrine of the sefirot, ten powers within the godhead produced by
emanation from the ultimate and unknowable En Sof (‘Infinite’).
The Zohar spread from Spain around the Mediterranean, and after it
was printed in Italy in the late 1550s it became even more widely accessible.
It was regarded by many as a sacred book, and some North African
synagogues contain two holy arks, one for the Torah and another for the
Zohar. The book became enormously influential in Hasidism, a movement
that arose in Poland in the eighteenth century, and it is said that
the founder of the movement, the Baal Shem Tov, always carried a copy
around with him. The opponents of the Hasidim, led by the Vilna
Gaon, also accepted the sanctity of the Zohar. However this sanctity
never became a matter of dogma, and nineteenth-century rationalism
62 Jewish books
14 See Gersion Appel, The Concise Code of Jewish Law: Compiled from Kitzur Shulhan Aruch and Traditional
Sources: a New Translation with Introduction and Halachic Annotations Based on Contemporary Responsa
(New York, 1989– ); Hayim Halevy Donin, To Be a Jew: a Guide to Jewish Observance in Contemporary
Life: Selected and Compiled from the Shulhan Arukh and Responsa Literature, and Providing a Rationale for the
Laws and the Traditions (New York, 1972); Boaz Cohen, The Shulhan Aruk as a Guide for Religious
Practice Today (New York, 1983); Mosheh M. Yashar, Saint and Sage: Hafetz Hayim (New York, 1937);
Simcha Fishbane, The Method and Meaning of the Mishnah Berurah (Hoboken, NJ, 1991); Shimon
Finkelman, The Chazon Ish: the Life and Ideals of Rabbi Yeshayah Karelitz (New York, 1989).
was strongly opposed both to kabbalah as a whole and to the exaggerated
respect paid to the Zohar. In recent times there has been a rediscovery
of the spiritual riches of the kabbalistic tradition. Unfortunately,
genuine interest in recovering an authentic Jewish heritage has become
confused with a modern quest for esoteric exotica and a spiritual ‘quick
fix’. Study of the Jewish mystical tradition requires linguistic skills and
painstaking work, as well as a sympathy with the aims of the earlier kabbalists.
A large number of the publications about the Zohar and kabbalah
available now are compiled by people lacking these resources, some of
them little more than charlatans. These books have little or nothing to
do with Judaism.
While there is an English translation of the Zohar, published in
London in 1931, it is obscure and difficult to use. Anyone wishing to
approach this key text and its ideas today would be advised to make use
of the excellent annotated compilation originally published in Hebrew
by Fischel Lachower and Isaiah Tishby and now available in an excellent
English translation.5
THE GUIDE OF THE PERPLEXED
There is another class of books that have never enjoyed a sacred or
canonical status, yet represent an important stream in Jewish thought
and have exerted a great influence at various times, namely works of
religious philosophy. The origins of this tradition are in Greek philosophy,
but it has become so deeply embedded within Judaism that there
are no real grounds for considering it an alien borrowing or a dilution of
the Jewish spirit.6
This type of work has a long history: an early exponent was Philo of
Alexandria in the early first century CE, a large body of whose works
have been preserved by Christians, although among Jews he was forgotten.
In the tenth century one of the giants of Jewish scholarship, Saadya
(882–942), wrote his very influential Book of Beliefs and Opinions. Written
in Arabic, like most of the medieval philosophical literature, this was
heavily indebted to the contemporary Muslim school known as Kalam,
and its aim was to set forth rational proofs of religious doctrines known
The Guide of the Perplexed 63
15 The Wisdom of the Zohar. An Anthology of Texts, arranged by Fischel Lachower and Isaiah Tishby, tr.
David Goldstein, 3 vols. (Oxford, 1989).
16 The best recent introduction to the subject is Colette Sirat, A History of Jewish Philosophy in the
Middle Ages, tr. M. Reich (Cambridge and Paris, 1985). The older book by Julius Guttmann,
Philosophies of Judaism (New York, 1973), is still useful.
by revelation and tradition. Most of the subsequent Jewish thinkers
stand in the Aristotelian tradition, but an important minority incline
rather to Neoplatonism: the foremost representative of the latter trend
is Solomon Ibn Gabirol (c. 1020–c. 1057), who is also known as a consummate
Hebrew poet. His major philosophical work is the Fountain of
Life, a discussion of the principles of matter and soul, but many of his
philosophical ideas are to be found, mingled with mystical motifs, in his
poems, particularly the long poem The Royal Crown (Keter malkhut).7
Another influential work of medieval Jewish thought is the Kuzari (The
Khazar) by Judah Hallevi (c. 1075–1141), also known as a Hebrew poet,
which actually attempts, through rational argument, to demonstrate the
inadequacy of reason as a source of knowledge of God compared to
scriptural revelation.8
Of the Jewish Aristotelians the greatest is beyond a doubt Moses
Maimonides (1135–1204), who also established a lasting reputation as a
codifier of halakhah and a medical writer, although his older contemporary
Abraham Ibn Daud (c. 1110–80) also made an important contribution
to Jewish Aristotelianism with his ‘Exalted Faith’ (Emunah Ramah).
Maimonides’ Guide of the Perplexed (Dalalat al-Ha’irin or Moreh Nevukhim),
has been widely regarded as the masterwork of medieval Jewish religious
thought, and indeed it was received and cited with approbation by
medieval Muslim and Christian thinkers. Its aim is to reconcile religious
belief based on the Bible with the rational arguments about physics and
metaphysics of Aristotle and his followers.9
The name of Maimonides is associated particularly with one of the
best-known answers to the question ‘what must a Jew believe?’ In his
commentary on the Mishnah he lists thirteen ‘principles of our pure
Torah and its foundations’.10 These principles have become a sort of
unofficial Jewish creed, and have made their way into the prayer book
in two forms, as a creed beginning ‘I believe with pefect faith that . . .’
and as a hymn.
Maimonides may have been the greatest of the medieval Jewish philosophers,
but he was by no means the last Jewish philosopher of note.
64 Jewish books
17 See p. 145.
18 Yochanan Silman, Philosopher and Prophet: Judah Halevi, the Kuzari, and the Evolution of his Thought, tr.
Lenn F. Shramm (Albany, NY, 1995).
19 Moses Maimonides, The Guide of the Perplexed, translated with an introduction and notes by
Shlomo Pines (Chicago/London, 1963). See also Oliver Leaman, Moses Maimonides (London,
1989).
10 See Menachem Kellner, Dogma in Medieval Jewish Thought, from Maimonides to Abravanel (Oxford,
1986).
Within the Maimonidean tradition Levi ben Gershom (Gersonides,
1288–1344) was a major figure, while Hasdai Crescas (c. 1340–1410) and
his pupil Joseph Albo (c. 1380–1444) were critical of Aristotelianism. The
modern era in Jewish thought was inaugurated by the disturbingly
radical figure of Baruch Spinoza (1632–77), who was expelled from the
Sephardi community of Amsterdam in 1656 for his heterodox views.
Despite this, Spinoza had an influence on later, more orthodox, Jewish
philosophers such as Moses Mendelssohn (1729–96). In the nineteenth
and twentieth centuries several important works of religious philosophy
were written, mainly by German Jews: they include Hermann Cohen’s
Religion of Reason out of the Sources of Judaism (published posthumously in
1919), Franz Rosenzweig’s Star of Redemption, and Martin Buber’s I and
You.11 Latterly German has been replaced, for historical reasons, by
English as the main language of Jewish religious thought.
In reviewing rapidly the ‘great Jewish books’ which might be found in
many Jewish homes we have only been able to skim the surface and
mention the major works whose titles are household names. Others
could be added which are equally well known among a more specialised
readership, such as the Tanya of Shneur Zalman of Lyady, the fundamental
text of Habad Hasidism. Nor should it be suggested that all these
works would be found in a single home. On the contrary, it would be a
very remarkable Jewish home which contained more than a few of them,
because (with the notable exception of the Bible and prayer book) they
represent distinct streams within Judaism. An Orthodox Jew who possesses
well-thumbed copies of the Talmud and Shulhan Arukh and related
halakhic works may never have opened the Zohar or Maimonides’ Guide,
while the latter works would appeal to very different types of readers,
with an inclination to mysticism and rationalism respectively.
Moreover, mention of these classic Jewish works does not begin to
exhaust the other, very different types of book we might find in a Jewish
home. Novels, books of poetry, cookery books and history books all have
their place on the Jewish bookshelf; grammars and dictionaries of
Hebrew, too, both the biblical and the modern language. There is a burgeoning
Hebrew literature from Israel which, even if it is inherently
secular, has a great deal to say on Jewish subjects. There is also a literature
in Yiddish which has come to be appreciated for its own sake and
The Guide of the Perplexed 65
11 Hermann Cohen, Religion of Reason out of the Sources of Judaism, tr. Simon Kaplan (New York, 1972);
Franz Rosenzweig, The Star of Redemption, tr.William W. Hallo (London/New York, 1971); Martin
Buber, I and Thou, tr. W. Kaufmann (3rd edn, Edinburgh, 1970).
not only out of folksy nostalgia. The earlier literature such as the Talmud
covered every conceivable subject: no topic or genre was ruled out
because it was not ‘serious’ or ‘religious’ enough. To the modern literature,
in all its diversity, Ignaz Maybaum applies the term ‘European
Talmud’:
It covers the literature in which European Jewry discussed Jewish problems,
wrestled with the spirit of its environment, succumbed to it, escaped it and
finally assimilated it to the Jewish spirit and thus renewed the old legacy. This
new literature is Jewish literature. Are Herzl’s writings and diaries ‘profane’ literature?
They are not as far as we Jews are concerned. Is Samson Raphael
Hirsch’s Bible commentary less Jewish than that of Rashi because the former
was written in the nineteenth century? Hermann Cohen, Franz Rosenzweig,
Mendele Mocher Seforim and Bialik, Ahad Ha’am and Solomon Schechter,
these and numerous others are the rabbis of the European Talmud.12
These words were written in 1945. Time has moved on, and Jewish literature
today is no longer only a European literature. It is American and
Israeli as well. This is an open-ended ‘Talmud’ that grows and grows.
Like the original Talmud, it does not seek final answers to perennial
questions, but revels in a debate which respects the arguments of the
other side, and finds as much value in analysing a problem as in solving
it.
66 Jewish books
12 Maybaum, The Jewish Home, p. 149.
CHAPTER FOUR
The Jewish religion
Jews today are more deeply divided than at any time in the past on the
theory and practice of their religion. The divisions are visible in the existence
of a multiplicity of synagogues in some towns, all proclaiming that
they hold the key to true Judaism, and in occasional acrimonious disputes
that have sometimes given rise to violence, particularly but not
exclusively in Israel.
To understand these divisions it is necessary for us to look more closely
at Jewish history over the last couple of centuries, and also at some of
the main theological principles involved.
The French Revolution, with its demand for equal rights for all, symbolically
marks the re-entry of the Jews into an active role in history. In
fact the struggle for equal civil rights was to take a very long time, and
in some countries it is still not over. Conversely, the ideas of the
Enlightenment, which gave rise to this demand, had been around, and
had been permeating Jewish society, for a long time before the
Revolution. However, it is convenient to see the end of the eighteenth
century and the beginning of the nineteenth as an important watershed
in Jewish history. In a sense this was the end of the Jewish Middle Ages,
at least in western Europe.
TRADITIONAL JUDAISM
The Jewish communities of the Middle Ages were essentially self-governing
entities, with very little social, cultural or religious contact with
their environment, although the various communities were attached to
each other in a far-flung network. The rabbis were the guardians of the
religious norms and traditions, and they issued rulings on questions
affecting individuals or the community as a whole. In determining points
of law the chief authority was the Babylonian Talmud, as interpreted
and made more relevant in a large and constantly growing body of legal
67
literature. The leaders of the community enjoyed various sanctions, and
in the last resort could expel those who flouted their authority from the
community, by invoking the herem or ban. In these circumstances tradition
was universally respected, change was slow, the ultimate objective
of education was to train worthy rabbis, and the profession of rabbi was
honoured.
There was very little dissent, and each town normally only harboured
one Jewish community. An exception was the rift between Karaites and
Rabbanites. Karaism was a reforming movement that was strong
between the ninth and eleventh centuries in the Middle East, and thereafter
in the Byzantine Empire. It rejected the authority of the Talmud,
and advocated a return to scripture. So acute was the rift between the
Karaites and their Talmudically oriented opponents, the Rabbanites,
that they formed separate communities in the same towns, which sometimes
had to be separated by a wall.
Later, after the expulsion from Spain, separate communities of
different origin were set up, for purely historical, not theological reasons,
in the cities of the Ottoman Empire, and congregations of Sephardim
and Ashkenazim existed side by side in some western European cities
such as Amsterdam, Hamburg and London. In this way the ground was
prepared for the pluralism that exists today. The distinctions were,
however, more social than religious, and membership of a community
was determined by descent rather than free choice.
A major shock was delivered to the old system by the revivalist movement
known as Hasidism, which arose first in south-eastern Poland in
the middle of the eighteenth century and spread very quickly throughout
Poland. Hasidism challenged not only the authority of the rabbis,
but their whole system of values, and it is hardly surprising that its fastgrowing
popularity was met by resistance on the part of the authorities,
However, it was only in Lithuania, under the power of the redoubtable
Gaon of Vilna and his disciples, that the bans pronounced by the
Misnagdim (‘opponents’) against the new movement were effective,
partly because they were backed up by appeals to the government. The
success of Hasidism demonstrated that it was possible to question and
even overthrow the traditional values.
A second challenge arose in the shape of the Haskalah, a self-consciously
Jewish offshoot of the Enlightenment movement that spread
eastward from Berlin during the nineteenth century. Its devotees, known
as Maskilim, attacked and mocked the obscurantism and superstition of
the rabbis and their abuse of their powers, and advocated secular values,
68 The Jewish religion
and the replacement of the traditional education by modern, westernstyle
schools. They were strong proponents of the Hebrew language, and
both secular Zionism and modern Hebrew literature have their roots in
the Haskalah.
As a successful Hasidic movement found itself in the position of the
Jewish establishment all over Poland and even further afield, and as its
leaders themselves confronted the challenge of the Haskalah, it became
less radical in its stance, and from ridiculing Talmudic casuistry it began
to concern itself with punctilious observance of the halakhah. Hasidim
were strong supporters of the Mahzike Ha-Das (‘Upholders of the
Faith’), an organisation set up in 1879 in Galicia to support traditional
values and combat modernism, and they are nowadays considered to be
among the most staunchly traditionalist of Jews.
The massive migrations that have taken place since 1880, coupled
with the Nazi genocide in Europe, have had the dual effect of destroying
the old centres of traditional Judaism and of spreading it to new
places, particularly in the United States and Israel, which are by far the
largest centres of Jewish population today. Those immigrants who were
most resolutely attached to the traditional style of Jewish life created
their own communities where they could live in self-imposed isolation
from the threats posed by the modern world, while others joined existing
communities, on which they gradually came to exert a marked
influence.
Because of the dramatic upheavals that have overtaken all the main
centres of traditional Jewish life, traditional Judaism today is almost
invariably associated with pockets of immigrant groups within western
societies, and this heightens their air of exoticism and artificiality. There
is almost nowhere left today where one can observe traditional Jewish
life being lived in an organic and unaffected way within its traditional
setting. Even the few surviving communities in Iran, Morocco and
Tunisia are on the decline, while those of Galilee are too close to the
hurly burly of Jerusalem to escape unscathed. The life of these, mainly
Sephardi, communities is marked by an unself-conscious and unquestioning
commitment to deeply rooted values, where legalism often yields
to common sense, and mystical piety plays an integral part, visible in
such practices as veneration of tombs of patriarchs and saints, often
associated with pilgrimage.
Traditional Judaism today, particularly in Israel, is often designated by
the Hebrew epithet haredi, meaning ‘fearful’ in the sense of maintaining
an attitude of awe or veneration (an expression borrowed from Isaiah
Traditional Judaism 69
66:5). The Haredi movement unites Hasidim and Misnagdim, despite
their historic divisions. Haredim affect a distinctive style of dress: the
men wear beards and sidelocks and black coats and hats, while married
women have shaven heads, covered by a wig or headscarf, and wear
modest clothing that hides most of their bodies. Haredim in Israel are
increasingly violent in their hostility to modernising trends, and particularly
to secular Zionism.
Since the political structures that supported pre-Emancipation
Judaism no longer exist, neo-traditionalism has to find other structures
in which to perpetuate the traditional forms of life and thought. This
amounts to re-creating an imaginary, voluntary ghetto. Various strategies
have been adopted, some of which (like the formation of political
parties) represent creative compromises with modernity, while others
involve theological developments. Many Ashkenazi Haredim support
the Agudah, a political party which is Jewish traditionalism incarnate.
The Agudah aims to make the voice of traditionalism heard where it
counts, and to gain financial support for its activities, and notably for its
impressive network of schools and colleges. Despite the hostility to
Zionism which is deeply rooted within all Jewish traditionalism, the
Agudah from the outset made its peace with the State of Israel, and plays
an active part in Israeli politics, even participating in government coalitions,
with a view to achieving its own aims. A ‘Council of Torah Sages’
supervises and guides the decisions of the movement, and through a new
doctrine known as ‘Knowledge of Torah’ (da‘at torah) the sages are
invested with almost infallible authority to determine not only religious
but political and even economic questions.
The characteristic and most important institution of traditional
Judaism is the yeshivah or academy. In the yeshivah the focus of study is
on the Talmud, which, despite its antiquity, is read as an authoritative
guide to Jewish living today. Traditionally yeshivah education is reserved
for men, but there are now some yeshivot catering to women. Yeshivot
have proliferated in recent decades in Israel, thanks to a law exempting
their students from military service, and although this has inevitably led
to a lowering of standards, the best yeshivot are highly regarded and
attract students from around the world. Many of these are baalei teshuvah
or ‘penitents’, young Jews who have been brought up without much
religious education, and are attracted by traditional values. The baal
teshuvah movement has been assisted by, and has in turn contributed to,
the introduction of new ways of teaching traditional Judaism in some
70 The Jewish religion
yeshivot, and the yeshivah model has come to be imitated in some less
traditional circles.
Haredi neo-traditionalism is a product of the Ashkenazi world. The
history of the Sephardi communities of North Africa and the Middle
East in their encounter with the modern world was completely different
from that of the Ashkenazim of eastern and central Europe. While
many Sephardi intellectuals, and even rabbis, were fascinated by the new
ideas coming in from France, Italy and elsewhere, there was not the same
polarisation and conflict that divided the Ashkenazim. The Sephardi
world was never divided into opposing camps like the Hasidim and
Misnagdim, modernists and traditionalists. On the contrary, successive
waves of foreign influence have tended to enrich the tradition rather
than challenge and unsettle it.
In Israel, however, the unique position of the Sephardi community
has gradually led it to adopt its own form of neo-traditionalism, to some
extent modelled on and influenced by its Ashkenazi counterpart but also
nourished by elements of the Sephardi tradition such as a strong attachment
to the mystical sources of Judaism which among Ashkenazim is
more or less confined to the Hasidim. Up to the end of the First World
War, under Ottoman rule, Sephardim constituted the backbone of the
Jewish presence in the Land of Israel. Deeply pious and traditional, they
clustered around the holy places of Jerusalem, Hebron and Galilee, of
which they considered themselves the custodians. They were not
immune to the influence of outside ideas, however, and a yeshivah,
named Porat Yosef, was set up in Jerusalem, providing a new style of
intellectual religious leadership for Sephardim not only in Israel but in
the Diaspora as well. Under British rule immigration from Europe dramatically
altered the numerical balance of Ashkenazim and Sephardim,
but after independence in 1948 mass immigration from Arab countries
brought in large numbers of Sephardim who were relatively untouched
by the encounter with religious and secular Zionism and with western
ideas. They were also socially disadvantaged, and after a difficult period
of adjustment they began to clamour for recognition of their own cultural
identity, a demand that found vigorous expression in the ‘Black
Panther’ movement of the 1960s and 1970s. The waves of social and
spiritual renewal converged in the formation of political activism under
the leadership of rabbis and former yeshivah students, of which the
most visible manifestation is the political party named Shas.
Traditional Judaism 71
THE MODERNIST REFORM
In terms of religious belief and practice, the most far-reaching reform
was that which began in Germany under the influence of the
Enlightenment and the movement for political emancipation.
The new ideas manifested themselves at first in liturgical rather than
in theological or legal reforms. The reason for this is presumably that
with increased contact between Jews and Christians, Jews became aware
of current Christian aesthetics of worship, and came to see their own
traditional forms of public worship as falling short of what their
Christian neighbours would expect. In the early nineteenth century the
issues which provoked debate included prayer in the vernacular, the
introduction of sermons and music, the shortening of the service and
the decorum of worshippers. It was only later that a theoretical basis was
sought for the reforms with the help of theologians and historians.
The first truly reformed congregation was the New Israelite Temple
Association, set up in Hamburg in 1817. The reforms included a strict
insistence on decorum, the introduction of choral and organ music,
prayers in German and a German sermon. The liturgy was abbreviated,
and the main emphasis was placed on the weekly Saturday morning
service. The influence of Christianity is obvious. The reforms were at
once condemned by the beth din (rabbinic court) of Hamburg, but they
were imitated elsewhere.
There was no agreement, however, about how far to proceed with the
reformation of Judaism or how fast, and the modernising movement was
soon riven by acrimonious debates. The new ways found expression in
a wide spectrum of formulations, ranging from the extreme theological
conservatism of Samson Raphael Hirsch (1808–88) to the extreme liberalism
of Samuel Holdheim (1806–60) and Abraham Geiger (1810–74).
Characteristically, these three German rabbis had all enjoyed both a
Talmudic and a secular university education, and much of the argument
focused on how far it was permissible to allow the values of the surrounding
culture to pervade Judaism.
Samuel Holdheim came from a background relatively untouched by
modern trends, and received a traditional Talmudic education, yet
became one of the most uncompromising of reformers. He formulated
the influential view that changing times demanded changes in the law,
even if the law is agreed to be of divine origin. He went further, however,
than most of his colleagues could follow him when he transferred the
Sabbath services in his Berlin temple to Sunday, abolished several festi-
72 The Jewish religion
vals, and officiated at marriages between Jews and gentiles. Holdheim
relied on the distinction between the religious and the national elements
in Judaism: the latter (echoing Spinoza) he declared to be obsolete since
the loss of the Temple in Jerusalem. In practice he was willing to
abandon many purely religious observances: what were important were
the beliefs and ethics of Judaism.
Abraham Geiger’s religious philosophy was similar in many ways. He
stressed the belief in progress: the Bible and Talmud represent an early,
primitive stage in a revelation which is still continuing. Many traditional
ceremonies (such as circumcision) are distressing to modern sensibility
or incompatible with modern life. In any case, he argued, the law of God
is essentially ethical, not ritual. Moreover, historical study shows that the
rituals themselves have changed and developed, and there is evidence of
this change in the Bible and Talmud themselves. Geiger became increasingly
convinced of the need to ‘dethrone the Talmud’. He supported the
critical study of the Bible and wished to extend the critical method to
the Talmudic literature as well.
Samson Raphael Hirsch’s approach was completely different: an
ardent radical, whose reforms of traditional practice often brought him
into heated conflict with members of his congregation in Nicolsburg in
Moravia, he would not allow any attempt to displace the Talmud from
its traditional role. He frowned on biblical criticism and he deplored the
overuse of the slogan ‘progress’. It was the Jews, not Judaism, who were
in need of reform, he argued. He hoped through education to breed a
better understanding of Judaism, which would make radical reforms
unnecessary.
The disagreements between Hirsch and Geiger and their respective
followers found expression in polemics as bitter as those between modernists
and traditionalists. From the literature it is clear that underlying
the debate about observance and ceremonies is a genuine theological
difference and, for once, an issue of belief. For Hirsch the belief in the
inspiration and authority of the Bible, the Talmud and the whole corpus
of rabbinic law became an article of faith. To budge from it even by an
inch was to open the door to unrestrained reform. Maybe that is why he
was particularly firm in his opposition to Zecharias Frankel (1801–75), a
very conservative modernist who was himself an avowed enemy of what
he termed ‘negative reform leading to complete dissolution’. But articles
of faith are alien to the whole spirit of authentic Judaism, which proceeds
through debate and consensus – or so at least the reformers
argued, and they dubbed the new conservatism ‘Orthodoxy’, a term
The modernist reform 73
borrowed from Christian theology, to highlight its dogmatic character.
The name stuck.
Hirsch can be considered as the founder of modern Orthodoxy, and
his books, such as the Nineteen Letters on Judaism and Horeb, are among the
movement’s classics. In 1851 he became the rabbi of the Adass Yeshurun
congregation in Frankfurt am Main, a position he held for thirty-seven
years, during which he transformed this small synagogue into the
flagship of the new movement. However, whereas at the outset he
claimed the support of the mass of German Jewry, over the years he was
forced to recognise that the Orthodox were a shrinking minority, and,
increasingly beleaguered, eventually he lent his support to the separation
of the Orthodox from the united communities that had previously
been the rule, and were increasingly dominated by reformers. This was
a very contentious issue that split German Orthodoxy; the impact of the
controversy can still be felt today.
The young Hirsch had had a vision of the best values in Judaism
marching forward arm in arm with those of the German universities.
The rapid growth of more radical Reform hardened his resistance to
change, and his Orthodoxy became increasingly defensive and reactionary.
In 1853, in response to the announcement that a new-style rabbinical
seminary was to be established in Breslau, Hirsch published an open
letter to the leaders of the seminary which was a tirade against the historical
study of the Bible and the Talmud which he rightly perceived was
undermining the fundamental belief that God had revealed the Torah
to Moses on Mount Sinai. This commitment to a rigid and inflexible
doctrine of revelation, increasingly difficult to maintain rationally, ultimately
undermined Hirsch’s conception of a fruitful marriage between
Jewish and secular studies (known as torah ‘im derekh erets), and stifled the
radical elements in Orthodoxy that had made it so exciting in its early
days.
For Orthodox Judaism today the Torah – meaning all the teachings
of the Bible and the Talmud and subsequent canonical literature, and
especially the practices codified in the Shulhan Arukh and other halakhic
writings – is divinely revealed and immutable. There is little or no room
in this view for open-minded biblical criticism or for historical analysis
of the Talmud. Orthodoxy likes to claim that it is doing no more or less
than continue the main stream of authentic Judaism as it has flowed
down from ancient times. This claim makes it difficult for the leadership
of Orthodox Judaism to guide the movement into new paths or even to
present a coherent and interesting statement of its aims, the more so as
74 The Jewish religion
Orthodox rabbis often seem fearful of being savaged by their own followers
and colleagues. Recently some leading Orthodox spokesmen in
the United States and in Israel have found a distinctive voice, but they
have difficulty making it heard in a movement that is dominated by neotraditionalist
tendencies, largely attributable to the enormous dominance
of Jews of eastern European origin, who have no understanding
of or sympathy for the cultural matrix from which the movement arose.
In the nineteenth century Orthodoxy steered a delicate middle course
between Reform and traditionalism and earned the suspicion and hostility
of both. Its social base and intellectual foundations, however,
placed it firmly in the modernist camp. Subsequently developments
sharpened the polemic between Orthodoxy and the more progressive
wing of religious Jewry, while gradually eliminating the border that
divided it from the more traditional elements. Today Orthodoxy, while
remaining a substantial and vocal presence within world Jewry, is in considerable
disarray, very largely because of uncertainty as to whether it is
essentially a conservative modernising movement or a progressive traditional
one. Orthodoxy still seems outwardly strong in western countries,
particularly in those like Britain or France where it enjoys a position of
institutionalised supremacy, but as a modernist movement it occupies an
uncomfortable – some would say an impossible – position, vulnerable to
attack both from the antimodernist right and from the antidogmatic left.
Orthodoxy appears to be uncomfortably straddling the fence between
traditionalism and modernism, allying itself openly with the traditionalists
(who have come to be termed, misleadingly, ‘ultra-Orthodox’, as if
they were a branch of Orthodoxy) yet conscious of competing for
members with the more progressive movements.
Conservative Judaism (known in some countries as Masorti, ‘traditional’,
presumably by comparison with the more progressive movements)
occupies the middle ground in Jewish modernism. Although its
roots are in Europe, in the ‘Historical Positivism’ associated particularly
with Zecharias Frankel, it is really an American movement, that is
closely associated with its main rabbinical college, the Jewish
Theological Seminary in New York, which was founded in 1887 in a
spirit of reaction against what were seen as the excesses of the Reform
movement. The aim of the founders was to embrace the liberalism and
pluralism of American Reform while safeguarding traditional practice.
The leaders of Conservative Judaism have always resisted the temptation
to embody the ideals and principles of the movement in an
authoritative statement. Certain strongly held beliefs, however, can be
The modernist reform 75
seen to be characteristic of the movement. In the first place, there is a
firm commitment to the people of Israel and its religious values, coupled
with a certain open-mindedness concerning the way these values should
be interpreted. The intellectual founder of the movement, Solomon
Schechter, declared that iconoclasm has always been a sacred mission of
Judaism, and while he insisted that it was mistaken to say that Judaism
had no dogmas, he felt that it had to be open to the demands of changing
times. He coined the term ‘Catholic Israel’ to indicate a non-denominational
approach which put the developing character of the Jewish
people at the centre of the religion.
Schechter presided over the establishment in 1913 of the United
Synagogue of America (later named the United Synagogue of
Conservative Judaism), ‘a union of congregations for the promotion of
traditional Judaism’, which now has well over 800 member congregations
in the United States and Canada, and is itself a constituent of the
World Council of Synagogues, established in 1957, and embracing synagogues
in South America, Europe, South Africa and Israel.
The movement maintains a Committee of Law and Standards which
attempts to rule on questions of religious practice, but the approach is
not authoritarian, and although there is a deep-rooted reluctance to
depart from established ways there is scope for openness and diversity.
This approach to halakhah differentiates Conservative Judaism sharply
from Orthodoxy, even if in practice many Conservative and Orthodox
Jews might agree entirely on matters of observance. One area where the
divergence has clearly visible consequences is in the place of women in
the synagogue. Mixed seating was a feature of Conservative synagogues
from the early days of the movement, and women were eventually permitted
to read from the Torah and to be counted in the number needed
to make up a congregation for public worship. In the 1980s, after a long
and divisive debate, women were accepted for rabbinical training in the
Seminary. Many Conservative synagogues are now completely egalitarian.
The decision to train women as rabbis led to the creation of a breakaway
organisation, now known as the Union for Traditional Judaism,
which has a rabbinical school of its own.
Reform Judaism, like Conservative Judaism, is particularly associated
today with the United States, while having its roots in nineteenthcentury
Germany and in the deep radicalism of men like Geiger and
Holdheim, prepared to do away with any heritage from the past that
stood in the way of the spiritual and moral regeneration of Judaism.Key
76 The Jewish religion
elements of Reform Judaism as it developed in Europe were the ‘normalisation’
of Jewish life and the breaking down of barriers between
Jews and gentiles, including the abolition of laws and customs that stood
in the way of this process; a strong sense of the common ground between
the Jewish and Christian religions and the mission of the Jews to bring
the moral values of the Bible to the world in conjunction with the
younger faith; and a strong commitment to the ideals of social justice
identified with the biblical prophets and brought up to date to embrace
such principles as the equal status of men and women within Judaism.
The movement was consolidated and disseminated through a new-style
rabbinate, trained in modern rabbinical seminaries to be familiar with
the critical study of the sources and to be able to preach attractively in
the vernacular. The reform of the religion was advanced through a
series of rabbinical synods, whose decisions were taken back by the
rabbis to their congregations.
Radical though European Reform was, its progress was hampered to
a large extent by structures of society and state that were generally resistant
to change and favourable to tradition and stability. America, on the
other hand, to which increasing numbers of central and western
European Jews were emigrating in the course of the nineteenth century,
provided an ideal breeding ground for Reform. There was no presumption
in favour of tradition; on the contrary, there was a strong feeling that
the past must be left behind and transcended. Individualism and initiative
were encouraged, and a spirit of common fraternity encouraged
Jews who had never been allowed to feel entirely German to consider
themselves American in every sense of the word, even while remaining
committed to their own religion. The small numbers of Jews and the
lack of rabbinic authorities in the pioneering days meant that an emphasis
on traditional observance was lacking.
The first Reform congregation on American soil was set up in
Charleston, South Carolina, in 1825, at a time when there were only
some 5,000 Jews in America. By 1875 the number had swollen to a
quarter of a million, and the majority of the newcomers were from
German-speaking lands. In 1842 a group of immigrants founded a
Reform congregation in Baltimore, but a more momentous event took
place three years later, with the creation of Congregation Emanu-El in
New York. Within a decade this congregation had a synagogue seating
a thousand congregants, in which men and women sat together (a practice
not yet established in Europe) and the decorous worship was accompanied
by a mixed choir; it also had its own prayer book, devised by its
The modernist reform 77
rabbi and spiritual leader, Leo Merzbacher, who ironically had come
from Europe with a certificate of Talmudic competence signed by the
great opponent of modernism, Moses Sofer.
The man who may be considered the architect of American Reform
was Isaac Mayer Wise (1819–1900). Although in many ways he was a
conservative, who never abandoned his belief that the Torah was
revealed by God and written down by Moses, Wise was thoroughly in
tune with America and the opportunities it offered to Jews to combine
loyalty to their country and their religion. Indeed in some ways he saw
American democracy as a natural outgrowth of Judaism. After a period
spent as a rabbi in Albany, New York, Wise was appointed in 1854 to a
congregation in Cincinnati, Ohio, a rapidly growing centre which,
under Wise’s tutelage, was to become the powerhouse of American
Reform Judaism. In 1873 a convention in Cincinnati set up the Union of
American Hebrew Congregations, and soon afterwards a rabbinical
seminary, the Hebrew Union College, was established. It is now one of
the foremost Jewish academies in the world, with campuses in Los
Angeles, New York and Jerusalem.
A conference of rabbis in Pittsburgh in 1885 formally adopted a kind
of creed, known now as the Pittsburgh Platform. Its architect was
Kaufmann Kohler, a leading progressive theologian of the movement.
The purpose was to mark Reform Judaism off clearly from Orthodoxy
and the nascent Conservative movement, on the one hand, and on the
other from more radical movements like the Society for Ethical Culture,
founded in New York in 1876/77, which rejected any claim to Jewish particularism
or a special mission. The Pittsburgh Platform, while expressing
respect for all religions, asserts that Judaism ‘presents the highest
conception of the God-idea’. The Bible reflects ‘the primitive ideas of
its own age’; modern advance in science, morality and social behaviour
must take precedence over its demands, and the Bible’s ceremonial regulations
concerning diet, purity and dress are abandoned, as is any hope
for a return to Palestine. ‘We recognise in Judaism a progressive religion,
ever striving to be in accord with the postulates of reason.’ The Platform
ends with a statement accepting the immortality of the soul and rejecting
bodily resurrection, and another on the duty to resolve the injustices
in society.
By 1937 the Pittsburgh Platform no longer seemed to represent the
aspirations and beliefs of the movement, and a new statement, the
Columbus Platform, was drawn up by Samuel Cohon. This adopted a
more positive approach to ceremonial and observance and to the Jewish
78 The Jewish religion
people and Palestine. A further statement, the ‘Centenary Perspective’,
was composed in 1976 by Eugene B. Borowitz.
Today Reform claims to be the largest of the religious Jewish movements
in the United States. American Reform is by far the most radical
of the three main movements. Some of its attitudes have stirred up controversy,
for example in revising the definition of Jewish identity to
include the offspring of a non-Jewish mother and a Jewish father
brought up as Jewish, and permitting the ordination of gays and lesbians
as rabbis.
Outside the United States Reform Jews are a minority today, and they
also tend to be much less radical than their American counterparts, with
whom they are associated in the World Union for Progressive Judaism,
created in London in 1926 and since 1973 based in Jerusalem. In Britain
there are two separate organisations which co-operate in many ways: the
Reform Synagogues of Great Britain and the slightly more radical
Union of Liberal and Progressive Synagogues.
RADICAL ALTERNATIVES
The three main modernist movements, Orthodoxy, Conservatism and
Reform, all share certain central presuppositions: in fact, despite their
hostile rhetoric towards one another they are very close in many ways,
that mark them off from traditional Judaism on the one hand and from
the more radical versions of Judaism that will be discussed next. This
rather sweeping statement would not be accepted by all modernist Jews:
for example very many self-professed Orthodox Jews feel a close affinity
with Ashkenazi traditionalism, at least in its more moderate forms.
Many others, however, are uncomfortable with some aspects of traditionalism
and feel themselves close to the more traditional wing of
Conservatism. Again, many Conservative or Reform Jews would feel
sympathy for some of the arguments and activities of Reconstructionism
or secular Judaism, even if they do not share their basic ideology. What
the various modernist movements share is a strong commitment to what
are seen as the central spiritual values and theological beliefs, religious
institutions and practices of Judaism as it has existed down the ages,
together with a sense that the traditional heritage has to be interpreted
and revised in the light of improved knowledge, technical advance and
social changes. In their very different ways they all profess the belief in
a single, beneficent God and in the authority of scripture, and they all
maintain the institutions of the synagogue and the rabbinate. They are
Radical alternatives 79
essentially conservative, and cautious in making reforms; though each
movement has both more traditional and more radical wings, these tend
to balance each other so that change, when it does occur, is rarely sudden
and drastic.
The search for more radical alternatives is not a new development in
Judaism; it has existed throughout Jewish history. One only has to think
of the ancient Hellenisers and Epicureans, the gnostics and ecstatics of
Roman times whose ideas fed into the medieval Kabbalah, or the many
outbursts of messianic fervour, including primitive Christianity and
Sabbateanism. Each of these was a response to a specific situation, and
each expressed an impatience with received beliefs and values and
sought a more drastic way out of what was seen as an intolerable Jewish
or human predicament.
The radical alternatives that exist today are actually similar to those
that existed at the end of the Second Temple period. The Epicureans
were extreme rationalists who could not accept that there was a personal
god who governed human affairs. At the other extreme were the various
movements that found mainstream religion too lukewarm or remote,
and looked for something more passionate and dramatic, involving an
immediate contact with the divine. These latter movements tended to
form close groups held together by esoteric beliefs and shared rituals.
Similar later examples can be found in the twelfth century, and in the
sixteenth and seventeenth (both periods that were marked by extremes
both of rationalism and irrationalism). Today again, the radical movements
range from extreme rationalists (so-called ‘secular Jews’) to
various groups of an esoteric character. Of course there is a fundamental
difference between these two types of response: the former is open
and public and would like to win over all Jews to its views by means of
rational argument, whereas the latter turns its back on reason and
favours intimacy and mystique. We must therefore study them separately,
but we should not forget that they are in a sense non-identical
twins, both responding to the same stimuli and both sharing a rejection
of mainstream beliefs.
‘Secular Jews’ is a term that refers to Jews who have chosen to
abandon the belief in God. Secular Jews have not rejected their Jewish
identity or their attachment to the Jewish people. On the contrary, they
are to be found among the strongest supporters of Jewish causes.
Jewish atheism has its roots in the Haskalah, the Hebrew Enlightenment,
in nineteenth-century eastern Europe, which shared the antireligious
and anticlerical sentiments of the European Enlightenment in
80 The Jewish religion
general, and in the Jewish socialism that emerged in the second half of
that century. Both these movements nourished early Zionism, and a
majority of the Jewish settlers in Palestine before the Second World War
were militantly or implicitly atheist, while identifying strongly as Jews.
Some of the prominent ideologists of Zionism, such as Ahad Ha‘am,
while rejecting Jewish religion as outmoded, call for a ‘spiritual’ revival:
however, on closer inspection ‘spiritual’ turns out to mean something
akin to ‘cultural’, even if these clarion calls are sometimes tinged with a
romanticism that verges on the mystical. This is particularly true of
Aaron David Gordon (1856–1922), a prophet of the return to the soil of
the Land of Israel. Today, many Jews in Israel describe themselves as
secularists (hillonim), and there is a lively and occasionally violent confrontation
between secularists and religious Jews (datiim). However,
secular Jews are also to be found in the countries of the former Russian
Empire and wherever Jews from those lands have settled. Not all secular
Jews by any means see themselves as socialist or as Zionist, though very
many do identify as one or the other or both at once.
Within the institution of the non-religious kibbutz in Israel new quasireligious
festivals were introduced in the 1930s, combining references to
the agricultural festivals of the Bible and the Zionist idea of returning
to the land. Most of the early experiments failed to catch on, but nonreligious
kibbutzim have developed their own ways of relating to the traditional
Jewish holy days. The Sabbath has been retained as a day of
rest, and among the other festivals Passover, with its theme of liberation
from slavery and oppression, has proved perennially popular. Kibbutzim
have compiled their own forms of service for the Passover seder, telling
the story of the exodus from Egypt without divine intervention.
It has been difficult for secular Jews to define their ideology in a positive
sense, since, like atheists everywhere, they tend to see themselves in
terms of what they are not, rather than what they are, and because of a
shortage of institutions organised exclusively around a secular Jewish
identity. By the last decade of the twentieth century, however, some
serious efforts were beginning to be made to devise an intellectual underpinning
for a secular Jewish identity.
Humanistic Judaism has emerged since the 1960s as a name for a form
of Jewish secularism that is establishing not only an ideology but an
organised structure, with leaders some of whom bear the title of rabbi.
An International Federation of Secular Humanistic Jews was set up in
1985.
Reconstructionism represents an original halfway house between
Radical alternatives 81
religious and secular Judaism. It is the creation of Mordecai Menahem
Kaplan (1881–1983), an American Conservative rabbi who in 1922
founded the Society for the Advancement of Judaism.Reconstructionism
combines the Conservative emphasis on the people of Israel with a rejection
of the supernatural element in Jewish theology.The result is a system
that places a high value on observance and community, but finally cuts
the thread linking contemporary Jewish religion with the idea of a
divinely revealed legislation. Jewish practices derive their authority not
from God but from their historical status as the expression of the corporate
will and identity of the people. The movement is thus in a direct line
from Historical Positivism, and shares much common ground with
Conservative andReformJudaism, but in abandoning the belief in a personal,
supernatural god it also moves closer to the secularist position.
Despite the apparent attractions of such a compromise between tradition
and modernity,Reconstructionism has failed to establish itself as a major
strand in contemporary Judaism, although it is possible that many Jews
share its main beliefs without having heard of the movement. The
Reconstructionist conception of the synagogue as a community centre in
which Jewish life in all its aspects (not just overtly religious ones) is preserved
and transmitted corresponds to a widely held image in the
Diaspora.
At the opposite end of the spectrum we find a proliferation of groups
that have moved away from the soullessness of the larger organisations
in search of an authentic religious experience drawing on various
strands within the Jewish tradition. Most of these groups are deliberately
small, and ascribe value to the individual person as a member of a
group, rather than to the group as an organisation in which the individual’s
identity can become lost. A first step was taken in the proliferation
of havurot (‘fellowships’) in the late 1960s and early 1970s. The first havurah
was founded in Somerville, Massachusetts in 1968, and others soon followed,
often in university towns. They devised forms of worship and
spiritual togetherness with great freedom, and generally with an emphasis
on equality of the sexes. So successful was the havurah movement that
it was partially hijacked by the religious establishment, with synagogues
setting up their own havurot not only for worship but for study or for social
purposes.
Like Hasidism before it, the havurah movement reclaimed the spiritual
heritage of the kabbalah, and indeed Hasidism itself became a major
source of spiritual renewal for groups not formally attached to the historic
Hasidic movement. The vocabulary of kabbalism and Hasidism
82 The Jewish religion
has entered the language of proliferating groups existing on the fringes
of Judaism, and increasingly reaching out to each other and beyond
through the internet.
This account of the divisions within contemporary Judaism has deliberately
emphasised the diversity that exists and the fluidity that characterises
all the trends. There has been a good deal of movement in every
direction, with children of Reform or atheist families discovering the
attractions of traditionalism, and the offspring of traditional parents
gravitating towards Reform Judaism or humanism
CHAPTER FIVE
The family
THE FAMILY AS A UNIT
Jewish society is built upon two main units, the family and the community.
What is the relationship between the two? It is very hard to say.
They are two very different spheres of activity, and the rules and maxims
that make up the Torah underline their difference by providing separate
and sometimes conflicting guidance. No doubt some Jews find greater
fulfilment in one or the other, and the balance may change in the course
of an individual’s life. But in the end both are equally necessary; to lose
or minimise either is to sacrifice something essential and distort the character
of Judaism. Louis Jacobs captures the dilemma acutely when he
writes:
Rabbis are fond of preaching that Judaism demands far more than regular
worship in the synagogue and that, for example, many of the highest ideals of
the Jewish religion are realized in the Jewish home rather than in the synagogue.
Worship in the synagogue is a sublime end in itself but it is also a means of
inspiring Jews to lead a full Jewish life and much of life has its place outside the
synagogue. There is a Torah for the synagogue, detailed rules, regulations, and
attitudes to be adopted in the synagogue, but this is only part, albeit a signi ficant
part, of the Torah as a whole. The Torah is always described as ‘the Torah of
Life’, that is of life as a whole.1
Students of religion have a tendency to look first and foremost at the
public face of religion: at the meeting places and public buildings, public
ceremonies and rituals, public statements embodied in homilies and
creeds. When they are not studying the public face they think of the
private face as represented by the solitary mystic, the hermit, turning his
back on the turmoil, delusions and temptations of society and seeking
God in the tranquillity of nature or the quiet of his innermost heart.
84
11 Louis Jacobs, The Jewish Religion. A Companion (Oxford, 1995), p. 517.
This approach, derived consciously or unconsciously from Christian
models, may not in fact be appropriate for the study of all non-Christian
religions. Students of Judaism can certainly not afford to ignore the
public face of Judaism, the worship of the synagogue and the communal
institutions, which form the subject of the next chapter. They must
be aware too of the voice of the individual,2 that is heard pre-eminently
in the biblical Psalms and in some of the other prayers recorded in the
Bible. But a depiction of Judaism that confined itself to these two areas
would be left with a gaping hole in the middle: the place that belongs to
the family and the home.
The place of the family at the heart of Judaism reflects the solid, reassuring
place of the family in a human society in which most people are
born into a family, grow up in the bosom of a family, and look forward
to creating a family of their own, in which the family is the unit that
underlies the legal and fiscal structures, and where the family home is
the commonest building-block of the urban landscape. That kind of
society is less familiar to us today than it would have been to our grandparents,
and their grandparents would very likely have known none
other.
In truth the family has never had an easy time of it, because the interests
of the family all too often seem to collide on the one hand with the
demands of the individual and on the other with the claims of the collective
– the state or society as a whole. Western civilisation has tended
to glamourise those whose individual fulfilment is crushed by the institution
of the family (Romeo and Juliet is just one of many fictionalised
examples) or who pursue the claims of their destiny, very often in the
service of the state or of the imagined good of the wider society, as soldiers
or knight errants. These ideals are totally at odds with those of
Judaism. Before the emancipation Jews were not called on to fight and
die for the state, and had no reason to identify with its demands, which
they generally experienced as hostile impositions. It was their private
home life that gave them a sense of purpose and destiny, and that they
did everything they could to protect and defend. In a conflict between
the individual and the family they sided naturally with the latter.
During the age of emancipation, the nineteenth century, European
and American Jews became assimilated to the ideals of the majority
culture and subject to the same legal and political demands. They were
conscripted or volunteered to serve in their countries’ armies, and some
The family as a unit 85
12 What place there is for the individual in Judaism is a matter of debate. See Jacobs, Religion and
the Individual.
had glorious military careers. Many found that the only way to better
their lot (or in many cases simply to survive in an increasingly industrialised
job market) was to put family life behind them, for a while or for
ever. These developments were as important in undermining traditional
family values as were the harsh blows of fate, the pogroms and persecutions,
the impact of war on powerless civilians, and the unprecedented
waves of migration. Throughout all these dramatic changes, however,
Jews tended to cultivate a glowing and no doubt romanticised image of
what family life had been like before, in a more innocent age.
Wherever and whenever they could, when the waves of violence
receded, when money became more plentiful, when as immigrants they
put down roots in a new land, these Jews made an effort to rebuild the
structures of family life, and the networks of friends and neighbours that
would support it. One fortunate sector of society, the wealthy Jewish
bourgeoisie that grew up in the European cities, were pleased to find that
the values of their adopted class coincided perfectly, in this respect, with
those of their ancestors: bourgeois life was founded on the family and
glorified its virtues. Well-to-do Jews in nineteenth-century Europe
created a unique fusion of Jewish and bourgeois life, which can be
studied in the writings and paintings of the period.3 It was a life that was
envied and imitated by less prosperous Jews. The atmosphere of a Jewish
family gathering, a Passover seder for example, owes as much even today
to this nineteenth-century Jewish bourgeoisie as it does to the medieval
ghetto or to Jewish life in the Greco-Roman period.
Karl Marx accurately observed this willing fusion of Jewish and bourgeois
values: ‘Judaism reaches its climax in the perfection of bourgeois
society,’ he wrote.4 However, he chose to focus on the negative aspects,
as he saw them, of bourgeois life, and overlook the positive ones. He had
many Jewish followers, particularly among the majority of Jews who
were pitifully poor. Jewish socialists were generally favourable to the
Marxist aim of destroying the foundations of bourgeois life, including
the family. This programme found its most extreme expression in the
deliberate abolition of the family unit in the kibbutzim of Palestine.
But even without going to such lengths many Jews in the twentieth
century promoted or accepted the breakup of the family unit and the
abandonment of family values. This is not the place to explore the intri-
86 The family
13 This point is well made by Ignaz Maybaum, Jewish Existence (London, 1960). Among many autobiographical
works exemplifying this theme one of the most powerful is Stefan Zweig’s The World
of Yesterday.
14 Karl Marx, On the Jewish Problem (1844). English translation by Helen Lederer quoted in Mendes-
Flohr and Reinharz, The Jew in the Modern World, p. 267.
cacies of the conflicts provoked by this confrontation within Jewish
society of two antithetical evaluations of family life, which is partly
responsible for the alienation of large numbers of Jews from the religious
establishment and for the distrust towards Zionism shown by most
religious Jews until recent times. What is important is to underline that
the place of the family within Jewish life is a subject of continuing
debate, which in some ways has been confused rather than facilitated by
the uneasy truce between the Jewish religious leadership and moderate
Jewish socialism. One strategy of a successful establishment is to yield to
some demands of its radical critics and to pay lip service to some of its
principles, while rejecting far-reaching change. In describing Jewish
family life we shall inevitably be presenting one side in this confrontation;
the other side does not seem to have much that is positive to contribute
to an account of Jewish family life.
If Jewish Marxists attack the family out of concern for the good of
society, what of the other side of the pincer movement, individualism?
Contemporary western civilisation encourages individuals, particularly
the young, to seek their own fulfilment at the expense of institutions such
as the family that might thwart them. Young Jews are naturally receptive
to this message. Jewish society favours upward economic mobility.
Jewish parents make sacrifices so that their children will do well. All too
often that means that the children will leave home and adopt a very
different lifestyle to that of their parents. In any case there is little in the
traditional social and religious structures to bind young Jews between
the age of Bar or Bat Mitsvah and the birth of their first child (which is
why in traditional society this gap was often reduced to a minimum,
whereas today it can last many years). Jewish society has its own strategies
to deal with this danger. Many opportunities have been created for
young Jews living outside the family to meet other Jews and share various
types of activity. Even if the worst comes to the worst, and a non-Jewish
marriage partner appears, there are various expedients that can minimise
the disaster. For their part, Jewish singles have developed their own
frameworks for Jewish growth and self-expression, such as the havurah
(‘fellowship’), a group (which may be more or less structured) that meets
on Sabbaths and other occasions to share a Jewish life without the constraints
of the family and the family-based synagogue.
The Jewish family is extensive and has rather flexible boundaries.
Family ties embrace not only those related to one another by blood, but
also those related by marriage, including the marriage of other family
members. (Those related by marriage are known as mehutanim.) In the
The family as a unit 87
past Jewish families were commonly very large, and a couple might find
themselves living under one roof not only with their children but also
their parents and even other family members who were single or who for
some other reason had no home of their own. Nowadays this arrangement
is less usual, as family units generally have become smaller and it
is easier for individuals on their own to fend for themselves, but a sense
of the wider family remains strong, and it is still quite common for
members of the extended family to gather together for special occasions
such as the Passover seder.
In the traditional family precise and differentiated roles were attributed
to men, women (married and unmarried) and children.
Responsibility was distributed between men and women, the latter by
and large taking more responsibility for the day-to-day running of the
home (and in some cases the family business), while the overall and longterm
responsibility fell upon men. Study of Torah was a religious obligation
binding on men in particular, and it was considered meritorious
(and still is in traditional circles) for a man to devote himself entirely to
study and count on his wife to support the family. As for children (defined
as boys up to the age of thirteen and girls up to twelve), they carried no
formal responsibility, being under the legal age, but were expected to
play their part within the family, obey their parents, and (particularly in
the case of boys) commence their studies. Men, women and children
also had distinct religious rituals allotted to them: for instance on
Sabbath Eve the woman of the house lit the lamps and her husband
recited the Sabbath blessings (kiddush), while at the Passover meal or
seder the Four Questions (mah nishtanah) were recited by the youngest
child present.
Today inevitably for most Jews these ancient structures have become
weakened, modified or demolished altogether. The ‘new man’ and the
emancipated woman have made their appearance, and home life is more
of an equal partnership with many of the roles being shared.
Nevertheless, the ritual aspects of the old division, together with some
social features, have proved remarkably resistant to change. It is still
common, even in emancipated families, to see the mother light the
Sabbath lights and the father say kiddush, while children still play their
traditionally prominent role during the Passover seder and (girls now
generally included) are still expected to study Hebrew and learn about
Jewish history and religion, whether in classes at the synagogue or at a
Jewish school.
88 The family
THE JEWISH HOME: SPACE
The Jewish home provides the physical setting for the life of the Jewish
family, and indeed is inseparable from it: it is the family that gives a
Jewish home its special character. Nevertheless, there are some external
signs that mark out the Jewish home, and the most visible is the mezuzah,
a handwritten parchment contained in an elongated case marked with
the Hebrew letter shin (for Shaddai, an old name of God), and fixed to the
doorways of the house. Although these are sometimes described as
amulets or talismans, and one sometimes sees pious Jews kissing them on
entering or leaving a house, there is nothing magical about them, but
they are a reminder of the words of the Torah which are actually
inscribed on them: ‘You shall write them [the words of the Torah] on
the doorposts of your house and upon your gates’ (Deuteronomy 6:9).
The meaning is understood to be that everything that is done by Jews
either inside or outside the home should be marked by an attentiveness
to the Torah. It is in obedience to an adjacent verse (‘You shall bind them
as a sign on your arm and they shall be as frontlets between your eyes’,
Deuteronomy 6:8, cf. Exodus 13:9) that traditional Jews when they say
their weekday morning prayers put on tefillin or phylacteries: leather
boxes containing similar handwritten texts, and attached to the forehead
and upper arm with leather straps.
The fixing of the mezuzah on a new home is an occasion for rejoicing.
There is a short religious service, known as Hanukkat Ha-Bayit (‘dedication
of the house’), an expression taken from Psalm 30, which is recited
on this occasion.
Each room in a Jewish home has its own particular character, but no
other room is so stamped by its Jewish identity as the kitchen, particularly
in Orthodox and traditional homes, where a rigorous separation is
made between milk and meat products, extending to keeping separate
cooking utensils, china and cutlery for each, and in very particular
households separate fridges and dishwashers. Since during the festival of
Passover many of these utensils cannot be used but must be replaced, it
can be an expensive operation to equip a Jewish kitchen.
All food served in an observant Jewish home must conform with the
rules of kashrut. These rules have become very complex over the years,
and they are observed more scrupulously in some households than in
others. Broadly speaking the rules can be divided into two groups, those
determining which species of animal may or may not be eaten, and
The Jewish home: space 89
those concerned with the manner of death, preparation, cooking and
serving.
The lists of forbidden and permitted animals are taken from the
Torah (Leviticus 11 and Deuteronomy 14:3–21). There are three main
classes of permitted animals: quadrupeds, birds and fish. Kosher quadrupeds
have to conform to two criteria: they must have cloven hooves
and chew the cud. The only animal that has cloven hooves but does not
chew the cud is the pig, which may be the reason why the pig has been
viewed as the non-kosher animal par excellence. Cattle, sheep, goat and
deer all come into the category of permitted animals. Horses, which
have undivided hooves, as well as animals with paws such as rabbit and
hare, are forbidden. As for birds, rather than provide general guidance
the Torah lists the ones that are forbidden. As it happens they seem to
be birds that kill other animals or fish or that eat carrion. The implication
is that all other birds are permitted, but since some doubt exists as
to the identity of some of the birds on the list scrupulous Jews only eat
domesticated birds that are known by tradition to be kosher, such as
chicken, duck, goose, turkey and pigeon. Fish have to have fins and
scales, a curious rule, since there do not seem to be any fish that have
scales but not fins. By and large this rule causes no difficulties, but rabbis
continue to argue over some doubtful cases, such as sturgeon, swordfish
and turbot. All other animals are forbidden, except for certain kinds of
locust that are specifically permitted.
Animals that are not kosher are called terefah (tref for short). Even a
small quantity of terefah can contaminate a dish or foodstuff, and so scrupulous
Jews are very attentive to the ingredients of prepared foods, such
as biscuits that may be made with animal fat. If a pot or pan in which
non-kosher food has been cooked is subsequently used for cooking
kosher food it will render it terefah, but the utensil may first be cleansed
in boiling water. (China and porcelain vessels cannot be cleansed.)
Animals that have been killed by other animals or that have died of
their own accord are specifically forbidden (Exodus 22:30; Leviticus
11:39; Deuteronomy 14:21), as is the consumption of the blood of any
animal (Leviticus 7:26–27; 17:10–14). This means that only those permitted
animals and birds that have been properly slaughtered may be eaten.
Elaborate rules have been developed for shehitah (slaughter). The butcher
or shohet must be a person of moral integrity, and his knife must be
extremely sharp and free from the slightest nick, so as to avoid inflicting
pain on the animal. The animal’s throat is cut with a single continuous
movement, and the blood is immediately emptied out. An animal that
90 The family
has certain defects or diseases, even if properly slaughtered, is considered
as terefah, so the butcher will examine the organs, particularly the
lungs, with great care, and if necessary will consult a rabbi. Not all parts
even of animals that have passed all these tests may be eaten. In particular,
the sciatic nerve which runs through the hindquarters is not eaten,
by very ancient custom (Genesis 32:32), and since removing it (‘porging’)
is a difficult process, the meat of the hindquarters is not eaten at all in
some places, such as Britain. Before the meat may be eaten the remaining
blood is drawn out by salting. (Grilling over a naked flame is an
acceptable alternative method in the case of liver.) Fish do not need to
be killed in a special way or salted, as their blood is not considered to fall
under the prohibition.
There is a further set of rules, based on a curious prohibition on eating
‘a kid seethed in its mother’s milk’, which is repeated three times in the
Torah (Exodus 23: 19; 34:26; Deuteronomy 14: 21). The rabbis understood
this to mean that no kind of meat may be cooked in any kind of
milk. As an extra precaution, they forbid the eating of meat and milk
products at the same meal, even if they have not been cooked together.
This rule in its turn has been extended, so that one has to wait a certain
length of time after eating meat before eating dairy products; some
people wait as much as six hours. And, as we have already mentioned, it
is common for Orthodox Jews to keep separate sets of pots, dishes and
cutlery for use with meat and dairy foods.
One way round most of these demanding requirements is not to eat
meat, and indeed there are many vegetarian Jews and there are even
Jewish vegetarian organisations. Even vegetarians, however, must be on
their guard against eating certain foods which transgress against one or
other of the food laws, such as an egg with a blood spot, cheese made
with animal rennet, or gelatine.
The place of the kitchen in Judaism is captured brilliantly by Lionel
Blue:
And the changes of the liturgical year are marked out for the Jew by smell and
taste, by the aromas of the kitchen. Through the most basic senses, he feels the
changing moods of the spirit. Theologies alter and beliefs may die, but smells
always remain in his memory, calling him back to his own childhood and to the
childhood of his people. Whatever prayers he may forget, the gastronomic cycle
always remains. Passover is the bread of poverty, with tears of salt water, and
the horseradish of bitterness. Ruth is cream and cheesecake, and the New Year
is the sweetness of apples and honey. Esther comes with poppy seed, and the
Maccabees with nuts. The delightful litany only halts to mark the destruction of
The Jewish home: space 91
the past, or days which commemorate the sins of the present. On these tragic
and sad days there is a total fast, and the kitchen, the heart and soul of the
Jewish home, misses a beat, and a darkness covers this little world.5
From the kitchen it is but a short step to the table. In an age when the
dignity of the dining room in many homes is being eclipsed, in Jewish
homes it still retains its centrality. It is not a formal and secluded room
from which children are excluded. At least once a week the whole family
gathers round the table for a festive meal with its traditional recipes and
rituals. If we imagine this table prepared for the evening meal of the
Sabbath or a festival, we must envisage it impeccably laid, with a clean
white tablecloth and the finest china and cutlery the family can afford.
Our attention may be caught by a pair of silver candlesticks and a silver
wine goblet, and an embroidered cloth covering a plaited loaf of bread
(hallah).
In some homes we may notice some skullcaps, plain or ornamental,
for the men and boys to wear while saying the blessings before and after
the meal. This is a subject where widely differing views prevail. The covering
of the head while praying is not mentioned in the Bible (except
that the high priest wore a mitre as part of his official vestments), and as
late as the thirteenth century it seems that rabbis in France recited blessings
bareheaded. By that time, however, the Babylonian custom of covering
the head to pray had gained wide acceptance, and many
traditionalist and Orthodox Jews keep their heads covered throughout
the day, whether indoors or out. Other Jews cover the head only while
in a Jewish home, and others again keep it covered while eating, particularly
on Sabbaths and festivals. Reform Judaism was at first opposed to
the custom of covering the head, but today many Reform and Liberal
Jewish men cover the head to pray. Many women, too, now cover their
heads to pray.
It has been said that in the Jewish home the father is a priest and the
table an altar. This is the time-honoured ritual of Friday evening or
Sabbath Eve. The mother lights the lights, traditionally at a specified
time before sunset, but in non-Orthodox homes it is often done at the
beginning of the meal. In the past oil lamps were often used, sometimes
hanging lamps with seven wicks, to represent the seven days of creation,
but today it is usual to light a pair of candles. The children are blessed
by their parents, and there may be a song symbolically welcoming angels
into the home, and the father may read aloud the praise of the valiant
92 The family
15 Lionel Blue, To Heaven, with Scribes and Pharisees (London, 1975), pp. 39–40.
wife in Proverbs 31:10–31. During the festive meal it is customary to sing
table songs (zemirot), and afterwards the grace or benediction after food
(birkat ha-mazon) is sung. The singing is jolly rather than reverential, and
the general mood is one of informality and joyfulness.
The Friday evening meal is the high point of the week in a Jewish
home, but there are other meals that have their accompaniment of
ritual. Traditionally the Sabbath has three meals: the second is lunch on
Saturday, and the custom exists in some circles of celebrating a third
meal on Sabbath afternoon to intensify and prolong the Sabbath mood.
The major festivals are marked by formal meals too: the three ‘pilgrim’
festivals Pesah (Passover), Shavuot (Pentecost) and Sukkot (Tabernacles)
and the two solemn holy days, Rosh Ha-Shanah and Yom Kippur.
The Passover evening meal is unique. The mood is like no other festival,
and the preparations may take several days or even weeks.
Scattered family members make a point of gathering together for the
festival, and it is customary to invite additional guests. The basic rules of
the celebration are found in the Torah (Exodus 12–13), but they were
considerably elaborated in the Greco-Roman period, and the meal as
celebrated today retains noticeable elements from a Roman banquet.
These include the custom of reclining on a cushion, and of dipping
herbs in salt water or sweet paste.
The bedroom is an area that in the ancient codes is as strictly regulated
as the kitchen, but since nowadays such regulations tend to be regarded
as an unwarranted intrusion on privacy the rules concerning sexual
activity are much less discussed and probably less strictly observed
(though this is not easy to ascertain) than the rules of kashrut.
The first and greatest restriction concerns who may legitimately have
sexual intercourse with whom. In practice this excludes all relations
except for those between married couples, and thus incest, group sex and
under-age sex are all ruled out by definition. Sexual acts between males
are also forbidden, on the basis of a biblical prohibition (Leviticus 18:22,
20:13), but the codes do not dwell on this topic. Lesbian sex, which is not
mentioned in the Bible, is forbidden by the codifiers under the rather
vague heading of ‘Egyptian acts’ (Leviticus 18:3). Recently strong arguments
have been put forward in progressive circles in favour of tolerating
or permitting homosexual acts by both sexes, at least within stable
relationships, but Orthodox authorities and a weighty body of
Conservative opinion are opposed to this reform. Solitary sex is forbidden
for males, who are also encouraged to avoid anything that might
The Jewish home: space 93
lead to it. (The Zohar describes it as the most defiling of all sins.) Since
this ban is based on a biblical prohibition on ‘wasting seed’, many
authorities hold that it does not apply to women.
Even within marriage sexual activity is closely regulated by the rule
books. It is forbidden during the wife’s menstrual period and for the seven
following days, when she is in a state of ritual impurity according to biblical
law (Leviticus 18:19; cf. 15:19–31). She is similarly ‘impure’ after
giving birth (Leviticus 12). During these periods the woman is termed a
niddah, and the whole subject of niddah impurity and the consequent prohibitions
is discussed with almost obsessive interest in the various rule
books. Nowadays many of the restrictions have been tacitly or explicitly
abandoned. The main one, which is supposed to be observed by
Orthodox Jews, is to refrain fromsexual intercourse, and at the end of the
period the wife is to immerse herself in a ritual bath (mikveh). After that,
normal sexual relations may resume until the next menstrual period.
‘Normal sexual relations’ are also governed by various rules, specifying
for instance that they must be conducted with sobriety and modesty,
in darkness, and with the husband uppermost. They are not permitted
if the wife is unwilling, or if she is too eager. On the other hand the
husband is to have regard to the wife’s pleasure, and he is not allowed to
deny her sexual intercourse altogether.
While the bathroom has no specified role in the Jewish home (private
bathrooms were virtually unknown when the rules evolved), cleanliness
is undoubtedly a virtue among Jews, and ritual washing and bathing
occupies an important place in traditional observance. Even progressive
Jews or secular kibbutzniks will tend to take a bath and dress in clean
clothes in readiness for the Sabbath and festivals. The mikveh (ritual bath)
used to be a feature of every Jewish community, and its demise in
modern times has no doubt been favoured by the availability of bathing
facilities at home. In addition to full immersion, which requires a mikveh,
handwashing is mandatory or customary in various circumstances, such
as on getting up in the morning, before eating bread, after sexual intercourse
and after a burial. In some Jewish homes you will see a small
pitcher with two handles, which is used for pouring water over the hands,
since water straight from the tap is not adequate for ritual washing.
THE JEWISH HOME: TIME
Time in the Jewish home is regulated by the regular succession of days,
weeks and years. On a longer scale it is measured by the lifetime of each
member of the family.
94 The family
The Jewish day begins technically at sunset, which is why the
Sabbaths and festivals are marked by lighting candles or oil lamps in the
home a little before sunset. Technically the Sabbath ends when three
stars have appeared in the sky.
The rhythm of the day is marked for observant Jews by the succession
of prayers. There are actually two different cycles: the Shma (which is
technically a scriptural reading rather than a prayer) is recited twice
daily, in the evening and in the morning, while the statutory prayer or
tefillah (commonly known as Amidah, ‘standing’, because it is always
recited standing up) is recited three times each day, evening, morning
and afternoon (in obedience to a hint in Psalm 55:17). Both the Shma
and the Amidah form part of the service of the synagogue, and many
Jews prefer to say them, where possible, with a congregation.
Nevertheless, strictly speaking there is an obligation for each Jewish man
(and woman in the case of the Amidah) to say them even if alone.
The week is made up of seven days, six working days followed by a
day of rest, the Sabbath. This pattern is very ancient, as we read in the
Torah: ‘For six days you shall labour and do all your work, and the
seventh day is the Sabbath of the Lord your God, when you shall do no
work’ (Exodus 20:9–10). The whole week seems to lead up to the
Sabbath, and in fact in Hebrew the other days do not have names of
their own, but are simply numbered ‘first day’ (Sunday), ‘second day’
(Monday) and so on.
Friday is a day of preparation for the Sabbath, particularly in the
home, which must be cleaned and tidied, and where the Sabbath meals
must be prepared in advance, since no cooking must be done once the
Sabbath has begun. (Hot food may however be kept warm.) The table
is laid for the evening meal, as we have seen, with a clean white tablecloth,
with the best tableware, and with the special candlesticks and
wine goblet. The members of the family bathe and dress in clean
clothes.
The arrival of the Sabbath is likened to the entry of a bride or a
queen. Some sources speak of a Jew possessing an ‘additional soul’ on
the Sabbath, and of the angels that enter the home at this time. It is a
time not only of rest from work but of joy and pleasure, which is why
there is an emphasis on eating and drinking, and it is considered a particularly
propitious time for marital relations.
Sabbath joy is more than the spontaneous relief of hardworking
people who are enjoying a break from their labours. It has something of
a religious character, and is known in Hebrew as oneg, in allusion to a
passage of the Prophet Isaiah (58:13–14):
The Jewish home: time 95
If you turn back your foot from the Sabbath, from doing your own will on My
holy day, and call the Sabbath a joy and the Lord’s holy day honoured, and if
you honour it by not doing your own ways, finding your own will, speaking your
own word, then you will rejoice in the Lord, and I shall let you mount upon the
high places of the world, and feed you with the inheritance of your father Jacob.
The word of the Lord has spoken.
The joy of the Sabbath is thus not an expression of material enjoyment
and crude merrymaking, but is closely linked to observing the
command to ‘Remember the Sabbath day to keep it holy’ (Exodus 20:8).
The primary reason given for the observance of the Sabbath in the
Torah is as a commemoration of the creation of the world, when God
is described poetically as resting on the seventh day. ‘For in six days the
Lord made heaven and earth and the sea, and everything that is in them,
and rested on the seventh day; therefore the Lord blessed the Sabbath
day and declared it holy’ (Exodus 20:11; cf. Genesis 2:2–3). All forms of
work are forbidden, and this is understood to include writing and handling
money, as well as switching on a light or electrical appliance and
driving or riding in a motor vehicle. For those who observe the rules
stringently the Sabbath really is a time apart from weekday life, when the
very rhythm and texture of living are different. Conservative Jews tend
to make some concessions, for example by switching on lights or driving
to synagogue, and Reform Jews are more permissive still, but all alike
strive to make the time of the Sabbath different from the rest of the
week. The Sabbath is a holy day, and ‘holiness’ (kodesh) in Hebrew has
more of the sense of difference than of spiritual elevation, though this
too has its place in Sabbath observance, particularly for the more mystical
wing of Judaism. The kabbalists, in welcoming the Sabbath as a
bride, imagine that they are welcoming the Shekhinah, the presence of
God. On this day the male and female elements in the Godhead are
united, hence the souls that enter children conceived on the Sabbath are
particularly sublime.
The Hasidim take the rejoicing on the Sabbath particularly seriously.
Before the beginning of the holy day they purify themselves by immersion
in the mikveh, and they dress in special clothes. Setting aside an old
prohibition, they are fond of dancing on the Sabbath, and they experience
the holiness of the day with great intensity. When they eat the
Sabbath meals in the presence of their leader, the Tsaddik, he passes
around to his followers food from the dishes he has tasted. Hasidim are
particularly aware of the mystical dimension of the Sabbath at the third
meal, in the afternoon. As the light fades they listen to the teaching of
96 The family
the Tsaddik, communicated to him by the Shekhinah. They also have an
additional meal after the departure of the Sabbath, to escort it on its way.
The end of the Sabbath, when three stars have appeared in the sky, is
marked by the ceremony of havdalah (‘distinction’). As the Sabbath is welcomed
with light and wine, so it is seen out with light and wine, and additionally
with fragrant spices. The special spice-boxes are often
beautifully made, and the candle is plaited so that it has several wicks.
The prayer for this occasion praises God ‘who makes a distinction
between holy and profane, between light and darkness, between Israel
and the other peoples, between the seventh day and the six working
days’. Afterwards it is customary to sing songs in praise of Elijah, the
harbinger of the Messiah. With this joyful and attractive ceremony the
Sabbath fades gradually once more into the mood of the working week.
The Jewish year is essentially lunar, and indeed in ancient times the
day of the new moon (Rosh Hodesh) was important enough to be compared
to the Sabbath (e.g. 2 Kings 4:23, Isaiah 1:13) although nowadays
it is a minor observance.Work is permitted, although there is an old tradition
that women have a holiday from work, and there is a tendency
now to see Rosh Hodesh as a women’s festival. Beginning in the United
States in the early 1970s, Orthodox women’s prayer groups are held on
Rosh Hodesh, and groups of women gather to perform rituals celebrating
rebirth and renewal. Originally the occurrence of the new moon was
determined by observation; the calendar was fixed by calculation in the
fourth century, and still corresponds to the observable phases of the
moon. Each month has either twenty-nine or thirty days.
The calendar is not purely lunar, however, for if it were the festivals
would move round the cycle of the seasons, whereas Passover must fall
in the spring, the season at which the exodus from Egypt took place. This
adjustment is achieved by ‘intercalating’ an additional month seven
times in every nineteen years. The additional month is inserted before
the month in which Passover falls.
All Jews today share this calendar (with the exception of the few
remaining Karaites, whose calendar is a little different). There is,
however, a discrepancy with regard to the so-called ‘second days’ of festivals.
Jews in Israel follow the biblical rules with regard to the three
‘pilgrim festivals’, Passover (the first and seventh days are full festivals),
Pentecost (one day) and Tabernacles (the first and eighth days are full
festivals). According to ancient custom, Jews outside Israel added an
extra day to each of these, probably because of uncertainty before the
calendar was fixed. Today Reform Jews in the Diaspora have reverted to
The Jewish home: time 97
the biblical dates, and some Conservative rabbis are in favour of doing
likewise. New Year, however, which was a one-day festival in the Bible,
is celebrated for two days both within and outside Israel, except among
some Reform Jews, who prefer to follow the biblical practice.
The cycle of the year in the home is marked by the two major religious
observances of Passover in the late spring and Rosh Ha-Shanah
(New Year) at the end of the summer, five and a half months later. The
home is cleaned and prepared in readiness for both festivals, but
Passover requires more thoroughgoing preparation because of the religious
requirements of the festival. According to the Torah, ‘no hamets or
leaven shall be seen within your limits’ (Exodus 13:7; cf. 12: 15, 19). Hamets
is understood to refer to grains that have sprouted or cereal products that
have become leavened. The house, and particularly the kitchen, is therefore
subjected to a very thorough springcleaning. Old food is thrown out
and fresh food is brought in, and bread is replaced by unleavened bread,
matsah, for the period of the festival, which lasts seven days according to
the Torah (eight days in many homes outside Israel). All Jewish festivals
have their own recipes and flavours, but Passover food is a world of its
own, to which whole books have been devoted. Pots and pans, plates and
dishes, knives and forks must all be specially treated, discarded or withdrawn
from use, and some households keep a special set of kitchen utensils
and tableware to be used only at Passover. According to old custom
a ‘hamets-hunt’ takes place the evening before the festival commences,
with a few crumbs being left deliberately to be found and ceremoniously
swept up, to be burnt the next morning.
Traditionally all members of the family should prepare themselves by
having their hair cut and by bathing. Technically first-born sons are supposed
to fast on the day leading up to the seder, in remembrance of the
killing of the Egyptian first-born (Exodus 12:29), although this fast is not
much observed today.
On the morning preceding the festival the preparations intensify. The
last hamets is burnt, and after mid-morning no more hamets may be eaten.
The evening meal, the seder, is a feast, and for many Jewish homes this
is the largest and most festive dinner of the year. Special dishes are prepared
for the meal itself, and each family has its own favourites. It is
common to begin the meal with hard-boiled eggs in salt water.
Symbolic foods adorn the table: three sheets of matsah (unleavened
bread), serving as a reminder that the Israelites left Egypt in such haste
that there was no time to let the dough rise; maror or bitter herbs, commonly
represented by horseradish, because the Egyptians embittered
98 The family
the lives of the slaves; pesah (Passover offering) is a lamb, appointed in the
Torah to be eaten as the meal of the day. Nowadays lamb is avoided for
the actual meal, but a roasted shank bone reminds the company of the
days when the sacrificial offering was made. A roasted egg is another
reminder of the sacrifices. There are also green leaves (karpas), because
this is the spring time, salt water for the tears of the afflicted, and a sweet
reddish-brown paste called haroset which is said to evoke the mortar used
by the slaves in construction work.6 Each of these foods has its place in
the ritual.
Wine plays a special part in the seder. Each participant is supposed to
drink at least four glasses, and an extra goblet is placed on the table for
the prophet Elijah, who according to folk belief will come again to
herald the Messiah.
The participants in the seder dress as they would for a formal dinner
or special occasion. In some Ashkenazi families it is still the custom that
the head of the household, who will lead the ceremonies, wears a kittel,
a white tunic that is one of the burial shrouds.
The book of words containing the Bible readings and prayers, and
often useful reminders about the conduct of the seder, is known as the
Haggadah (‘recitation’). The text is very old: although some songs were
added in the Middle Ages the main text goes back to the time of the early
rabbis.
The rituals of the seder are strictly laid down by tradition and followed
in due order. The first of the four glasses of wine is for the kiddush
of the festival, which opens the proceedings. Those present then wash
their hands (an ewer and basin are passed round the table for this
purpose). Then the leader, normally the master of the house, dips some
parsley or another salad vegetable in salt water and passes it around to
everyone. He takes the middle matsah of the three, breaks it in half, and
sets one half aside. This is the afikoman, the symbolism of which is now
shrouded in obscurity. The custom is for the children during the meal to
steal the afikoman (often it is hidden for them to find) and hold it to
ransom, as the seder cannot continue without it. The narration proper
then commences, in response to four questions usually asked by the
youngest child:
Why is this night different from all other nights?
On all other nights we eat either leavened or unleavened bread: why tonight
do we only eat unleavened bread?
The Jewish home: time 99
16 For some recipes see Claudia Roden, The Book of Jewish Food (London, 1997).
On all other nights we eat all kinds of herbs: why tonight do we eat bitter
herbs?
On all other nights we do not dip our herbs even once: why tonight do we
dip them twice?
On all other nights we eat either sitting or reclining: why tonight do we all
recline?
The reply begins:
We were Pharaoh’s slaves in Egypt. The Lord our God brought us out from
there by power and force. And if the Holy One, blessed be He, had not brought
our ancestors out of Egypt, then we, our children, and our grandchildren would
continue to be enslaved to Pharaoh in Egypt. That is why, however wise or
clever or old we are, however knowledgeable in Torah, we must obey the
command to talk about the Exodus from Egypt. The more one talks about it,
the more praiseworthy it is.
There follows a lengthy series of comments on the biblical account of
the Exodus, and in some homes, not content with reciting the traditional
texts, the participants add their own explanations, and their own comments
on the theme of liberation, because the theme of Passover is not
only the historical exodus but everything it symbolises, including the
contemporary political implications of freedom as well as its moral and
spiritual dimensions, and also the future redemption. The three main
symbols, the roast lamb, unleavened bread and bitter herbs, are each
singled out and explained, and then the Hallel is recited, consisting of
Psalms 113 to 118, followed on this occasion by the ‘Great Hallel’, Psalm
136.The Hallel is interrupted by the meal. (Originally the meal was eaten
at the beginning, before the four questions, which are evidently a
response to it.) There is a series of blessings before the meal, on wine
(the second glass), handwashing, bread and matsah (of course matsah is
used for both of these, since leavened bread is strictly forbidden), and
maror (bitter herbs). Pieces of horseradish are generally used for maror;
first they are dipped in the sweet paste, haroset, and then they are eaten
in the form of a sandwich between two pieces of matsah. After the meal,
when the afikoman has been bought back from the children, it is broken
in pieces which are either eaten or kept until the next Passover. Then
grace after meals is sung, followed by the drinking of the third glass of
wine.
After the end of the Hallel there are some prayers, and then the fourth
glass of wine is drunk, at which point the proceedings are technically
over, and the following concluding hymn is sung:
102 The family
The Passover seder is concluded
According to custom and ordinance.
As we have been found worthy to celebrate it
So may we be found worthy to celebrate it again.
Pure One, dwelling in Your habitation,
Raise up the countless congregation.
Take and lead the saplings of Your stock –
Redeemed with joyous song – to Zion.
NEXT YEAR IN JERUSALEM!
The evening does not end here, however, but a cheerful singsong
ensues, a reward for the children who have stayed awake this long.
Those families that keep the festivals for two days will have a second
seder the following night; the rest have only one seder, and for these at
the end of the first day, which is marked in the home by a festive midday
meal, full festival changes to hol ha-moed, an in-between time that shares
in the sanctity of the festival but on which work, at least of the more
essential kind, is permitted. The special food laws continue to be
observed, and only unleavened bread may be eaten. The cakes and biscuits
cannot be made with flour; delicious pastries are made with other
ingredients, notably almonds and cinnamon. The seventh day (seventh
and eighth for those who keep two days) is a full festival, with further
feasting.
On the second evening, according to an ancient custom, there begins
a period of seven weeks known as the ‘Counting of the Omer’. (The
omer, ‘sheaf ’ was a harvest offering that was formerly brought to the
Temple on the second day of the festival: Leviticus 23:9–14.) It is customary
to count the days and weeks aloud, and some families have an ‘omer
board’ which helps them to keep count. For reasons which remain
unclear the counting of the omer became a period of sadness, during
which weddings do not take place. Orthodox Jews do not shave or have
their hair cut. The thirty-third day (known as Lag Ba-Omer) is, however,
a joyful day, when marriages are permitted. The origin and significance
of the day are obscure; it has attracted various folkloric practices, particularly
among kabbalists, who consider it to be the anniversary of the
death (or as they euphemistically say the ‘marriage’) of one of their
greatest saints, Simeon bar Yohai, whom they consider to be the author
of their holy book, the Zohar. At his grave in the Galilean village of
Meron they dance around fires singing hymns in his honour, and threeyear-
old children have their hair cut for the first time. In the West there
are no particular observances for Lag Ba-Omer.
The Jewish home: time 103
After the end of the seven weeks of the omer comes the festival of
Pentecost or Shavuot, which is understood to commemorate the giving
of the Torah at Mount Sinai. There are no specific rituals in the home,
but it is customary to decorate the home with greenery and flowers, and
to serve dairy products such as cheesecake or blintses (cheese pancakes).
As on the other pilgrim festivals and Rosh Ha-Shanah, all work is forbidden
and a mood of joyful rest pervades the home.
In the course of the summer three weeks of solemnity are observed,
beginning with the fast of Tammuz (which usually falls in July) and
ending with the fast of the ninth of Av. Weddings are not celebrated
during these three weeks, and some Jews also refrain from buying new
clothes, wearing clean clothes, having their hair cut, or eating meat or
wine on weekdays. (Others only apply these restrictions during the last
nine days, while many, perhaps most, ignore them entirely.)
As the summer proceeds towards its end Jews become increasingly
aware of the approach of the most solemn festivals of the year,Rosh Ha-
Shanah and Yom Kippur. Penitential prayers (selihot) are recited, and it
is customary to visit the graves of parents or close relatives at this time.
Rosh Ha-Shanah means ‘New Year’ (although in the Torah the year is
said to start in the spring, in the month of Passover). This New Year festival
is not, however, a time of uproarious celebration, but of serious
reflection and self-examination. It is also known as Yom Ha-Din, ‘Day
of Judgment’: it is taught that at this time all Jews are judged in relation
to their actions during the preceding year, and that on Yom Kippur, the
Day of Atonement, nine days later, their fate is sealed. The synagogue
liturgy of these Days of Awe is sternly adorned with allusions to God’s
majesty and all-seeing justice. Yet in the home something of the sweetness
of the festival comes out, in the usual festive family meals, and particularly
in the custom of dipping the bread at the beginning of the meal
into honey rather than salt, and then of eating apple dipped in honey,
accompanied with the wish to be granted ‘a good, sweet year’. The loaf
itself is plaited in a round shape rather than the usual elongated form,
perhaps to indicate that like the year it has no real beginning or end.7
But the joyful theme yields to a more sombre mood of repentance in the
Ashkenazi folk ceremony of tashlikh, when Jews go to water, preferably
to a river or the sea where there are fish, and shake their clothes as if to
cast off every trace of sin, while reciting appropriate biblical verses, such
as Micah 7:18–20, which contains the words ‘and you shall cast (tashlikh)
104 The family
17 For other food customs observed on this festival see Roden, The Book of Jewish Food, pp. 27–8.
into the depths of the sea all their sins’. The origin of this practice is
unknown, and there is no mention of it before the fifteenth century: it
may represent a Jewish adaptation of a pagan ritual.
The days from Rosh Ha-Shanah to Yom Kippur are known as the Ten
Days of Penitence, and their mood is unrelievedly chastened. This is the
last opportunity to make amends for sins of commission or omission in
the hope of obtaining a favourable judgment before the heavenly ledgers
are finally closed. Some rise early to recite penitential prayers, and read
improving tracts. It is recommended to seek forgiveness from all those
one may have wronged during the year just elapsed, so as to be able to
concentrate one’s efforts on atoning for sins against God. The third day
of the month is a minor fast, known as the fast of Gedaliah. On the
morning preceding Yom Kippur some still perform the colourful ceremony
known as kapparot, ‘atonements’. A white fowl is taken, a cock for
a man or a hen for a woman, and waved three times round the head,
with the words: ‘This is my substitute, this is my vicarious offering, this
is my atonement. This fowl will go to its death, but may I enjoy a long,
pleasant and peaceful life.’ The bird is then slaughtered, and the meat is
given to the poor, or it is eaten and its value given to the poor in money.
Once widespread, this folk custom was vigorously opposed by Sephardi
rabbis, but it has retained its popularity among Sephardim as well as
Ashkenazim to this day, testifying, like tashlikh, to the persistence of folklore.
Pious Jews also bathe in the mikveh on the eve of the fast, perhaps
as a symbol of the washing away of sins, or in recollection of a celebrated
play on words ascribed to Rabbi Akiva: the prophet Jeremiah
(17:13) calls God the mikveh (meaning ‘hope’) of Israel. ‘As the mikveh
cleanses the unclean, so does the Holy One, blessed be He, cleanse
Israel.’8
The great fast of Yom Kippur is the one day of the Jewish year in
which the home plays no part. Eating and drinking, washing, the use of
unguents and the wearing of leather shoes, and even sexual relations are
forbidden. The scene of activity shifts to the synagogue, and it even used
to be customary for worshippers to remain there all night in prayer,
turning their backs on the comfort of home and bed. The solemn fast is
framed, however, by two family meals, and it is taught by way of discouraging
asceticism that it is as praiseworthy to dine well beforehand as it
is to fast. A candle is lit that will burn throughout the twenty-five hours
of the fast.
The Jewish home: time 105
18 Mishnah, Yoma 8:9.
Immediately after breaking their fast some families make a point of
making a start with the construction of the sukkah, in readiness for the
festival of Tabernacles (Sukkot), which follows only five days later. A
sukkah is a simple, impermanent structure roofed with greenery thin
enough to allow the stars to be glimpsed. It must be built out of doors,
so as to be exposed to the elements, but it is permissible to build it on a
roof or an open balcony. It is made in obedience to the Torah, where
God states (Leviticus 23:42–5): ‘You shall live in huts (sukkot) for seven
days; all native-born Israelites shall live in huts, so that future generations
may know that I made the Israelites live in huts when I brought
them out of the Land of Egypt.’ Theoretically, therefore, one should
take all one’s meals in the sukkah and even sleep in it for the seven days
of the festival. (There is no obligation to do either if the rain is coming
in.) In accordance with the principle of ‘adorning the precepts’ (hiddur
mitsvah) it is customary to decorate the sukkah with flowers and fruit, and
it is also customary to invite guests to share the joy of the sukkah. There
are also invisible holy guests (ushpizin, from the Latin hospites, ‘guests’), the
biblical heroes Abraham, Isaac, Jacob, Joseph, Moses, Aaron and David,
whose presence is welcomed on successive evenings with elaborate greetings
composed by Isaac Luria, the kabbalist of Safed in the sixteenth
century.
The festival week of Tabernacles concludes with the riotous joy of
Simhat Torah (Rejoicing in the Torah). Although the proper place for
this celebration is the synagogue, where the scrolls are lodged, the joyfulness
is so intense that it spills over into the home and even the street,
with singing and dancing, and a certain amount of alcoholic indulgence.
Tabernacles marks the end of an intense and often draining period of
mingled festivities and solemnities, and it is with some sense of relief that
the Jewish family looks forward to the relatively quiet period that follows.
The gloom and darkness of winter are relieved by the eight-day joyfulness
of Hanukkah (meaning ‘dedication’), commemorating the rededication
of the Jerusalem temple by the Maccabees after it had been
desecrated by the Seleucid hellenisers in the second century BCE.
Hanukkah is a minor festival: there is no feasting, and it is not a holiday
from work. The main way it is observed is by lighting oil lamps or
candles, one on the first evening, two on the second, and so on, until on
the eighth evening eight lights are lit. On each evening an additional
‘servant’ light (shammash) is used to light the main lights. Special lamps
or candle-holders (known by the name of menorah or hanukiyyah) are used,
sometimes devised in fanciful styles, and they are placed in a window so
106 The family
as to shine out into the darkness. The lighting of the lamps is accompanied
by special prayers, and the singing of a much-loved hymn, Ma‘oz
Tsur, ‘Fortress, Rock of my salvation, it is pleasant to sing your praise.
Restore my house of prayer, and there we shall offer thanksgiving…’ A
special blessing praises God for ‘performing miracles on those days at
this season’. Among the ancillary customs that have grown up, children
are given gifts of cash, and play gambling games with little spinning tops
inscribed with four Hebrew letters, while their parents may play cards.
Fried foods, such as latkes (potato pancakes), doughnuts or fritters, are
eaten.
A few weeks after Hanukkah comes another minor observance, the
‘new year of trees’, the 15th of Shevat or Tu Bi-Shevat, celebrated by
tree-planting and by eating fruits, particularly those that come from the
land of Israel.
The month of Adar (February/March) is described as the happiest
month of the year, because on the 14th there falls the joyful celebration
of Purim. This is the month that is repeated in intercalated years, and
when this happens Purim falls in the second Adar, so that it is always a
month before Passover. Purim, like Hanukkah, is a minor festival, but its
theme is a major one for Jews: deliverance from persecution. Tradition
lays down various observances, such as a fast on the preceding day and
a feast on the day itself, charitable gifts, and taking food to friends or
neighbours, but the most striking features of the home celebration are
the licence, indeed encouragement, to drink to the point of oblivion, and
a riotous carnival atmosphere, with the wearing of masks and fancy
dress (even cross-dressing, forbidden in the Torah, is tolerated). Children
act out the story of Queen Esther, and three-cornered pastries filled with
poppy seeds, known as ‘Haman’s ears’ or ‘Haman’s pockets’, are traditionally
eaten.
RITES OF PASSAGE
The lifetime of each Jew is marked by joyful or sad ceremonies marking
moments of transition from one status to another. Some of these ceremonies
find an echo in the synagogue and the wider community, but
their primary focus is generally within the home.
The Jewish home is built upon the institution of marriage. It is considered
a binding obligation to ‘be fruitful and multiply’, which is said to
be the first commandment uttered by God to mankind (Genesis 1:28; cf.
9:1, 7); but marriage is also praised as conferring joy, love and harmony.
Rites of passage 107
Both the institution and its ceremonies have evolved considerably over
the centuries. In the West, under Christian influence, there is a certain
tendency for marriages to be performed in synagogue with a rabbi
officiating and delivering an address, and with bridesmaids and a best
man. Traditionally, however, the couple marry each other with no need
of an officiant, and the ceremony may take place at home or even in the
open air. It is performed under a canopy known as a huppah, and the term
huppah has come to be used of the marriage itself. There are many variations
in the details, but the following account, based on the Orthodox
marriage ceremony, includes the most widely followed practices.
A marriage document or ketubah is first drawn up and witnessed,
stating the date and place and recording the husband’s acceptance of his
obligations towards his wife, and the amount that he will pay her if he
divorces her. It includes these words: ‘I faithfully promise that I will be a
true husband to you, I will honour and cherish you, I will work for you,
I will protect and support you, and will provide everything that is necessary
for your due sustenance, as it is fitting for a Jewish husband to do.’
(Reform Judaism favours a reciprocal marriage ceremony and an egalitarian
ketubah.) This legal document, traditionally drawn up in Aramaic,
is sometimes richly illuminated. It is signed by two witnesses. Without a
ketubah it is not strictly legal for husband and wife to live together.
Marriage is an occasion for rejoicing, but it is also a solemn moment
for the bride and bridegroom, and they are supposed to fast from dawn
until the end of the ceremony. Mindful of the serious responsibilities
they are undertaking, when they say their prayers they include a confession
of sins and some penitential passages. It used to be customary for
the bridegroom to wear for the first time during the ceremony the kittel,
the death-robe which he would put on each year at the Passover seder
and the Day of Atonement, and in which he would be buried: this
shroud was a gift from his bride. ‘It is truly a unique wedding gift. It
serves to remind us that in the midst of life we are near death.’9
The bride and bridegroom are escorted to the huppah by their parents,
who stand under the huppah with them, the bride and groom facing
towards the east. The ensuing ceremony is in two parts, representing two
stages which in ancient times were completely separate, the betrothal
(erusin or kiddushin) and the marriage proper (nisuin). After some opening
songs and prayers, the officiant says the blessing over wine and then
recites the benediction for betrothal. The bride and groom sip the wine,
108 The family
19 Maybaum, The Jewish Home, p. 125.
and the groom places a ring on the bride’s right forefinger, saying:
‘Behold, you are betrothed to me by this ring according to the law of
Moses and Israel.’ (In egalitarian marriages there is an exchange of
rings.) The ketubah is then read out, and this concludes the first stage, the
betrothal ceremony. In the second stage seven benedictions are recited,
linking the marriage on the one hand to the creation of mankind and on
the other to the future redemption. The seventh blessing runs as follows:
Blessed are you, Lord our God, king of the universe, who created joy and gladness,
bridegroom and bride, mirth and song, jubilation and merriment, love and
companionship, peace and friendship. Soon, Lord our God, may there be heard
in the cities of Judah and in the streets of Jerusalem sounds of joy and gladness,
the voices of bridegroom and bride, jubilant voices of bridegrooms from their
bridal canopy and of young people feasting and singing. Blessed are you, Lord,
who make the bridegroom rejoice with the bride.
After another sip of wine the bridegroom breaks a glass, an ancient
custom whose significance has been lost. It may have been intended originally
to avert the forces of evil – or perhaps it is to remind the couple
and their guests of the fragility of all happiness. Technically the marriage
is incomplete without being consummated by sexual union, symbolised
by the bride and bridegroom spending some moments together
after the ceremony. (This is known as yihud, ‘unification’.) The marriage
is also incomplete without feasting and dancing. (In very traditional
circles the men and women dance separately.) The meal ends with a
special grace, followed by a repetition of the seven blessings.
A good marriage is a blessed ideal, but Jewish law recognises that
sometimes it cannot be achieved, and makes provision for divorce. The
Jewish attitude to divorce is pragmatic: whatever the attitude may have
been in earlier times, today it is seen as a matter for regret and is only
practised as a last resort, when the marriage has irretrievably broken
down. However, the sources speak of it in a matter-of-fact way, and no
particular stigma attaches to a divorcee. As with the marriage, so with
divorce: it is a matter for the couple themselves and not the state or the
court. A rabbinic court is, however, invoked to ensure that the instrument
of divorce, a document known as the get, is correctly drawn up and
delivered, since any technical fault may render the divorce invalid and
prevent a subsequent remarriage. The get is written by a qualified scribe,
and is delivered by the husband to the wife in the presence of two witnesses,
who sign the document. Once the get has been duly delivered the
parties are free to remarry, just as widows or widowers are.
The birth of a child is a happy event. In fact, as we have seen, it is
Rites of passage 109
considered to be mandatory to have children (defined minimally as a son
and a daughter), and to have a large family has traditionally been seen
as a blessing. Even Orthodox authorities, however, do not rule out birth
control entirely, once the basic command to reproduce has been complied
with, although they tend to limit it to cases where the wife’s life
might be endangered by a pregnancy. Conservative and Reform rabbis
are more lenient.
Traditional Judaism has been more welcoming of boy children than
of girls. The Torah prescribes that a mother is ritually impure for seven
days after giving birth to a son and for twice as long for a daughter, and
there is even a view, also rooted in the Torah, that the periods should be
forty and eighty days respectively. After the birth of a son there is the
excitement and festivity of the circumcision ceremony, when the child
receives his name, together with a series of feasts on the Friday evening
after the birth, a week after the circumcision, and at the age of one
month in the case of a first-born, but there is no such public rejoicing
over a daughter. The Talmud records a statement: ‘Happy is the man
who has male children, and woe to the man who has female children.’
Naturally this kind of sexual discrimination is anathema to the more
liberal wing of Judaism, and even within Orthodoxy some feminists have
rebelled against it and devised ceremonies to mark the birth of a girl.
Circumcision, a minor surgical operation involving the removal of the
prepuce, is a religious obligation devolving upon the father (though he is
usually only too happy to delegate it to a specialist circumciser, termed
a mohel). It is an occasion for rejoicing: it is customary to assemble a gathering
of family and friends, and to serve a festive meal afterwards.
Circumcision is a visible sign of the covenant between God and the
Jewish people (although it should be noted that a son of a Jewish mother
who for whatever reason is not circumcised is still Jewish). It is known in
Hebrew as brit milah, ‘covenant of circumcision’, or more commonly
simply as brit, ‘covenant’. It is therefore the first stage of a process that
will be completed at the age of thirteen when the child comes of age
legally, and takes upon himself the obligations laid down in the Torah.
This being so, it is hardly surprising that both occasions are marked by
festivity and joyfulness. It used to be a custom to embroider the baby’s
swaddling band with his name and the date of the circumcision, and the
hope that he may achieve Bar Mitsvah, marriage and good deeds (a form
of words taken from the blessings recited on this occasion). The band
was donated to the synagogue, where it was used to bind the scroll of the
Torah.
110 The family
The proper age for circumcision is the eighth day, that is the same day
as the birth but a week later (see Genesis 17:12, Leviticus 12:3). However,
this is understood as a minimum age, and the circumcision may be
deferred for reasons of health.
Circumcision may be performed at home, in synagogue, or in any
other place. (If the eighth day falls on Yom Kippur it is performed in
synagogue, since that is where the congregation is assembled.) A couple,
sometimes an engaged or childless couple, are designated as godparents,
and they hand the baby to the sandek, the person who will hold the child
during the proceedings. Before the circumcision the mohel recites a blessing,
and afterwards the father and the mohel both recite special blessings.
The child is then given a Hebrew name, in the form of a patronymic –
N son of N. This is the name by which he will be named all through his
life in synagogue, and which will be inscribed on his ketubah and his
tombstone. The baby is given a drop or two of wine, and the father and
mother drink some wine. (In traditional circles the mother is not present
in the room, and the goblet of wine is taken out to her.) After the festive
meal which follows there is a special form of grace, invoking blessings on
the parents, the child, the mohel and the sandek.
An ancient rite which is still observed by traditionalists is the ‘redemption
of the first-born son’ or pidyon ha-ben. It is performed when the child
is thirty days old, since before that time the life of the new-born child is
not considered to be decisively established. In the Torah God gives this
instruction to Moses: ‘Dedicate to me every first-born, the first fruit of
every womb among the Israelites, whether of human or beast: it is mine’
(Exodus 13:2). This instruction is understood to apply only to male children:
a daughter does not have the status of a first-born. The child is ceremonially
purchased back (the original meaning of ‘redemption’) from
a priest (kohen) who is invited to share in a festive meal. The priest asks
the father whether he prefers to hand over his son or five pieces of silver.
The father hands over five coins, and various blessings are recited.
It is interesting to compare the destiny of the two rituals, circumcision
and the redemption of the first-born. Both are very ancient, being
grounded in the Torah. Both concern new-born babies, an area in which
superstition is rampant. Both are open to similar rational objections:
they are remote from real life in the modern world, and are blatantly
sexist. Additionally, circumcision is aesthetically repugnant to many
people, and carries with it a small but real risk to the health of the child.
For this reason, if one of the two had to die out, it might have been supposed
it would be circumcision. And yet circumcision, even after coming
Rites of passage 111
under outspoken attack in the ninteenth-century Reform movement and
having betrayed countless Jewish men and children to death at the hands
of the Nazis and their collaborators, is maintained by the vast majority
of Jewish families today (even if they often resort in the West to the services
of a surgeon rather than a mohel ), whereas the redemption of the
first-born is all but forgotten. The answer probably lies precisely in the
role of circumcision as a factor in Jewish identity. It has come to be seen
as the outward mark of a Jewish man, and it may be that in an age when
other visible signs of Jewish identity have progressively disappeared it
became all the more important to hang on to this one. Even so critical a
Jew as Spinoza could say: ‘Such great importance do I attach to the sign
of the covenant that I am persuaded that it is sufficient by itself to maintain
the separate existence of the nation for ever.’
The period of childhood runs officially up to the age of twelve for a
girl and thirteen for a boy. Traditional Judaism imposes very few restrictions
on children. They are not considered legally responsible (their
parents carrying the responsibility for their actions). In traditionalist
circles no distinction is made between boys and girls until the age of
three. From this age a girl is protected from being alone with a male aged
nine years or over, and a boy’s hair will now be cut short, with the exception
of the side-curls that are left hanging over the ears, in obedience to
an instruction in the Torah (Leviticus 19:27). He will begin to wear a
skullcap (kippah) on his head, and a fringed undergarment (tallit katan)
under his shirt, and his education will commence. These customs are not
observed by the majority of western Jews.
The education of children is the responsibility of the parents, and
specifically the father. The instruction to teach the Torah ‘to your children’
is repeated twice in the Shma. Unfortunately the Hebrew word for
‘children’ is ambiguous: it can also mean ‘sons’, and there is disagreement
both about the original meaning of the instruction and about the
way in which it should be carried out today. Many traditionalists argue
that only sons should be educated, since the full weight of Jewish observance
falls on them. Traditionally it is true that Jewish education was
largely confined to males. With the breakdown of male dominance of
the religion among Reform and later among Conservative Jews the education
of girls has gradually come to be accepted, at least in the West,
and changing attitudes have begun to percolate into Orthodox circles
too. Nowadays a majority of Jewish girls receive some form of education
about Judaism, although at the more traditional end of the spectrum
it may not be strictly comparable to that dispensed to boys, either
112 The family
in quantity or in content. In some respects traditionalist girls may receive
a broader education than boys, who are expected to concentrate on the
study of the Talmud and the minutiae of the halakhah.
The passage from childhood to adulthood at twelve or thirteen is
marked, at least for boys and increasingly for girls too, by family celebrations
that can sometimes reach exorbitant proportions. From this age,
early though it may seem, Jews are technically of marriageable age, and
in traditional societies the broking of a suitable match becomes a prominent
preoccupation of the parents, particularly for daughters. The professional
matchmaker (shadkhan) used to be a familiar figure in the ghetto;
his activity has been replaced not only by the amateur efforts of family
and friends but by specialised Jewish dating agencies. Jewish youth clubs,
of a religious, political or sporting nature, play their part in helping to
bring about suitable matches, which in practice means ensuring that
Jews marry other Jews. There is understandable anxiety about the future
of Judaism in an open society, particularly in the absence of any real tradition
of growth through conversion, and exogamy (generally referred
to as ‘marrying out’, ‘intermarriage’, or in a vaguer way as ‘assimilation’)
is seen instinctively by many as the main threat. This is the reason why
membership of Jewish youth clubs is frequently restricted to Jews, a
restriction that occasionally gives rise to misunderstanding and even
resentment. In Israel the state makes no provision for marriage between
members of different religious communities; although this policy is no
doubt effective up to a point in limiting exogamy, it is perceived by many
as an intolerable curb on personal freedom, and there are increasingly
vocal demands for it to be abandoned. In any case, Jewish Israelis who
are determined to marry non-Jews may do so abroad, in which case their
marriage is recognised in Israel. Young Jews sometimes complain of the
pressures that are put on them to marry, and specifically to marry Jews.
Even homosexuality is not taken very seriously as a valid reason for not
marrying. Orthodox authorities tend to insist that homosexuals are
subject to the requirement to ‘be fruitful and multiply’, and in current
debates about homosexuality and Judaism one often has the impression
that the sin of wilful childlessness is a more cogent objection than the
Torah’s prohibition on sexual relations between men.
One way round the threat to the Jewish family posed by exogamy is
to welcome the non-Jewish marriage partner into the wider family, and
provide pressure and support for the children of the marriage to be
brought up as Jews. As recently as a generation or two ago it was not
uncommon for Jewish parents to go into mourning for a child who
Rites of passage 113
‘married out’, and cut off all relations. Rabbinic authorities refused to
entertain applications for conversion to Judaism on the grounds of marriage,
invoking an old law stating that conversion could not be countenanced
if the convert received a benefit as a result. Nowadays these
attitudes have virtually disappeared, at least in the West. Traditional law
recognises the children of a non-Jewish father and a Jewish mother as
Jews in every respect. Such Jews are an ever-growing element within
Jewish communities today, and attitudes and institutions are having to
adapt to accommodate them. Their non-Jewish parents are increasingly
welcomed, and even encouraged to play a part in the life of the community
as they do in the family. The more radical wing of the Reform movement
(and this includes the numerically dominant American Reform
movement) goes further, and recognises the children of a Jewish father
and a non-Jewish mother as Jewish, under certain conditions. Some
Conservative Jews are sympathetic to this realignment, which in addition
to its practical benefits in terms of Jewish demography eliminates a
provision which is easily attacked as needlessly discriminating between
the sexes.
As for the expedient of conversion, this is positively encouraged by
many rabbis, in preference to ‘marrying out’, and the vast majority of
cases of conversion heard by rabbinic courts fall into this category. The
preparation of prospective converts is slanted towards the setting up of
a Jewish home, and the Jewish marriage partner is encouraged to share
in the convert’s studies. Although it would be wrong to deny that some
prejudice, the legacy of centuries, still exists among Jews against converts,
it is breaking down very fast in the face of the contemporary situation,
and members of Reform congregations will freely admit that
converts are among the most knowledgeable, active and committed
members of the community.
The emphasis on having children is not simply a matter of natural
instinct, obedience to the Torah, or concern for the future of the Jewish
community. In many people’s minds a function of children is to look
after their parents in sickness or old age, to ensure that they are properly
buried, and to recite the Kaddish prayer in their memory. There is an
obligation on children, throughout their lives, to ‘honour and fear’ their
parents. This is explained as encompassing such things as standing up
when they come into the room, ensuring that they are clothed and fed,
not contradicting them, losing one’s temper with them, or putting them
to shame, and speaking of them with respect, even after their death.
Death is part of life, and it is accepted in Judaism as an inevitable
114 The family
aspect of the human condition. Everything possible must be done to
promote health and save life, and killing is viewed with abhorrence; but
Jewish teachers have insisted that one should not be afraid to die or be
angry about it, but should accept one’s death, whatever the circumstances.
On hearing news of a death the Jew is supposed to respond with
the words ‘Blessed be the true judge’, affirming one’s confidence in the
justice of God’s decrees, however hard it may be to accept the individual
verdict.
A Jew who senses the approach of death and is able to do so recites a
confession. The following form of words is found in prayer books, and
Nahmanides (1194–1270) says that it was already old in his day:
I acknowledge before you, Lord my God and God of my ancestors, that both
my cure and my death are in your hands. May it be your will to send me a
perfect healing. Yet if my death is fully determined by you, I will lovingly accept
it from your hand. May my death be an atonement for all the sins, iniquities and
transgressions that I have committed before you. Grant me some of the great
happiness that is stored up for the righteous. Make known to me the path of life.
In your presence is fullness of joy; at your right hand bliss for evermore.
Other prayers may be said, and as the end approaches those present
recite the following verses aloud, concluding with the opening words of
the Shma, the declaration of God’s unity that all pious Jews long to say
as they expire:
The Lord reigns, the Lord reigned, the Lord shall reign for ever and ever.
Blessed be the name of His glorious reign for ever and ever.
The Lord, He is God.
Hear, Israel, the Lord our God, the Lord is One.
A dying person should never be left alone, and those present have an
obligation to treat him or her with consideration and respect, and to
avoid doing anything that might hasten death. Euthanasia is considered
to be murder, although some rabbis have argued that there is no obligation
to keep someone alive mechanically who is not capable of independent
life, particularly if the patient is in pain. It is also widely accepted
that pain-killing drugs may be administered even if they have the indirect
effect of hastening death.
According to classical halakhic sources, the cessation of breathing
marks the moment of death. Since the concept of ‘brain death’ emerged
in the late 1960s there has been some rabbinic discussion of the possible
need to revise the old definition, particularly in relation to the vexed
question of organ transplantation.
Rites of passage 115
Once death has been established the eyes of the corpse are closed,
preferably by a son, and it is carefully placed on the floor. A dead body
must be handled with the same respect as is due to a living person. It is
not stripped naked, but is always decently covered, and it is not disturbed
more than is necessary. It is not left alone, but traditionally ‘watchers’
(shomrim), who may be relatives or friends, stay with it until the burial,
reciting psalms.
Mourning is governed by very strict rules. Those who have observed
them tend to agree that they are a help rather than an intrusion. They
provide reassurance, and a framework for conducting oneself at what
can otherwise be a time of aimlessness and uncertainty. The object of
the rules is not to stifle or contain grief, but rather to provide support to
the mourners and to help them over their time of trial and back into
normal life.
The definition of a mourner is a father, mother, son, daughter,
brother, sister, husband or wife of the deceased. Children under Bar/Bat
Mitsvah age do not observe mourning, and there is no mourning or
formal burial for an infant under thirty days old. (Informal rites of grieving
for still-born babies and for infants are now being devised, because
of a recognition that the parents need some means of channelling their
grief.) Sons or daughters are distinguished from other mourners in a
number of ways. For example, mourners have their clothes torn as a
mark of grief: for sons and daughters this is done on the left, near the
heart, while for other mourners it is done on the right side. (Nowadays,
since people tend to object to expensive clothes being torn, the tearing
is often done on a tie or a ribbon. Reform Judaism has abandoned the
practice of tearing altogether.) The period of mourning extends to a
year for one’s parent; other mourners only mourn for a month.
Mourning proper only begins from the funeral. In the period between
death and burial the mourner is known as an onen, and is not subjected
to many particular rules, but, on the contrary, is relieved of religious obligations
such as reciting prayers or saying the blessings before and after
food. An onen should not drink wine, eat meat, indulge in luxuries or
pleasures, or conduct business or professional activities. The main
concern of the onen is to make arrangements for the funeral.
On returning home from the cemetery the mourner (who is now
known as an avel) is offered a plate of food, which generally includes
hard-boiled eggs and other round foods. It is customary to light a candle
which will burn for the next seven days. Some people cover the mirrors
in the house of mourning, or turn them to face the wall.
116 The family
Mourning comes in three stages. The first, and most intense, lasts for
seven days, and is known as Shivah (‘seven’). In fact, since the day of the
funeral counts as the first day and Shivah ends one hour into the seventh
day, it actually lasts rather less than six days; moreover on the Sabbath
no outward signs of mourning are observed. If a festival falls during the
period the Shivah ceases and is not resumed. During Shivah the mourners
remain at home and sit on low stools (whence the popular expression
‘to sit Shivah’). They do not work or attend to their business affairs, have
sexual intercourse, bathe, use cosmetics or creams, shave or have their
hair cut. It is customary not to study Torah. After three days the rules
are relaxed a little, and those who must go back to work may do so.
Prayers are held in the house of mourning, and friends gather, to offer
condolences, show solidarity, and provide a congregation so that the
Kaddish may be said. The mourners are not expected to act as hosts:
friends often bring food, and take it on themselves to serve it, and to
underline this reversal of the norms there is a tradition, still observed by
some, that a mourner receives greetings but does not initiate them.
The next period, Shloshim (‘thirty’), continues until the morning of
the thirtieth day after the funeral. During this phase mourners continue
to refrain from shaving and having their hair cut, they do not listen to
music and do not attend weddings or parties. (The restrictions on
shaving and hair-cutting are often ignored today, and even Orthodox
Jews sometimes cease to observe them after the Shivah.) At the end of
the Shloshim mourning is at an end, except for children of the deceased
who continue until twelve months after the death.
The date of death is commemorated each year by lighting a memorial
candle and reciting Kaddish. This is known among Ashkenazim by
the Yiddish name yortsait or yahrzeit (‘year-time’). In Britain it is customary
to say to mourners at this time, ‘I wish you long life’.
As the preceding pages show, there are ample opportunities not only
on special occasions but in daily life too for Jews to remind themselves of
their distinctive heritage and destiny. The various rituals have the power
to bring Jews closer to God, and also closer to their family and friends,
and indeed to their ancestors too. In traditional Jewish life these reminders
are ever-present. Boys and men wear a head-covering and fringes
all the time, and the very traditional wear distinctive clothing. Women
observe the rules of tseniut, ‘modesty’, keeping their bodies covered with
the exception of hands and faces. Married women have shaven heads,
and many wear a wig known as a sheitel. There are blessings to be said
not only over different kinds of food and drink, but for example on
Rites of passage 117
seeing an unusual sight, or on hearing good or bad news. The majority
of Jews, however, do not adhere to the whole of this rich and distinctive
tradition. Many lead lives which are almost indistinguishable from those
of their gentile neighbours
CHAPTER SIX
The community
THE JEWISH COMMUNITY AND HOW IT WORKS
If the family and the home constitute one focus of Judaism in the world,
the community and the synagogue constitute the other. The difference
between the home and the synagogue is the difference between the
private and the public sphere. These two are impossible to separate in
the life of the individual Jew. The life of the home leaves spaces which
are to be filled by the synagogue and public observance. The home
observances of Yom Kippur, for example, the two family meals, frame
the long hours of synagogue worship. Equally the synagogue leaves
room for the home. And the two spheres sometimes break in on each
other: when the family go to synagogue and pray together, as they now
can in Reform and Conservative synagogues, and particularly when they
gather to celebrate a family occasion such as the birth of a baby, a Bar
Mitsvah or a marriage; or when the community gathers in a house of
mourning to express their solidarity with their grieving fellow members
and to make up a minyan for the recitation of the Kaddish.
The concept of the minyan is at the heart of the traditional distinction
between private and public. The Hebrew word minyan simply means
a number, but it is used to refer to the number required to make up a
congregation for public worship. The old rule is that a minimum of ten
adult male Jews are required for the recitation of certain prayers, particularly
the Kaddish. Conservative rabbis, seeking to remedy some of the
more offensive distinctions between the sexes in the old halakhah, allow
adult women to be counted in the minyan. Of course in large communities
the congregation is often far greater than a bare minyan: it may
consist of hundreds or exceptionally even thousands of worshippers. But
even in large gatherings the concept of minyan has its role to play. The
worshippers do not all arrive simultaneously, and it is convenient to have
a clear and incontrovertible definition of when enough people have
119
arrived to allow public worship to begin. Traditionally it has been considered
meritorious to be one of the minyan, that is to be among the first
ten men to arrive at the synagogue. To make up a minyan is particularly
important in small communities, where public prayer may have to be
suspended if the crucial number of ten is not reached. Hence the old
institution of the ‘minyan man’, a poor Jew who was paid to attend services
and make up the numbers. Reform Judaism has abolished the
whole concept of the minyan: prayers may be said with any number
present, and services begin at advertised times. This obviates some problems,
particularly for small communities, but at the cost of blurring the
distinction between private and public.
Apart from the regular worship of the synagogue a minyan may
gather in any suitable place to say the public prayers. The obvious
example of this is the minyan that gathers in a house of mourning.
Another, more joyful, example is the recitation of the seven blessings at
dinner on one of the seven days following a wedding. In fact in the
ordinary grace after food the presence of a minyan is marked by a
special opening formula. But a group of people who happen to be
together for whatever purpose, for example for a meeting, or because
they work nearby, may decide to constitute a minyan to say their
prayers together.
This minyan may sometimes develop into a fixed gathering that
becomes in a sense an alternative to the regular synagogue worship. It
may grow in time into a fully fledged synagogue: many synagogues have
begun in this way. But the members may well feel that ‘small is beautiful’,
and foster the intimacy of a small minyan.
The synagogue is the visible side of the Jewish community. The community
in turn is made up of a number of families and individuals. The
word ‘synagogue’ in fact can be used to refer to the community rather
than the building. Despite what is sometimes said to the contrary, this is
not a modern development aping the Christian use of the word ‘church’,
but goes right back to the origins of the word ‘synagogue’, which is a
Greek word originally meaning an assembly. In Greek Jewish texts from
the ancient world (especially outside the Land of Israel) ‘synagogue’
usually means the community of the Jews.
Each synagogue is autonomous, since Judaism acknowledges no
central human spiritual authority, and no overarching organisation.
There may well be two or more synagogues in a single town; many more
in a big city, representing different quarters of the town, or different
origins of the members, or different religious ideologies. Sometimes one
120 The community
synagogue is technically a branch of another. In some cities or countries
some or all of the synagogues may be brought together under a single
communal structure. For example, in London many of the Orthodox
Ashkenazi synagogues share a common organisation, the United
Synagogue. In Paris both Ashkenazi and Sephardi synagogues belong to
the Consistoire. The United Synagogue of America is an association of
Conservative synagogues. Whatever the relationship between the synagogues,
however, members are free to transfer their membership from
one synagogue to another, to belong to more than one at the same time,
or to worship occasionally or even regularly in a synagogue they do not
formally belong to. It may even happen that members of the same
family belong to different synagogues.
It is considered meritorious to help to found or run a synagogue, to
attend its services and to contribute generously to its charitable funds. A
special prayer is said after the reading of the Torah calling down God’s
blessing on
those who unite to form synagogues for prayer, and those who gather in them
to pray; also those who provide lamps for lighting and wine for Kiddush and
Havdalah, food for wayfarers and alms for the poor, and all who occupy themselves
loyally with the needs of the community.
A synagogue is generally administered by a council and by honorary
officers (chairman or president, secretary, treasurer and so forth), who
are members, elected by the membership. (The right of women to vote
or hold office is a matter under debate in Orthodoxy.) There may also
be wardens (gabbaim), who supervise the smooth running of the services.
It is conventional to refer to these persons collectively as the lay leadership,
to distinguish them from the rabbi and his or her assistants, but it
should be noted in passing that there is no foundation in Judaism for this
distinction, which is borrowed from Christian usage and suggests that
the religious leadership enjoys a priestly status which the lay leadership
does not share. Priesthood in Judaism has a very specific meaning: it is
an inherited status, implying direct descent from Aaron, the brother of
Moses. A priest (kohen) traditionally enjoys certain privileges, a residue of
the remote period when priests were responsible for the administration
of the sacrificial cult in the Temple, such as the right to be called up first
to the reading of the Torah in synagogue and to pronounce the priestly
blessing (Numbers 6:24–6) over the congregation; and he is subject to
certain restrictions, for example he may not come into contact with a
corpse except a close relative, and he may not marry a divorcee. (In
The Jewish community and how it works 121
Reform Judaism both the privileges and the restrictions have been
abolished as having no significance and drawing unnecessary and inappropriate
distinctions among Jews.) Priests exercise no authority by
virtue of this hereditary status, and there is no connection whatever
between the priesthood and the rabbinate: a priest may become a rabbi,
in which case he is a rabbi like any other rabbi and a priest like any other
priest. Besides the priests (kohanim) there are the Levites (leviim), the
remaining descendants of the tribe of Levi, to which Moses and Aaron
belonged. Levites are called up second in the synagogue, after a priest,
and they wash the priests’ hands before the priestly blessing. If the term
‘layman’ has any sense in Judaism it ought to refer to the ordinary
‘Israelites’ who are neither priests nor Levites. In fact, however, this
usage has never suggested itself, presumably because the distinction is
such an unimportant one in practice.
What is a rabbi, then, if he is not a priest? The title seems to have originated
around the time the Temple was destroyed, to denote someone
distinguished for his scholarship and powers of leadership, within the
movement that we nowadays call ‘rabbinic Judaism’ which is the ancestor
of virtually all the forms of Judaism current today. The rabbis
retrospectively bestowed the rabbinic title on Moses, calling him Moshe
Rabbenu, ‘Moses our rabbi’, presumably because they considered him
to embody in a very high degree the distinguishing qualities mentioned
above.
Originally there seems to have been a formal recognition or ordination
of new rabbis, symbolised by a laying on of hands (semikhah). Only
those who had been ordained in this way were able to use the rabbinic
title. Eventually the practice of ordination ceased and the title was given
to any teacher of Torah. Much later, in the Middle Ages, a new form of
ordination was instituted among the Ashkenazim, in which a prominent
scholar examined a candidate in his competence in Jewish law, and if
satisfied issued him with a licence to issue decisions (heter horaah). It has
been suggested that this system was borrowed from the nascent universities,
from which Jews were excluded. Contemporary rabbinic ordination
derives in part from this institution, and, particularly in the more
traditional wing of Judaism, the sources of rabbinic law still play an
enormous part in the rabbi’s education. After the emancipation,
however, new-style rabbinic seminaries were established, at first in
Europe and later in the United States, which aimed to impart a much
broader education in Jewish history and thought, and to train rabbis for
their new role as preachers and spiritual leaders. These modern rabbis
122 The community
were also encouraged to obtain a university education in addition to
their study at the seminary.
In the meantime an important change had occurred affecting the
basic character of the rabbinate. Originally, Torah study had been an
end in itself and an obligation on all Jews, and it was felt to be wrong to
earn one’s livelihood from it. Great rabbis like Maimonides earned their
living as physicians or from some trade. From the sixteenth century,
however, it became commoner for a community to employ a rabbi as its
legal authority and religious leader, and in this way the rabbinate
became a profession. After the emancipation in Europe the rabbinate
became assimilated more and more to the model of the Christian ministry,
and we even find a hierarchical system growing up, in which Chief
Rabbis are recognised by the state as the spiritual heads of the Jewish
community, and come to exert authority over other rabbis, a development
which has no basis in Jewish law or tradition. Many rabbis are
employed by synagogues to offer religious leadership and provide a wide
range of services to the community.
Not all rabbis are rabbis: some of those who hold rabbinic appointments
may not hold a rabbinic qualification, and some of those who are
qualified as rabbis have no communal rabbinic appointment. In
England for a long time there was no rabbinic ordination, and the graduates
of the seminary, Jews’ College, were given the title ‘Rev.’, which
sounded attractively similar to rav or rabbi. Today, in a dwindling community
which invests heavily in rabbinic education at both ends of the
religious spectrum, there is a growing number of people entitled to call
themselves ‘rabbi’ who do not, for a variety of reasons, choose the rabbinate
as their profession.
Until recently, in keeping with the general character of Judaism at the
time, the rabbinate was reserved to men. In the present century women
have played an increasingly prominent role in religious leadership (particularly
prominent in the British Liberal movement, where Lily
Montagu was a rabbi in all but name). The Reform seminary in Berlin
ordained a woman rabbi in the 1930s, but she was killed by the Nazis and
after the war the impetus was lost, and it was some time before the issue
came to the forefront of discussion again. With the growth of Jewish
feminism in the late 1960s pressure began for the ordination of women
as rabbis, at first in the Reconstructionist and Reform movements. In
1972 the Reform movement in America ordained its first woman rabbi;
the British Reform movement and the American Conservative movement
followed suit in 1975 and 1985 respectively. In these liberal
The Jewish community and how it works 123
movements the rabbinical seminaries now have more or less equal
numbers of male and female students. Orthodoxy has yet to take the
plunge, although the subject is under discussion at the more liberal
fringe of the movement.
Sephardim have tended to prefer the title Hakham (‘sage’) in preference
to Rabbi, but the history of the institution is similar. In the
Ottoman Empire the hakhamim exercised communal leadership within
the millet system regulating minorities, and there was a kind of chief
rabbi, the Haham Bashı. In England the title Hakham is reserved for the
leading rabbi. In recent times the Sephardi rabbinate has tended to
follow the model provided by the numerically superior Ashkenazi sector,
and many Sephardi rabbis have received part or all of their training in
Ashkenazi seminaries or yeshivot.
Besides the rabbi, traditional Judaism evolved various parallel or subordinate
offices, some of which lend themselves to confusion with the
rabbinate. The first is the preacher or Maggid. In eastern Europe the
town rabbi normally only preached twice a year, on the Great Sabbath
before Passover and the Sabbath of Repentance between Rosh Ha-
Shanah and Yom Kippur. The Maggid was often an itinerant preacher,
who was rewarded for his services by each community where he
preached; some larger communities maintained a permanent Maggid.
Hasidism introduced a new type of religious leader, the Tsaddik, often
known as a rebbe to distinguish him from the rabbi in the normal sense
(though the two words share the same etymology). Some rebbes also
served as town rabbis, but they exercised a charismatic leadership over
a following that was often widely scattered, in distinction to the rabbis,
whose authority was strictly local. The Hasidim established a principle
of hereditary succession for rebbes, which has sometimes been imitated
in non-Hasidic circles. The Tsaddik or rebbe demanded complete submission
from his followers, and his authority was based not on his learning
but on his spiritual stature, which could sometimes border on the
supernatural. Some were even said to work miracles, and holiness was
thought to attach to the food they had blessed or their cast-off clothes.
They are believed to have the power to intercede for their followers after
their death, and some followers of the late Lubavitcher Rebbe became
convinced that he was the Messiah and would return after his death.
This is all far removed from the authority of the rabbi, and yet for the
outside observer it is all too easy to confuse a Hasidic rebbe with a rabbi.
In eastern Europe the office of principal of the yeshivah (Talmudic
academy) became detached from the town rabbinate, and with the pro-
124 The community
liferation of yeshivot attracting students from far and wide yet another
religious leader came into being, the Rosh Yeshivah (‘Yeshivah Head’),
who was often a scholar renowned for his academic knowledge of the
law. Even within modern Orthodoxy, former yeshivah students may consider
their Rosh Yeshivah to be their true spiritual guide, even while recognising
the practical authority of their local rabbi. A certain rivalry
sometimes arises between yeshivah heads and rabbis, or even Chief
Rabbis.
A synagogue service does not need to be conducted by a rabbi. Any
congregant may lead the prayers (although Orthodoxy does not permit
women to lead men in prayer). In keeping with the trend to transform
the rabbi into a minister of religion, conducting services has come to be
part of the function of a modern rabbi, at least at the more liberal end
of the spectrum. In some larger synagogues this role belongs to the hazan
or cantor, a salaried official chosen for his musical abilities as well as his
good character.
THE SYNAGOGUE
The word ‘synagogue’, as we have already seen, comes from the Greek.
The Hebrew term is Bet Kneset, ‘house of assembly’. Many Ashkenazi
Jews refer to it by the Yiddish term shool, meaning a school. This may
reflect the fact that the synagogue sometimes doubled as a house of
study, although that is strictly a separate institution, called in Hebrew Bet
Ha-Midrash. The word kloyz (related to ‘cloister’ in English) was formerly
used in central and eastern Europe for a synagogue, or for a house
of study that doubled as a synagogue. Some Jewish communities use the
term ‘temple’ in preference to ‘synagogue’. This usage originated in
eighteenth-century Europe, probably under the influence of French
Protestantism; it gained currency in the nineteenth-century Reform
movement, which was attracted by its allusion to the ancient Temple in
Jerusalem. American Reform has retained the term, and it has been
adopted by some Conservative congregations.
Synagogues come in all shapes and sizes, and there are no particular
architectural requirements. They tend to reflect local architectural
trends, sometimes flirting with church or mosque architecture and sometimes
deliberately avoiding it. In the medieval period they were often
small and discreetly located, so as not to attract attention to themselves.
The Hasidim in Poland, barred from the synagogues, chose to worship
intimately in a little room called a shtibl. In the course of the nineteenth
The synagogue 125
century grand ‘cathedral’ synagogues were built in the large cities of
Europe and America, reflecting the size, wealth and self-assurance of the
post-emancipation communities. The favoured styles belonged to the
classic European repertoire, but Gothic was deliberately avoided (presumably
it was regarded as too ‘churchy’), and Romanesque and the
vaguely exotic Byzantine and unambiguously oriental Moorish idioms
were preferred. Jews were slow to penetrate the architectural profession,
and many of these grandiose synagogues were built by gentiles. In
Britain the first Jewish synagogue architect was David Mocatta, a pupil
of Sir John Soane and well known as a railway architect. Mocatta
designed a synagogue at Ramsgate for his cousin Sir Moses Montefiore
and two successive buildings for the fledgling London Reform congregation,
of which he was himself a founder member and Chairman of
the Council. The present handsome building of the congregation was
built, with advice from Mocatta, by Henry Davis and Barrow Emanuel,
who also designed other London synagogues. A similar story could be
told elsewhere. The twentieth century has been marked by a more
adventurous approach, and some very interesting and unusual synagogues
have been built, such as Frank Lloyd Wright’s synagogue at
Elkins Park, near Philadelphia, or Heinz Rau’s white dome for the
Hebrew University in Jerusalem.
Synagogues frequently identify themselves on the outside by means of
a Hebrew inscription or some Jewish symbol such as a six-pointed star
of David or a seven-branched candelabrum (menorah). Internally, the
dominant feature is the holy ark (aron ha-kodesh, or in Sephardi usage
heikhal or ekhal), which normally occupies the middle of the wall closest
to Jerusalem. The ark usually has the form of a tall cupboard with
double doors opening outwards. Above it hangs a lamp known as the
eternal light (ner tamid), and in Ashkenazi synagogues a curtain (parokhet)
hangs in front of the ark. The only other prominent feature is a flat or
sloping desk on which the scroll of the Torah is placed when it is opened
for the reading. This stands on a raised dais (known as bimah, almemar, or
among Sephardim tebah), reached by steps and often partly enclosed by
railings or a balustrade.
The need to accommodate these two elements – the ark, placed
against one wall, and the reading desk, which was often located in the
centre of the synagogue – imposed awkward constraints on the design,
particularly in terms of the seating. Traditional synagogues often have
wooden pews arranged in the long axis of the hall, facing the reading
desk which takes up a large part of the centre. This arrangement suits
126 The community
the reading of the Torah, but means that congregants must make a 90°
turn when the ark is opened or when they face Jerusalem to recite the
Amidah. An alternative arrangement, pioneered by the Reform movement
but now found in other kinds of synagogue too, combines the ark
and reading desk on a single platform at one end of the building, leaving
the rest of the hall free for seating and obviating the need to turn.
Traditional and Orthodox synagogues have separate seating for men
and women; often the women are relegated to a gallery or separated
from the men by a screen or other physical barrier (mehitsah), but in
extreme cases they are placed in a separate room where they are completely
hidden from male worshippers.
THE WORSHIP OF THE SYNAGOGUE
Like the architecture of the synagogue, the style of worship is very variable.
It can be very grand and formal, with wardens in top hats and tailcoats,
strict decorum and sublime organ music and choral singing; or at
the other end of the spectrum, as in a Hasidic shtibl, it can be intimate
and homespun, do-it-yourself and raucous, with congregants arriving at
intervals throughout the service and chatting uninhibitedly to one
another. Most services fall somewhere between the two.
Although the prayers may be led by a rabbi, they do not have to be,
and often are not. In a smaller traditional synagogue the male congregants
may well take it in turn to serve as shaliah tsibbur, literally the ‘communal
delegate’ who leads the prayers. In larger synagogues there is
often a salaried reader or cantor.
The language of prayer has been a hotly debated issue. The Talmud
allows prayers to be said in any language, but throughout the Middle
Ages it was universally accepted that the only language suitable for
public prayer was Hebrew. Some German Reformers at the beginning
of the nineteenth century promoted prayer in German, seeing in the
Hebrew language an obstacle to understanding and therefore to true
spirituality, and also a barrier between Jew and gentile. Even Orthodox
modernists favoured a greater understanding of the prayers, and printed
prayer books with facing English translations. The leading Reformer
Abraham Geiger was ambivalent. He referred to Hebrew as a ‘foreign
dead language’, and maintained that most German Jews were more
affected by German prayers than by Hebrew ones; yet he had a deep
love for the Hebrew language, and used it in his synagogue. The important
rabbinical conference at Frankfurt in 1845, under Geiger’s
The worship of the synagogue 127
influence, declared that while there was no objective legal necessity for
retaining Hebrew in the service, yet it was subjectively necessary to do so.1
In a further vote it became clear that a slight majority was in favour of
eventually replacing Hebrew by German or using the two languages side
by side. This was not acceptable to Zacharias Frankel, the leader of the
most conservative wing, and he withdrew from the conference; ever
since, the attitude to Hebrew in the synagogue has been one of the issues
dividing Reform from Conservative Jews. But even within the Reform
movement the attitude has been by no means unambiguous or unanimous.
British Reform, for example, has tended to favour a half-and-half
mix, and has retained the tradition of printing its bilingual prayer books
starting from the right, like Hebrew books, while Liberal Judaism in
Britain at first virtually eliminated Hebrew, and its prayer books opened
from the left like English books. When Isaac Mayer Wise, the great
pioneer of Reform in America, issued his new prayer book Minhag
America in 1857, it contained a totally Hebrew text opening from the
right, and a separate English or German translation opening at the left.
Those congregations that wished to do so could pray entirely or mainly
in the vernacular, and this became increasingly common in Reform congregations.
In the twentieth century, however, there was a notable return
to the use of Hebrew: the Columbus Platform of 1937 included the use
of Hebrew among the elements of tradition it proclaimed were required
by a Jewish way of life, and the later emergence of a symbiosis between
Reform and Zionism, with its strong espousal of the Hebrew language,
further strengthened the place of Hebrew in Reform Judaism.
There are several different traditions of Hebrew pronunciation, most
of which may be included under one of two main headings, Ashkenazi
and Sephardi. While many of the differences between them are
superficial and can be ascribed to the influence of Germanic and Slavic
languages on the former and languages such as Spanish and Arabic on
the latter, there are some very distinctive features that may go back to
ancient dialects. In particular, one of the vowels pronounced a by
Sephardim is pronounced o by Ashkenazim, and one of the consonants
pronounced s by Ashkenazim is pronounced t by Sephardim. (Thus
Ashkenazim will say kashrus, sukkoh, sukkos, matsoh, where the Sephardi
pronunciation followed in this book has kashrut, sukkah, sukkot, matsah.)
The Zionist movement adopted the Sephardi pronunciation, and it is
the official pronunciation of Israel. For that reason it is tending to
128 The community
11 See Michael A. Meyer, Response to Modernity, pp. 96–7, 137.
encroach on the Ashkenazi pronunciation in synagogues both in Israel
and abroad. The Reform movement has had a predilection for the
Sephardi pronunciation from the outset.
Music was another issue dividing traditionalists and modernisers in
the nineteenth century. Instrumental music was not used in the medieval
synagogue, and the prayers and hymns were usually chanted to traditional
melodies. The reading of the Torah and the Haftarah
(prophetic reading) had their own traditions of cantillation. A greater
emphasis on beautiful music is discernible from the sixteenth century on,
the first known composer of synagogue music being Salamone Rossi (c.
1570–1628) of Mantua. Meanwhile the Lurianic kabbalists of Safed sang
melodies to beautify the prayers and to help them concentrate on their
mystical meanings. Later the Hasidim composed their own melodies or
adapted current folksongs, and cultivated music enthusiastically in their
quest for ecstasy. A distinctive Hasidic contribution is the wordless
melody (niggun). All over Europe, as Jews became acquainted with the
music of the world around them, the synagogue cantors (hazzanim)
became more self-conscious and ambitious, and some combined synagogal
with operatic careers. Such was the case, for example, of Meyer
Leoni (1740–96), cantor at the Great Synagogue in London, who was
fired for singing in a performance of Handel’s Messiah. More recently
the Polish cantor Gershon Sirota (1877–1943), ‘the Jewish Caruso’, was
a popular performer in the concert hall. In Europe of the emancipation
era a great deal of synagogue music was composed, particularly for
Reform temples with their organ and choir. The best-known composers
of the time, such as Salomon Sulzer (1804–90) of Vienna, Samuel
Naumbourg (1815–80) of Paris and Louis Lewandowski (1821–94) of
Berlin, successfully blended traditional eastern European Jewish elements
with the dominant musical styles of their day. The nineteenthcentury
heritage still dominates synagogue music today, although
twentieth-century composers have added their contributions, and many
congregations have deliberately chosen to move away from art music
towards more traditional styles of cantorial or congregational singing.
The congregation is made up of men, women and children. In traditional
Judaism their respective roles are strictly defined.Women sit apart
from men, as we have already seen, separated by a mehitsah, a barrier or
screen. Attendance by women is not particularly encouraged, and at
some services, for example on Sabbath eve, it is usual for women to stay
at home and for men and male children only to go to the service. Some
Orthodox synagogues remain close to this traditional model; others
The worship of the synagogue 129
encourage the attendance of women and reduce the mehitsah to a symbolic
railing, but the women are still observers who cannot lead the
prayers or take any other part in the conduct of the services. In most
Conservative and in Reform and Reconstructionist synagogues women
and men may sit together. As for children, their attendance is encouraged
(particularly in the case of boys) in traditional services, and the segregation
of the sexes is not strictly applied to small children. They do not
take an active part in the conduct of the service, except for one mystical
hymn, the Song of Glory, which is commonly led by a small boy. Some
early Reform synagogues, attempting to impose a proper decorum on
the services, forbade parents to bring small children, but nowadays most
Reform synagogues welcome children.
Another demand of the early Reformers was that congregants should
wear clean and respectable clothes. Traditional Judaism too commends
cleanliness and the wearing of fine clothes on Sabbaths and festivals, but
evidently standards had slipped by the early nineteenth century, and in
some traditional services today sartorial elegance does not seem to be
highly prized. In fact there has been a general relaxation of dress codes
in all but the most formal synagogues. Men traditionally cover their
heads with a hat or skullcap and wear the tallit, the fringed prayer shawl.
The tallit is not worn in the evening, except on the eve of Yom Kippur.
On weekday mornings men put on tefillin, phylacteries, to pray. Women
and children do not wear tefillin or tallit, in fact in some Ashkenazi communities
men do not wear the tallit until they are married. Married
women cover their heads. On Yom Kippur men may wear the white
tunic, the kittel. All this is the traditional practice, which is still observed
in many Orthodox congregations. With the rise of feminism, however,
many women have taken to wearing the tallit, even in Orthodox synagogues,
although it is frowned on by most of the all-male Orthodox
rabbinate. In Reform Judaism, at least in its more radical manifestations,
including American Reform and Liberal Judaism in England, headcovering,
tallit and tefillin were all abandoned, but there has been a return to
the skullcap and tallit recently.2
Congregants are seated for most of the service and for the readings,
standing when the ark is open and when the scroll is elevated and to say
the Amidah and certain other prayers. Traditionally the Amidah is said
facing Jerusalem, and with the feet together. At four points near the
beginning and end it is customary to bow. When the Torah scroll is
130 The community
12 See further Samuel Krauss, ‘The Jewish Rite of Covering the Head’, Hebrew Union College Annual
19 (1945), pp. 121–68.
carried round the synagogue the worshippers turn so that they are
always facing it, and it is usual to touch it with a corner of the tallit which
is then kissed. The same gesture is made to the open scroll when one is
called up to the reading. When the scroll is elevated and displayed to the
congregation, some people raise an arm towards it, holding a corner of
the tallit. When the priests pronounce the priestly blessing they remove
their shoes, cover their heads and arms with the tallit, and hold their
fingers in a special way. Jews do not kneel, except that once a year, on
Yom Kippur, they kneel and prostrate themselves. These are the only
gestures normally practised in Jewish prayer, and in Reform services
even these are not usually seen, with the exception of standing, but in
very traditionalist circles some other gestures may be observed. Men
may cover their heads with the tallit to say their prayers. They may sway
their bodies backwards and forwards and bob their heads up and down.
This ancient practice is particularly practised by Hasidim.
The prayers are meant to be said with kavvanah, concentration or
intention. As one medieval writer, Bahya Ibn Pakuda, puts it, ‘prayer
without kavvanah is like a body without a soul’. How to achieve proper
kavvanah is a matter of debate. It is said that the pious men of old used
to meditate for an hour, then pray for an hour, then meditate for another
hour. The Hasidim are particular concerned with kavvanah. The founder
of Hasidism, the Baal Shem Tov, taught that one should say to oneself
before beginning to pray that one would be willing to die through powerful
concentration on the prayers. His own powers of concentration
were legendary. The early Hasidim felt that a major obstacle to concentration
on prayer was the requirement to pray at fixed times: they therefore
did away with fixed times, and encouraged people to pray when they
felt ready to do it with kavvanah, and for this they were severely criticised
by their opponents.
The Reformers were also concerned about the times of services, but
for a different reason, although in their way they were also in search of
kavvanah. Traditional services tended to start when there was a minyan,
and the principal services, on Sabbath and festival mornings, continued
for several hours. The Reformers insisted that services should commence
at the advertised time, and should not be too long. They pruned
away many of the hymns and readings that had found their way into the
liturgy over the centuries, and removed repetitions of prayers. In this
way they hoped to improve worshippers’ concentration and decorum,
and they also made room for the new synagogue music and for the clear
reading of prayers which in the traditional service had often been
The worship of the synagogue 131
mumbled in an undertone. The modern Orthodox service, as in so much
else, tends to represent a compromise between the style of traditional
and Reform worship, while Conservative synagogues, for their part, can
be situated between Orthodoxy and Reform.
The prescribed times for public worship correspond to the times when
sacrifices were offered in the Temple. The morning service, Shaharit,
corresponds to the daily dawn sacrifice, and on Sabbaths, New Moons
and festivals it is followed by an additional service, Musaf, corresponding
to the additional burnt offering on these days. The afternoon service
(Minhah) corresponds to the regular evening sacrifice; it may be said at
any time in the afternoon, and is sometimes held close to sunset and
joined to the evening service (Maariv), which itself may take place at any
time from sunset to dawn, but preferably before midnight. Maariv alone
has no temple ritual corresponding to it, and for that reason there is
some discussion in the literature as to whether it is strictly obligatory.
RELIGIOUS SERVICES
It is difficult to generalise about the structure and content of the regular
services, because since the beginning of the great movement of prayer
book reform in the early nineteenth century Jewish prayer books have
come to diverge considerably from one another (and even before that
time there were notable discrepancies). The divergences are particularly
noticeable in comparing translations, because while the Hebrew text
contained in each new prayer book represents a revision, often relatively
slight, of an earlier Hebrew text, the translations are often completely
new, and sometimes, for theological or aesthetic reasons, they are far
from being a word-for-word rendering of the Hebrew. In what follows,
I shall aim to describe the common basis of the majority of prayer
books, and shall translate the Hebrew as faithfully as is consistent with
the need to write fluent English. I shall point out the main differences
between the different movements. I shall also point out where services
for different occasions differ from each other. This is inevitably a very
complex and technical area, and the reader is advised to regard this
description as a very rough guide, and to refer to specific prayer books
for more detailed information. By way of illustration of some of the
difficulties, here are two passages from the regular prayers as they are
translated in current prayer books of two modernist movements,
Orthodoxy and British Reform.
The first example is taken from the second paragraph of the
132 The community
Amidah, which deals with the controversial topic of the resurrection of
the dead.
Singer’s Prayer Book (1992) (omitting some phrases that are added on
certain occasions in the year):
You, O Lord, are mighty for ever; You revive the dead; You have the power to
save . . . You sustain the living with lovingkindness, You revive the dead with
great mercy. You support the falling, heal the sick, set free the bound, and keep
faith with those that sleep in the dust. Who is like You, O Master of mighty
deeds? Who resembles You – a King who puts to death and restores to life, and
causes salvation to flourish? And You are sure to revive the dead. Blessed are
You – the Lord, who revives the dead.
Forms of Prayer (1977):
You, O Lord, are the endless power that renews life beyond death; You are the
greatness that saves. You care for the living with love. You renew life beyond
death with unending mercy. You support the falling and heal the sick. You free
prisoners, and keep faith with those who sleep in the dust. Who can perform
such mighty deeds, and who can compare with You – a king who brings death
and life, and renews salvation. You are faithful to renew life beyond death.
Blessed are You Lord, who renews life beyond death.
The second example is from the prayer called Aleynu, which comes
at the end of the service. Apart from the problem of finding appropriate
language to represent traditional views of the nature of the universe,
this prayer in its original form makes some Jews uncomfortable by its
negative and potentially offensive attitude to other religions.
Singer’s Prayer Book (1992):
It is our duty to praise the Lord of all, and to ascribe greatness of the Author
of Creation, who has not made us like the nations of the world, nor has placed
us like other families of the earth; who has not made our portion like theirs, nor
our destiny like that of all their multitude. Therefore we bend the knee, bow
down, and acknowledge before the supreme King of Kings, the Holy One,
blessed be He, that it is He who stretched out the heavens and founded the
earth, and set His glorious throne in the heavens above, and the abode of His
power in the loftiest heights. He is our God, there is no other. Truly, he is our
King, there is none besides Him, as it is written in His Torah: Now be sure, and
keep it in mind, the Lord alone is God, in the heavens above and on the earth
below; there is no other.
Forms of Prayer (1977):
It is our duty to praise the Lord of all, to recognise the greatness of the creator
of first things, who has chosen us from all people by giving us his Torah.
Religious services 133
Therefore we bow low and submit, and give thanks before the King above the
kings of kings, the Holy One, blessed be He. He extends the limits of space and
makes the world firm. His glory extends through the universe beyond, and the
presence of his strength into farthest space. He is our God; no other exists. Our
king is truth; the rest is nothing. It is written in His Torah: ‘Realise this today
and take it to heart – it is the Lord who is God in the heavens above and on the
earth beneath; no other exists.’
While some of the changes have clearly been made for aesthetic
reasons, because of the sound of the words (and we should bear in mind
that in Orthodox prayer books the translation is provided solely to help
worshippers to follow the meaning of the Hebrew, while in the more
liberal movements it may be read aloud, by the leader or by the congregation
in unison), other changes reflect differences in understanding the
facts of nature or the needs of the Jew at prayer.
The texts that make up the services may be classified under four headings
1. Biblical texts. First we may consider actual readings, when the text is
read aloud or cantillated, and the congregants listen. Blessings are
recited by the reader before and after these formal readings. The major
regular readings are on the morning of Sabbaths and festival days, when
passages from the Torah and the Prophets are read out. This reading
constitutes the central act of the services in question, and it is accompanied
with a certain amount of ceremonial. The passages from the Torah
are read from a handwritten scroll, which is solemnly taken out of the
ark and processed around the synagogue, and ‘undressed’ and held up
to view by two congregants publicly named for the purpose; other congregants
are honoured by being ‘called up’ to the reading. The prophetic
passage (Haftarah) is read from a printed book. There is short reading
from the Torah scroll as well on Sabbath afternoons and on Monday and
Thursday mornings, as well as on certain special days which are not full
festivals: New Moon, fast days, Hanukkah and Purim, and the intermediate
days of Sukkot and Passover. Apart from the scroll of the Torah,
there are five short books of the Bible that are known as scrolls and are
read on special days of the year: Song of Songs (Sabbath of Passover
week), Ruth (Shavuot), Lamentations (9th of Av),Kohelet or Ecclesiastes
(Sabbath of Sukkot week), Esther (Purim). Of these only Esther is normally
read from an actual scroll.
The ‘reading of the Shma’, although it is technically called a reading, is
in a different category from the readings just mentioned. It does not have
134 The community
to be read from a written text (in fact some devout Jews cover their eyes
when they recite the first verse, as an aid to concentration). Nor does it
require the presence of a congregation, as we saw in the previous chapter.
The reading is made up of three separate passages from the Torah:
Deuteronomy 6:4–9, Deuteronomy 11:13–21, and Numbers 15:37–41. The
Shma is a kind of profession of faith, and it is enormously important to
Jews. In addition to the full reading, in the evening and morning services,
the opening verse is recited on various other occasions in the services.
The biblical psalms figure prominently in the worship of the synagogue.
The Book of Psalms is not read in its entirety in the services,
although some pious Jews do read the whole book privately each week,
or even each day. Instead, particular psalms or sequences of psalms are
read at specific points in the service or on special occasions. For example,
Psalms 100 and 145–150 are said in the daily morning service; Psalms 19,
34, 90, 91, 135, 136, 33, 92, 93 and 145–150 (in that order) on Sabbath and
festival mornings; and in the conclusion of the morning service the
‘psalm of the day’ is recited, prefaced with the words ‘this is the . . . day
of the week, on which the Levites in the Temple used to say . . .’. On
Friday evening the Sabbath is welcomed with Psalms 95–99 and 29, a
custom introduced by the Safed kabbalists of the sixteenth century.
Psalms 145 and 24 (on weekdays) or 29 (on Sabbaths) is sung when the
scroll of the Torah is returned to the ark. A special liturgy of psalms
known as Hallel is sung on festival days: it consists of Psalms 113–118,
preceded and followed by a special blessing.
Other scriptural passages are included in the services. For example, 1
Chronicles 29:10–13, Nehemiah 9:6–11 and the ‘Song at the Sea’
(Exodus 14:30 to 15:19) are said after the main sequence of psalms in the
morning service, and some congregations follow the kabbalistic custom
of reciting the Song of Songs on Sabbath eve.
2. Blessings. Blessings or benediction (berakhot) play a large part in the
private devotional life of the Jew as well as in the worship of the synagogue.
Many of them were composed by the rabbis of the Talmud, and
the Amidah, which was composed at that time, consists of a series of
blessings. Liturgical blessings may be long or short, the short ones often
consisting of only a few words. Blessings begin in one of two ways,
‘Blessed are you, Lord, our God, King of the universe (or eternal King)’
or simply ‘Blessed are you, Lord.’ What follows this opening may be anything
from a long paean of praise to a short formula, often consisting of
only two words, identifying an aspect of God’s character or activity. A
Religious services 135
curiosity of these formulae is that they are frequently worded in the third
person, even though the introduction is in the second person. (For
example: ‘Blessed are you, Lord, who blesses His people Israel with
peace’.) The formulae are best understood as being in effect titles of
God, ‘resurrecter of the dead’, ‘clother of the naked’, ‘blesser of his
people’ and so forth. If the blessing is a long one it will often conclude
with a short blessing, summing up the message of the longer blessing.
This short blessing is known as a ‘seal’ (hatimah). A seal is frequently
found at the end of a prayer which does not begin as a blessing; in this
case the whole prayer is considered to be a blessing.
3. Other prayers. In the course of centuries new prayers have been composed,
in forms other than that of the blessing. We have already looked
at one of them, the Aleynu, which is said to have been composed in the
third century CE, but may well be even earlier. Traditional liturgies
contain many such prayers, and contemporary liturgies have displayed
considerable inventiveness in combining traditional forms of words with
new ideas. One feature these prayers have in common by and large is
that they are couched in the first person plural (unlike biblical prayers
which are generally personal): the community expresses its needs and
desires and its gratitude as a public body. With few exceptions, private
prayers have no place in the synagogue. In fact Jews are encouraged to
pray with the community in preference to praying alone. Maimonides
argues as follows:
Communal prayer is always hearkened to and even if there are sinners among
them the Holy One, blessed be He, does not reject the prayers of the many.
Consequently, a man should associate himself with the community and he
should not recite prayers in private when he is able to recite them together with
the community.3
4. Hymns. Jews love to sing their faith and their love of God. In the home
they do it in the table songs (Zemirot), and in the synagogue they do it
with hymns. The power of music in the synagogue is seen at its strongest
in the hymns. A firm favourite, of unknown authorship, is Adon Olam
(‘Eternal Lord’):
Eternal Lord, who reigned before any artifact was created.
When everything was made by his will he was already proclaimed King.
And when everything is ended he will still reign, alone and awesome.
136 The community
13 Code, Rules of Prayer 8:1, quoted from Jacobs, Religion and the Individual, p. 39, where the subject
is discussed further.
He was, he is, and he will be in splendour.
And he is One, and there is no second to liken or join to him.
Without beginning, without ending, he has power and dominion.
He is my God, my living Redeemer, my Rock, my life-line in time of distress,
He is my banner and my refuge, my cupful when I cry out.
Into his hand I entrust my spirit whether I sleep or wake,
And with my spirit my body too: the Lord is mine, and I am not afraid.
Other popular hymns are Ein Keloheinu (‘There is none like our God’),
Yigdal (‘Great is the living God’)4 and Lekha Dodi (‘Come beloved to meet
the bride’), the mystical welcome to the Sabbath bride composed by the
Safed kabbalist Solomon Alkabets in the wake of the expulsion from
Spain.
There are innumerable hymns, and their origins are diverse.5 A great
period of productivity was in Byzantine Palestine, in the fourth to
seventh centuries, and a second peak was reached in Muslim Spain, in
the tenth to twelfth centuries. Many hymns from both these periods
grace the traditional prayer books. Some of them are complex and allusive,
based on interwoven acrostics and replete with obscure allegorical
allusions. The Reformers were of the opinion that they cluttered and
choked the liturgy and were a major obstacle to understanding; they
freely pruned them out so as to restore the classical simplicity of the
prayers. Even Orthodox modernists were in favour of lightening the
service in this way, though they retained many of the old favourites, particularly
at Rosh Ha-Shanah and Yom Kippur, when there is less objection
to long services.
These are the main types of material that make up most of a Jewish
service. In addition, there are passages from other sources, for example
Orthodox prayer books insert passages from the Talmud, while Reform
prayer books include readings from a range of origins, including contemporary
literature.
All regular services actually have the same basic structure, which is
seen most simply and clearly in the weekday evening service. It consists
of: 1. An invocation to prayer; 2. the Shma and its blessings; 3. the
Amidah; 4. concluding prayers. Let us look at these four elements more
closely.
Religious services 137
14 See below, pp. 174‹5
15 For a full account see Leon J.Weinberger, Jewish Hymnography (London/Portland, Oregon, 1998).
1. An invocation to prayer. This is the same at all services. The reader says:
‘Bless the Lord who is to be blessed!’ and the congregants reply: ‘Blessed
be the Lord who is to be blessed for ever and ever!’
2. The Shma and its blessings. The text of the Shma itself (see above, p. 135)
is always the same. The blessings before and after it vary, however,
according to the time of day. In the evening there are two blessings
before the Shma. The first blesses God for making the evening: ‘He
causes the day to pass and brings on the night, and makes a distinction
between day and night.’ The second speaks of the great love of God for
the Jewish people, expressed in the giving of the Torah. (Both love and
Torah are themes of the Shma itself.) The blessings after the Shma
acknowledge God’s redemptive power, pray for shelter from the perils of
the night, and look forward to the coming of God’s kingdom.
3. The Amidah. The Amidah, always said standing, begins with an invocation
from Psalm 51:17: ‘O Lord, open my lips, that my mouth may
declare Your praise’. The body of the Amidah consists of a series of
nineteen blessings, of which the ‘seals’ (each of which, as observed
above, identifies a facet of God’s nature and activity) run as follows on
weekdays:
11. Shield of Abraham
12. Reviver of the dead
13. The holy God
14. Dispenser of knowledge
15. Desiring repentance
16. Generously forgiving
17. Redeemer of Israel
18. Healer of the sick of His people Israel
19. He who blesses the years
10. He who gathers in the dispersed of His people Israel
11. The king who loves righteousness and justice
12. He who breaks enemies and humbles the arrogant
13. The support and shelter of the righteous
14. Who rebuilds Jerusalem
15. Who makes the power of salvation spring up
16. He who hears prayer
17. He who restores His presence to Zion
18. Goodness is Your name, and to You it is fitting to give thanks
19. Who blesses His people Israel with peace.
138 The community
Taken together, this prayer, intimately familiar to religious Jews by
being repeated thrice daily, may be considered as a kind of Jewish creed.
Less philosophical than the Thirteen Principles of Maimonides, it distils
the essence of the biblical teachings about God, combining universal
aspects with those focused on the destiny of the people of Israel. Some
elements not represented in the ‘seals’ are woven into the body of the
blessings. Thus the first blessing, ‘Shield of Abraham’, declares that the
God of Abraham, Isaac and Jacob is also the most high God, the creator
of all things, and it looks forward to the coming of the redeemer. The
second blessing, ‘Reviver of the dead’, also mentions other aspects of
God’s beneficence: ‘supporter of the falling, healer of the sick, liberator
of captives’.
4. Concluding prayers. On weekday evenings these are normally very short,
beginning with the Aleynu, the prayer quoted earlier insisting that the
God acknowledged by the Jews is the universal and supreme God of all
humankind and indeed of the whole universe. A second prayer looks
forward to the coming of God’s kingdom, when (in the words of
Zechariah 14:9) ‘the Lord shall be one and His name one’. The service
is concluded by the mourner’s Kaddish, which continues the theme of
the kingdom of God. It is recited by mourners, the congregation
responding with a series of amens.
This basic structure underlies all services, evening, morning or afternoon
(with the omission of the Shma), whether on weekdays, Sabbath, or festival
days. There are variations, elaborations and additions, but they do
not disturb the orderly succession of these four elements. The longest
service of the day is the morning service, swollen further on Sabbaths
and festivals by the reading of the Torah followed by an additional
Amidah. The main outlines of a service for Sabbath morning are as
follows.
1. Blessings and prayers, followed by psalms and songs of praise.
2. The invocation, as above, followed by the Shma and its blessings. The
blessing for the evening is replaced by a morning blessing, addressed
to God ‘who forms light and creates darkness, makes peace and
creates all things’. There is only one blessing after the Shma, ‘who
has redeemed Israel’.
3. The Amidah. On Sabbath a special Amidah is recited, which has
seven blessings instead of the usual nineteen. The first three and
the last three are essentially the same, but instead of the thirteen
Religious services 139
blessings in the middle there is a single blessing, with the ‘seal’ ‘who
sanctifies the Sabbath’. Festival days have their own blessing instead,
naming the festival in question, and ending ‘who sanctifies (the
Sabbath and) Israel and the festive seasons’. It is customary for the
Amidah to be said twice, the first time silently by all and the second
time aloud by the reader alone. At the repetition a kedushah
(‘sanctification’) is inserted in the third blessing, describing the
worship of the angels who declare ‘Holy, holy, holy is the Lord of
Hosts, the whole world is full of His glory’ (Isaiah 6:3). Later the
reader also inserts the priestly blessing (Numbers 6:24–6). On festivals
and semi-festive days Hallel (Psalms 113–18) is added after the
Amidah.
4. The Reading of the Torah. The ark is opened and a scroll of the
Torah (or two, exceptionally three, depending on the number of
readings prescribed for the day) is removed. The scroll is carried in
procession round the synagogue, and taken to the reading desk,
where it is ‘undressed’, that is the silver ornaments and pointer, the
velvet mantle and the binder are removed. It is then unrolled a little
and held up so that the congregation can see the written words. (The
Sephardi custom is to display it before the reading; Ashkenazim do it
afterwards instead.) Members of the congregation are then ‘called
up’ by their Hebrew names, beginning with a priest and a Levite if
any are present. It is considered an honour to be called up. The
Torah is divided up into sections (each known as a parashah or among
Ashkenazim as a sidrah), and one of them is read each week, so that
the whole Torah is read in the space of a year. Each section is divided
into shorter readings according to the number of people to be called
up. The person called up recites a blessing before and after the
reading. In Reform and Liberal synagogues only a short portion of
each section is read. After the conclusion of the Torah reading the
scroll is rolled up and ‘dressed’. A Haftarah, a short portion from the
prophetic books, is read, preceded and followed by a special blessing.
Unlike the Torah, the Prophets are not read in their entirety, but only
in excerpts, chosen to suit the Torah readings they accompany.
Special prayers are then said, for the congregation, for the state and
its government, for the State of Israel, and before each month for
blessings during the coming month. The scroll is then processed once
more round the synagogue and replaced in the ark, with the words
‘Turn us back to Yourself, Lord, and we will return; renew our days
as of old.’ In some congregations there is a sermon at this point.
140 The community
5. Additional Amidah (Musaf). This is similar to the main Amidah.
Reform liturgies have tended to omit it.
6. Concluding hymns and prayers. The Aleynu is flanked by hymns. In
some congregations the Hymn of Glory, a breathtakingly anthropomorphic
love-song of rare obscurity, is sung by a small child before
the open ark. Various other additional psalms and readings may be
inserted, and in more traditional services the mourner’s Kaddish is
said not once but three times.
After the conclusion of the service it is customary to recite kiddush, the
blessing of the Sabbath, over wine and bread, and this provides an
opportunity for congregants to mingle and talk to one another. People
celebrating a happy event, such as a Bar Mitsvah, a wedding or some
other family celebration, will often provide more substantial refreshments.
THE CYCLE OF THE YEAR
Just as in the home so too in the synagogue the regular succession of
Sabbaths forms the backbone of the year, for it must be admitted that
weekday attendance is generally very small and many synagogues do not
even trouble to open their doors for weekday prayer. Sabbath services,
then, beat out the rhythm of the year, each Sabbath taking the name of
its designated Torah reading. In Orthodox synagogues the sunset
Sabbath eve service is short and almost perfunctory, since Sabbath eve
is considered to be a family celebration for which the most fitting place
is the home, and the main emphasis falls on the morning service, with
its Torah reading, its sermon and its kiddush. Many non-Orthodox synagogues,
however, lay greater stress on Friday evening in the synagogue.
It was the great American reformer I. M. Wise, in the nineteenth
century, who took the step of holding a Friday evening service at a fixed
time later in the evening, giving families time to eat together at home
first. There being no reason to hurry this service, it may be enhanced by
a Torah reading or a sermon or a lecture, and may be followed by a
social get-together. But if the heart of the synagogue beats to the regular
rhythm of the Sabbaths, it gives an extra leap of joy on festival days and
whenever private celebrations occur.
The major festivals in the synagogue are similar to those in the home,
but they are celebrated differently. The great days are the Days of Awe
or High Holy Days in the autumn, Rosh Ha-Shanah (New Year) and
Yom Kippur (Day of Atonement). On these days the attendance at the
The cycle of the year 141
synagogue is swollen out of all proportion to the regular congregation.
This raises an awkward problem whenever a synagogue is built: should
it be built to accommodate the High Holy Day congregation, at great
expense and at the risk of seeming vast and empty throughout the year,
or should it be built with the normal Sabbath attendance in mind, necessitating
the hiring of premises for ‘overflow’ services once a year? Each
congregation solves the problem in its own way; many opt for a compromise:
a large building divided by movable partitions, providing classrooms
and meeting rooms whenever the large prayer hall is not required.
If the individual Jew needs to prepare inwardly by self-searching, penitence
and prayer for the day of judgment which is Rosh Ha-Shanah,
the synagogue too needs to prepare. The usual black vestments and the
velvet hangings and Torah mantles are replaced with white ones. Some
congregations need to hire additional readers for the overflow services,
and there are many tasks that need to be allocated. The Days of Awe
have their own special melodies, which readers must learn if necessary
and choirs rehearse. A mood of activity and a sense of expectation
infects the congregation.
The morning service for Rosh Ha-Shanah is a long one, and it is
marked by a unique and unforgettable sound, the eerie and jubilant cry
of the shofar, the ram’s horn. The holiday is described in the Torah as a
day of blowing the horn (teru‘ah) (Leviticus 23:24; Numbers 29:1), and
although a horn from any kosher animal may be used preference is given
to a ram’s horn because of the symbolism of the ram that was sacrificed
in place of Isaac in Genesis 22, which is one of the readings for the festival.
There is no prescribed size or shape for the shofar: some are short
and crescent-shaped, others are long and straight with an upward turn
at the end, while others spiral exuberantly. It takes a certain amount of
skill to produce a fluent sound, and good shofar-blowers are in demand
at this time of the year. Different reasons are given for the blowing of the
shofar, some of which are alluded to in the liturgy, which cites a series of
biblical verses referring to the shofar. Maimonides offers a striking explanation
in his Code:
It seems to say: Awake, you sleepers, you who have fallen asleep in life, and
reflect upon your deeds. Remember your Creator. Do not be among those who
miss reality and pursue shadows instead, who waste their years seeking after
vain things that neither benefit nor save them. Look well to your souls, and
improve your deeds. Forsake every one of you your evil ways and thoughts.
This view is well suited to the mood of the liturgy for the festival,
which lays a strong emphasis on repentance and self-improvement.
142 The community
Yom Kippur is the grandest and most solemn day in the calendar of
the synagogue, and this is the day when synagogues are full to
overflowing. (There is a popular expression ‘a Yom Kippur Jew’,
meaning one who attends synagogue only once a year.) In older times
some Jews remained in the synagogue from the beginning of the fast
until the end, twenty-five hours later. Nowadays there is a break for the
night, and it is common to have a short interval in the afternoon as well.
On Yom Kippur, as at the Passover seder, some Jews still observe the
old custom of wearing the kittel, the plain white tunic in which they will
be buried. Franz Rosenzweig has this commentary on the symbolism of
this practice: ‘Man is utterly alone on the day of his death, when he is
clothed in his shroud, and in the prayers of these days he is also alone.
They too set him, lonely and naked, straight before the throne of God.’6
The opening service is the only really substantial evening service in
the traditional synagogue, and the only one when men wear the tallit. It
begins with a declaration known as Kol Nidrei, sung in Aramaic to a
haunting melody. The effect of the Kol Nidrei is to announce that all
religious vows made during the coming year are not to be considered
binding. The reason for the declaration is wrapped in obscurity, and it
has given rise to various misunderstandings which led to its being
omitted from some Reform liturgies. However, in most synagogues it has
not only held its own but stamps the services with its own unique character,
indeed the eve of Yom Kippur is popularly called ‘Kol Nidrei
night’.
Repentance (teshuvah) is the keynote of the Yom Kippur liturgy, and
the five services all culminate in a detailed and comprehensive public
confession of sins. The prayers dwell on the awesome majesty of God,
who is a judge with the power to sentence to death, yet who is also compassionate
to those who sincerely repent. One of the most moving
prayers is the unetanneh tokef, composed under the Byzantine Empire but
associated by legend with a martyr rabbi named Amnon of Mainz, who
after being tortured during the Crusades was carried dying into the synagogue,
and expired while reciting this prayer:
We evoke the solemn holiness of this day, for it is a day of awe and terror. On
it your dominion is exalted, your throne is established with love, and you sit
upon it with truth. Truly you are the only judge, arbiter and all-knowing witness,
you inscribe and seal, you enumerate and reckon, you recall all that is forgotten,
you open the book of memorial and it recites itself, and the seal of every
human hand is upon it. A great shofar is sounded, a still small voice is heard, the
The cycle of the year 143
16 Franz Rosenzweig, The Star of Redemption, tr. W. W. Hallo (London/New York, 1970), p. 327.
angels are dismayed, seized with fear and trembling, and they say, This is the
Day of Judgment: the army of heaven is to be inspected and judged. For even
they cannot be justified in your judgment. As for dwellers on earth, you pass
them all before you in their ranks. As a shepherd inspects his flock, passing them
beneath his crook, so do you pass and count and reckon, inspecting every living
soul, determining the measure of every created being, and writing down their
decreed sentence.
On Rosh Ha-Shanah it is inscribed, and on the fast of Yom Kippur it is
sealed: how many shall pass away and how many shall be created; who shall live
and who shall die, who at his appointed time, and who before it, who by fire and
who by water, who by the sword and who by the wild beast, who by hunger and
who by thirst, who by earthquake and who by plague, who by strangling and
who by stoning, who shall have rest and who shall roam, who shall be calm and
who shall be tormented, who shall be tranquil and who shall be afflicted, who
shall become poor and who shall become rich, who shall be brought low and
who shall be raised up.
BUT PENITENCE, PRAYER AND CHARITY MAY AVERT THE SEVERITY
OF THE SENTENCE.
Many other solemn prayers and hymns reiterate the same themes,
dwelling on the power and justice of God and also on his compassion
and openness to prayer. All the great hymnographers have contributed
compositions to the liturgy. One of the loveliest is Mi yitneni (‘O would
that I might be . . .’), by the medieval Spanish poet Judah Hallevi, of
which this is an extract:
If in my youth I still
Fail to perform Thy will,
What can I hope when age shall chill my breast?
Heal me, O Lord! with Thee is healing found–
Cast me not off, by weight of years oprest,
Forsake me not when age my strength has bound.
O! would that I might be
A servant unto Thee,
Thou God, by all adored.
Then, though by friends out-cast,
Thy hand would hold me fast,
And draw me near to Thee, my King and Lord!7
Of all the poetic compositions few can compare with the Keter malkhut
(‘Royal crown’) of Solomon Ibn Gabirol, which is printed in Sephardi
prayer books, and is still recited in part in the British Reform rite, which
is based on the Sephardi tradition. In North African communities it is
144 The community
17 Translated by Mrs Henry Lucas (Alice Lucas), Songs of Zion by Hebrew Singers of Mediaeval Times
(London, 1894), pp. 10–11.
chanted around dawn, before the morning service begins. Keter malkhut
is a magnificent meditation on the wonders of nature and the greatness
of God, the frailty of human beings and their need for penitence, blending
biblical Hebrew allusions with themes borrowed from Neoplatonist
philosophy, and counts among the great Hebrew poems of all times.8
A unique element in the Yom Kippur liturgy is the so-called Avodah,
the re-enactment of the Temple worship in the course of the Additional
Service (Musaf ). This was the holiest day in the year of the Temple,
because on this day the High Priest, after suitable ablutions and
purifications, entered the Holy of Holies and pronounced the ineffable
name of God, the name that was so holy that its pronunciation eventually
died out. When he said the name all the people who heard him fell
on their faces, and it is still the custom in some congregations for the worshippers
to kneel and prostrate themselves on this occasion. This is the
only occasion when a Jew is permitted to kneel. ‘And he does not kneel
to confess a fault or to pray for forgiveness of sins, acts to which this festival
is primarily dedicated. He kneels only in beholding the immediate
nearness of God.’9 This service also contains a martyrology, calling to
mind the martyrs who perished under the Roman emperor Hadrian and
at various later times, such as during the first crusade. Some modern liturgies
have introduced references to the martyrs of the Nazi holocaust
at this point.
The special feature of the Afternoon Service is the reading of the
Book of Jonah as the Haftarah. The message of the book is that repentance
averts the evil decree, even for a whole city of wrongdoers like
Nineveh.
The Concluding Service (Neilah) is unique to this day. Its Hebrew
name means ‘closing of the gate’, because this was the time when the
gates were locked in the Temple. As the sun begins to go down the mood
of the prayers changes, and a tone of confidence and hope enters the
words and melodies. In the Sephardi liturgy the service begins with a
beautiful hymn by Moses Ibn Ezra, El nora ‘alilah, which is sung to a spirited,
almost bouncy tune: ‘O God, awesome in deeds, grant us pardon
at the hour of Neilah.’
The climax is reached at the end of Neilah, as the end of the day
approaches. The whole congregation proclaims in a loud voice the first
sentence of the Shma: ‘Hear O Israel, the Lord our God, the Lord is
One!’, then three times: ‘Blessed be the name of His glorious reign for
The cycle of the year 145
18 It is translated by Raphael Loewe in his book Ibn Gabirol (London, 1989) and by Bernard Lewis,
The Kingly Crown (London, 1961). 19 Rosenzweig, The Star of Redemption, p. 323.
ever and ever’, and finally seven times ‘The Lord, He is God. The Lord,
He is God.’ After the regular evening service and the havdalah, the
marking of the distinction between holy day and weekday, a single long
blast is sounded on the shofar and people disperse to break their fast in
their homes.
Only a few days later the community reassembles to celebrate Sukkot
(Booths, or Tabernacles). ‘Although the Feast of Booths celebrates
redemption and rest, it is nevertheless the festival of wandering through
the wilderness’,10 and the symbol of this wandering is the booth itself,
the sukkah. Such a visible sign of the festival in the home, a sukkah is also
built in the grounds of the synagogue. But the real mark of Sukkot in
the synagogue is the taking of the four species. The Torah states: ‘You
shall take on the first day the fruit of goodly trees, branches of palm
trees, boughs of thick trees, and willows of the brook, and you shall
rejoice before the Lord your God for seven days’ (Leviticus 23:40). The
four species in question are identified as citron (etrog), palm, myrtle and
willow, and ‘taking’ is understood literally as picking them up. A palm
frond, three sprigs of myrtle and two of willow are bound together and
held in the right hand, and the lemon-like fruit of the citron is taken in
the left, and they are waved up, down, and to the four points of the
compass after the recitation of an appropriate blessing. The four species
are also carried in procession around the synagogue, accompanied by
the singing of ‘Hosannas’ (hoshanot), petitions for salvation. On the
seventh day of the festival seven circuits are made, which is why this day
is known as the Great Hoshana (Hoshana Rabbah). Some Jews still
observe the custom of beating a bunch of willow sprigs until the leaves
come off.
The eighth day of the festival is called Shemini Atseret, usually translated
as ‘Eighth Day of Solemn Assembly’. This day is chosen to mark
the liturgical transition from summer to winter, and in the Additional
Service (Musaf ) prayers for rain are recited before the open ark. The
concluding words of the prayer, ‘causing the wind to blow and the rain
to fall’, are added to every Amidah from now until Passover.
The last day of this autumn festive season is Simhat Torah, ‘Rejoicing
in the Torah’. In Israel and in Reform synagogues this coincides with
Shemini Atseret, but other diaspora congregations celebrate it on the
following day. This is the day when the annual reading of the Torah is
concluded and resumes again immediately at the beginning. It is a time
146 The community
10 Ibid., p. 321.
of joyful celebration, no doubt occasioned partly by the fact that it marks
the end of a very long period of solemnities and festivities, when it is
natural to let off steam. All the scrolls are taken out of the ark and processed
around the synagogue seven times, accompanied by singing and
dancing. Members of the congregation are honoured by being called up
to be the ‘Bridegroom of the Torah’ (Hatan Torah) and the ‘Bridegroom
of Bereshit [Genesis]’ (Hatan Bereshit), but in some synagogues all the
congregants are called up, and it is also customary to call up the children,
the only day in the year when they are called up to the Torah. The
children are given sweets and apples, and they process behind the Torah
waving appropriately decorated flags. The two ‘bridegrooms’ (who in
progressive congregations may be ‘brides’) make a party for the whole
congregation.
The other festive days cannot really compete with the powerful and
contrasting moods of the autumn festivals. Passover and Shavuot have
special liturgies, as do all the special days of the year, and there is a
custom of decorating the synagogue with greenery at Shavuot, although
some rabbis have opposed it on the grounds that it seems to be an imitation
of a Christian harvest festival. At Purim the scroll of Esther is read
both in the evening and in the morning; those present, especially children,
make a loud noise with rattles whenever the name of the wicked
Haman, the persecutor of the Jews, is mentioned in the reading. On the
fast day of the 9th of Av, the commemoration of the destruction of the
Temple, the synagogue takes on an air of gloom. Joyful prayers are
omitted; darkness reigns, and worshippers avoid sitting on chairs, like
mourners. The tallit and tefillin are not put on in the morning; dirges
(kinnot) are sung, and the book of Lamentations is chanted to a mournful
melody.
MOMENTS OF LIFE
These are the special observances, solemn and lighthearted, that mark
the rhythm of the synagogue’s life year on year. Ceremonies of a
different kind punctuate the year, beating time to the pulse of each
family, and sharing with them in the joys and griefs of each member. In
a small, closely knit community the boundary between synagogue and
home is narrow and ill-defined. Members share each other’s happiness
and sorrow, gathering spontaneously for a circumcision, a burial or a
Shivah. A larger congregation tends to be more impersonal, but even
here the community enfolds its members in warmth and affection, as
Moments of life 147
when parents come to give thanks on the birth of a child, or when a
bridegroom is called up before his wedding, or when a mourner is welcomed
into the synagogue and the congregation respond ‘amen’ as he
recites the Kaddish. In many congregations the names of departed
family members are read out during the memorial prayers on Yom
Kippur. As we have seen, circumcision and marriage may be performed
in synagogue, which may also be deemed the appropriate place for the
eulogy on the death of a distinguished member.
The regular services provide an opportunity for private events to be
mentioned: after a member of the congregation is called up to the Torah
a blessing known as misheberakh is said, beginning ‘May He who blessed
our ancestors Abraham, Isaac and Jacob bless. . .’. (Egalitarian versions
of the prayer also exist, naming matriarchs as well as patriarchs.) Such
events as the birth of a child, a wedding, or even nowadays a silver or
golden wedding or a seventieth or eightieth birthday, may be mentioned,
and this is also a point in the service where prayers may be offered for
someone who is ill. Charitable donations may be made at this point,
although some synagogues discourage the practice as confusing the
material and the spiritual, and encouraging unseemly and invidious displays
of wealth or generosity. If the person called up has been in grave
danger, during a journey or illness for example, he may say a special
blessing known as gomel: ‘Blessed are You, Lord our God, king of the universe,
who bestows favours on the undeserving, for he has favoured me
with such great good.’
The gomel may also be said by a mother coming to the synagogue for
the first time after giving birth. The baby may be brought, to be blessed
by the rabbi. In Reform synagogues the baby will now receive its Hebrew
name.
The passage from childhood to adulthood is marked in synagogue, by
what has come to be known as the Bar Mitsvah or Bat Mitsvah ceremony.
This is a joyful moment for the community as well as for the
family, and it is usual for the parents to invite the whole congregation to
join the family for a celebration after the service. The Bar Mitsvah ceremony
as we know it is not of great antiquity, and belongs to the realm
of custom rather than ordinance. On reaching the age of thirteen a boy
becomes technically subject to the commandments, but no particular
action or observance is laid down in this connection. It was apparently
in medieval Germany that it was decided to mark the occasion by calling
him up to the Torah, and having a party at which he made a speech, displaying
such learning as he had mastered. This is the basis of the present
148 The community
practice. The boy attends synagogue with his parents, and chants or
reads a portion from the Torah and the Haftarah. There is a special
blessing to be pronounced by his father: ‘Blessed be He who has freed
me from the responsibility of this [child].’ The idea is that hitherto he
was responsible for any wrongdoing committed by his son, who from
now on will take responsibility for his own actions. The rabbi will address
the boy, exhorting him to be a loyal and steadfast Jew. It is usual for the
Bar Mitsvah to take place on Sabbath; it may also occur on a Monday
or Thursday (the other days when the Torah is read), in which case the
boy will put on tefillin for the first time.
Since in traditional synagogues girls were not called up to the Torah,
and indeed played no part in the life of the synagogue, no such ceremony
was devised for them, and some Orthodox rabbis today object to
any kind of Bat Mitsvah ceremony on the grounds that it is untraditional.
Some Orthodox congregations have a special weekday service at
which a number of girls who have reached the legal age of twelve recite
biblical texts and prayers; others permit a Bat Mitsvah to deliver an
address during the Sabbath service. In Conservative and Reform synagogues
girls read from the Torah just as boys do.
The Bar Mitsvah ceremony has been under attack for a long time,
because thirteen seems a very early age for a boy to become a man, and
indeed many boys at this age hardly seem mature enough to appreciate
the responsibilities they are supposed to be undertaking. Only rarely do
Bar Mitsvah boys have sufficient Jewish education to be aware of a
respectable number of the 613 commandments of the Torah, and those
who do may very well not have much general ethical and religious education.
By the beginning of the nineteenth century in Germany a
confirmation ceremony had been introduced, at which the rabbi asked
the boy to give well-rehearsed answers to questions about such subjects
as belief in God, and then to recite Maimonides’ Thirteen Principles.
Large numbers of Jewish catechisms were published, both in Hebrew
and in German, and the emphasis was on general rather than
specifically Jewish principles. The influence of the Christian environment
is obvious, and this new ceremony was objected to by some who
felt it went too far towards imitating the Church, and pointed out that
Judaism does not have a creed, so that catechising is not strictly appropriate.
Nevertheless, confirmation became an established feature of
Reform Judaism, being made available to girls as well as boys, and
spreading to America, where it gradually replaced the Bar Mitsvah. The
age of confirmation also rose, from thirteen to fifteen or sixteen. This
Moments of life 149
was connected to a notable emphasis on Jewish education in American
Reform Judaism in the years between the two World Wars.
Confirmation at a later age meant that young people were better prepared,
in terms both of knowledge and of religious and moral maturity.
It also provided an answer to one of the other worrying features of early
Bar Mitsvah: in the absence of any subsequent educational goals, teenagers
tend to abandon their Jewish education and indeed to drift away
from the synagogue. Meanwhile, all denominations of Judaism have
tried to remedy the educational problems associated with Bar Mitsvah
by insisting on a certain level of synagogue attendance and educational
attainment beforehand, and by trying to encourage commitment afterwards
in various ways.
OTHER COMMUNAL INSTITUTIONS
We cannot take leave of the Jewish community before taking a look at
some of its other institutions besides the synagogue. In the days of the
ghetto each community maintained a number of individuals and teams
of people and various buildings set aside for specific functions: schools;
kosher butchers; a bakery making bread, and hallah for Sabbaths and festivals;
a matsah bakery for Passover; a mikveh (bath-house); a mohel (circumciser),
and a sofer (scribe) to write mezuzot and tefillin as well as Torah
scrolls and other texts.
Little survives now from all of this, except in the larger traditional
Jewish communities. There are still kosher butchers, but many kosher
products are mass-produced, and most matsot come from a few large factories.
One has to look quite hard to find a mohel or a sofer. Mikvaot are
few and far between, although they have undergone a certain revival in
some places recently. On the other hand there has been a proliferation
of youth groups, attached to synagogues or to national or international
youth organisations.
The one area which still attracts a large investment of effort and
money is education, whether for children or for adults. Jewish education
is no longer an orderly progression from elementary schooling for children
to advanced studies for adults. So neglected was religious education
during the emancipation period, and so disrupted was it by pogroms
and migrations, that many otherwise well-educated adult Jews feel that
in terms of Jewish knowledge they are infants. Education fights therefore
on two fronts. Children are taught in Sunday schools, evening
classes, and increasingly also in day schools. (The age of the Jewish
150 The community
boarding school seems to be past.) Adults can choose from a range of
evening classes and other educational options, including residential
courses and Jewish options in universities and colleges. Rabbinic seminaries
tend to offer courses for the wider public, and are blurring the distinction
between seminary and university. The content of all these
classes ranges from traditional options such as biblical and Talmudic
study to historical and social studies and languages (not only Hebrew, but
Yiddish and Judaeo-Spanish too).
The training of rabbis takes place in a rabbinic seminary, or (for the
traditional sector) in a yeshivah. Graduating rabbis are employed by synagogues,
or serve the community in some other capacity. Some will
become teachers. And some will end up sitting on a Bet Din, a rabbinical
court. The full range of activities of a Bet Din embrace dispensing
justice according to the code of rabbinic law in all its aspects, as well as
supervising the rules of holiness and purity. (It is the Bet Din that stamps
kosher foodstuffs with its seal of approval and licences kosher butchers,
caterers and restaurants.) Since in practice, however, outside Israel the
Jewish courts have very limited jurisdiction, in practice most their work
is concerned with matters of personal status, such as divorce and conversion.
A Bet Din consists of three rabbis; a rabbi acting as a judge is
termed a dayyan. Formerly dayyanim, like rabbis, were always males, but
now that the Conservative and Reform movements have women rabbis,
they have women judges too.
One institution of the medieval community still plays the same role as
it always has done: the cemetery. Jewish cemeteries are set apart by a wall
or hedge, and are treated with great respect. In the matter of tombstones
Sephardi and Ashkenazi practice differs sharply: Ashkenazi graves have
a standing headstone while Sephardi graves are covered with a stone
lying flat. The stones carry an inscription in Hebrew or the vernacular,
or both. Occasionally one will see a grave marked ‘genizah’: this is where
discarded holy books are buried. Jewish gravestones are normally
simple, without elaborate carvings. Flowers are not placed on the coffin
or on graves; people who visit a grave will often place a small stone on it
to mark their visit.
Jewish tradition teaches that the dead must be buried as soon as possible,
usually within twenty-four hours, unless death has taken place
on the eve of Sabbath or a festival, or if there is a particular reason to
postpone the burial, for example to wait for relatives and friends to
arrive from far away, or if suitable shrouds or a coffin are not available.
Traditionally, Jews buried their dead, and did not countenance
Other communal institutions 151
cremation. Cremation became popular in the late nineteenth century,
and Reform Judaism has no strong objection to it, but it is frowned on
in Conservative Judaism and forbidden in Orthodoxy. In Britain the
Orthodox authorities permit the ashes of someone who has been cremated
to be buried in a Jewish cemetery, provided the ashes are placed
in a normal coffin. Elsewhere some Orthodox rabbis do not even permit
this.
Before the body is placed in the coffin it is cleaned and ritually
washed. This is often done by members of a special society, the Hevrah
Kadisha (‘Holy Society’). To assist in the burial of the dead is a valuable
service and a sacred duty, and it is considered an honour to belong to a
Hevrah Kadisha. Separate teams attend to male and female corpses, out
of respect for the deceased, and throughout the washing great care is
taken to maintain due respect. The body remains covered at all times.
After the body has been carefully washed the ‘purification’ (taharah) is
performed, by pouring a quantity of water over it. The body is then
dried and dressed in a special set of clothes (takhrikhim), which are the
same for everybody, without distinction of wealth, status or learning.
They are made of white muslin, cotton or linen, and are made and put
on without any knots. If a man has his own kittel, the tunic which is sometimes
worn on Yom Kippur and at the Passover seder, it forms part of
the takhrikhim, and a man is also wrapped in his tallit (prayer shawl), which
has had the tassels (tsitsit) removed. A little earth from the Holy Land is
sprinkled on the body, and it is placed in a plain coffin which is then
sealed: it is not the custom to display the body to view, nor is the application
of cosmetics allowed.
The funeral is known as levayah, ‘accompanying’. It is considered a
duty to accompany the dead, and a mark of respect which is all the more
commendable as the recipient is unable to reciprocate. Prayers are said
at home before proceeding to the cemetery, where further prayers are
said in a hall or chapel, and a eulogy praising the deceased’s virtues and
accomplishments may be delivered. Nowadays a rabbi often officiates at
a funeral, but there is no requirement to have a rabbi present: like
officiating at marriages, this development is an example of the adaptation
of the functions of a rabbi to those of a Christian minister or priest.
Pallbearers, or relatives and friends, carry the coffin from the chapel to
the grave, pausing seven times on the way. The coffin is lowered into the
grave, and immediate relatives, followed by the rest of those present,
shovel some earth onto it.Worn-out Bibles, prayer books and other texts
containing the divine name may be buried in the grave, or they may be
152 The community
placed in a grave of their own, since they too are to be disposed of
respectfully and not simply jettisoned.
After burial the mourners recite the prayer known as Kaddish. This
prayer contains no mention of death or of grief, but is a glorification of
God and a prayer for the coming of his reign on earth. The recitation
of this prayer by mourners, both at the cemetery and subsequently, represents
an act of submission to the divine will on the part of mourners,
and is popularly thought to bring merit to the soul of the departed. This
is one of the practices (like attendance at the Passover seder and Yom
Kippur services) that are observed by large numbers of Jews who do not
otherwise observe many religious rituals.
Before the mourners leave the cemetery, they are greeted with these
words of condolence: ‘May God comfort you together with all those who
mourn for Zion and Jerusalem.’ It is customary to wash the hands before
leaving the cemetery.
The consecration of the tombstone generally takes place either a
month or a year after burial, depending on local custom, with a simple
ceremony. Thereafter it is customary for relatives to visit the grave on the
anniversary of the death, during the month before Rosh Ha-Shanah, or
at any other time they choose.
In some countries there is a custom, going back to the Middle Ages,
of visiting the tombs of individuals reputed for their piety or learning as
a sign of respect or to offer up prayers. This custom is particularly
strongly established in Morocco and other parts of North Africa, where
it is not confined to Jews: in fact Jews, Muslims and Christians visit each
others’ shrines. In Poland the Hasidim developed the custom of visiting
the tombs of their rebbes on the anniversary of their deaths. In the
Middle East, particularly in Israel, Iraq and Iran, the tombs of biblical
patriarchs and prophets attract pilgrims, and the kabbalists of Safed
identified tombs of famous ancient rabbis all over Galilee. All these sites
are visited by pilgrims, particularly kabbalists and Hasidim. The annual
pilgrimage to the supposed tomb of Simeon bar Yohai at Meron has
already been mentioned, and a new pilgrimage has been introduced, to
the tomb of a modern North African saint called Baba Sali at Netivot.
Such observances, however, are completely unknown in the West.
Besides the specific responsibilities of children towards their parents,
the whole community has a responsibility towards those of its members
who are in distress, whether through poverty, ill-health, mental anguish
or old age. Every congregation has charities that administer funds for the
benefit of the poor, the sick and the elderly, and there are generally
Other communal institutions 153
panels of members who share in visiting the sick. It is now common in
western countries for the Jewish community to make its contribution also
to charities benefiting the wider community.
In these various ways the Jewish communities, even in places where
they constitute a tiny minority, proudly and loyally maintain their individual
identity and their ancient traditions.
x
Comentarios
Publicar un comentario